It was 2010. Harmonix was basically at the peak of its powers. If you walked into a Best Buy back then, you’d see a plastic graveyard of fake guitars, but Rock Band 3 songs were about to change the conversation entirely. Most people remember the peripherals—the crazy Pro Keyboard, the Fender Mustang with 102 buttons, the MIDI adapters. But if you strip away the plastic and the tech, what’s left is arguably the most cohesive, diverse, and well-curated setlist in the history of the rhythm genre.
Honestly, it wasn’t just a game. It was a music education.
While Guitar Hero was busy leaning into the "shred-til-you-die" aesthetic, Rock Band 3 took a hard pivot toward variety. It was the first time we saw a massive inclusion of keys, which meant the tracklist had to accommodate more than just power chords. We’re talking about a lineup that put Huey Lewis and the News right next to Anthrax. It sounds like a mess on paper. In practice? It was brilliant.
Why the Rock Band 3 songs selection felt so curated
Most rhythm games feel like a "Greatest Hits" compilation you’d buy at a gas station. You know the vibe—just the radio edits everyone knows. But Harmonix didn't do that. They went for deep cuts and tracks that actually felt fun to play, not just listen to. When you look at the 83-song setlist, there’s a specific flow to it.
You’ve got the heavy hitters. "Bohemian Rhapsody" by Queen is the obvious crown jewel here. Before RB3, if you wanted to play Queen, you were usually stuck with "We Will Rock You." Getting the full, multi-track master for "Bohemian Rhapsody" was a massive deal for the community. It wasn't just about the novelty; it was about the vocal harmonies. Rock Band 3 introduced triple-part harmonies, which meant you and two friends could finally live out your Wayne’s World dreams in the living room without sounding (entirely) like dying cats.
But then they’d hit you with something like "The Hardest Button to Button" by The White Stripes. Simple? Yeah. Fun? Absolutely. It’s that balance between the technical wizardry of DragonForce and the raw, garage-rock energy of Jack White that kept the game from feeling like a chore.
The Keyboard Revolution
We have to talk about the keys. Adding a 25-key controller meant the developers had to source music where the piano wasn't just a background texture. This gave us "Low Rider" by War and "Werewolves of London" by Warren Zevon. It changed the DNA of the game. Suddenly, you weren't just a wannabe Slash; you were Ben Folds.
💡 You might also like: Why Batman Arkham City Still Matters More Than Any Other Superhero Game
- "Imagine" - John Lennon: A bold choice for a "party" game, but it worked because it grounded the experience.
- "Roundabout" - Yes: A prog-rock masterpiece that tested whether your fingers could actually move that fast on a keyboard.
- "Saturday Night's Alright for Fighting" - Elton John: High energy, complex, and iconic.
The transition to Pro Mode was the real kicker. Harmonix wanted to teach people how to actually play instruments. If you flipped on Pro Keys, you were playing the actual notes. It wasn't just a game anymore; it was a glorified tutor. This is why Rock Band 3 songs have such a high "re-playability" factor. You could master the Five-Button version, then spend six months failing at the Pro version.
The Weird, The Wild, and The "Wait, This is in Here?"
One of the most underrated parts of the RB3 experience was the inclusion of songs that felt like "inside jokes" for music nerds. Take "Llama" by Phish. If you play drums, you know. It’s a relentless, high-speed jazz-fusion-infused nightmare that leaves your forearms feeling like they’re made of lead.
Then you have "Jerry Was a Race Car Driver" by Primus. Les Claypool’s bass lines are notoriously difficult to translate to a controller, but they nailed the "thump" and the weirdness of it. It’s these kinds of inclusions that proved the developers actually cared about the culture of music, not just the charts. They weren't just looking for Billboard 100 hits; they were looking for songs with character.
Breaking down the genre spread
If you look at the data—and people have, extensively—the genre spread in Rock Band 3 is wider than any of its predecessors.
- New Wave: Devo, The B-52's, and Blondie.
- Metal: Avenged Sevenfold, Dio, and Ozzy Osbourne.
- Grunge/Alt: Jane’s Addiction, Soundgarden, and Stone Temple Pilots.
- Pop: Amy Winehouse and Phoenix.
It’s that mix. You could go from the soulful "Rehab" to the shred-heavy "Rainbow in the Dark." It kept the fatigue at bay. You didn't get bored because the gameplay loop was constantly shifting its requirements of you.
The Licensing Nightmare and the "Exports"
If you’re a die-hard fan, you know the real value of Rock Band 3 wasn't just the 83 songs on the disc. It was the fact that it acted as a "hub" for every other song you owned. Through the export system, you could bring in tracks from Rock Band 1, Rock Band 2, Lego Rock Band, and Green Day: Rock Band.
📖 Related: Will My Computer Play It? What People Get Wrong About System Requirements
By the time the DLC library hit its stride, you could have over 2,000 songs accessible in one menu. But there's a catch. Licensing is a fickle beast. Over the years, songs have "delisted" due to expiring contracts. If you didn't buy "Run to the Hills" by Iron Maiden or certain Fleetwood Mac tracks years ago, you're basically out of luck now. This has turned the original Rock Band 3 songs list into a bit of a time capsule.
The "Rock Band Network" also allowed independent artists to put their music in the game. It was a democratic era for music gaming. You could find obscure death metal bands or weird indie projects that never would have made it onto a Guitar Hero disc. It made the game feel alive, like a living, breathing record store.
The Technical Mastery of the Setlist
Let's get nerdy for a second. The way these songs were mapped—the "charting"—was a massive step up. In earlier games, sometimes the notes felt a bit "off," like they were trying to fill space. In RB3, the charts felt more musical. They captured the vibe of the performance.
Take "The Beast and the Harlot" by Avenged Sevenfold. The drum chart is a legendary test of coordination. It’s not just about hitting things hard; it’s about the syncopation. On the flip side, "I Need to Know" by Tom Petty and the Heartbreakers is a masterclass in "less is more." It’s simple, but every note feels intentional.
What most people get wrong about the RB3 soundtrack
There’s this common misconception that Rock Band 3 was "too soft" compared to the earlier games. People saw the keyboard and the "Imagine" trailer and thought Harmonix had gone "pop."
That’s just not true.
👉 See also: First Name in Country Crossword: Why These Clues Trip You Up
If anything, RB3 was the most "rock" the series ever got because it acknowledged that rock music isn't just distorted guitars. It’s the piano in "Great Balls of Fire." It’s the brassy soul in Chicago’s "25 or 6 to 4." By expanding the definition of what a "rock band" looked like, they made the game more authentic to the actual history of the genre.
The difficulty was still there, too. Trying to 100% "Caught in a Mosh" on Expert Drums is still one of the hardest things you can do in a video game. Period.
How to experience these songs today
If you’re looking to dive back in, you’ve got a few hurdles. The hardware is getting old. Plastic guitars are becoming expensive relics on eBay. However, the community is surprisingly resilient.
- The Used Market: Look for the Xbox 360 version if possible. It’s generally considered the most stable and has the best compatibility with legacy controllers.
- The DLC Store: Believe it or not, some of the store is still functional, though many tracks have been pulled. It’s worth checking what’s left before the servers eventually go dark for good.
- Harmonix's Legacy: A lot of the DNA of Rock Band 3 lives on in Fortnite Festival. While it’s not the same as having a full plastic kit in your living room, the charting style and the focus on "stems" (the individual instrument tracks) started right here.
Actionable Next Steps for the Modern Player
If you still have your old console gathering dust, here is how you make the most of the Rock Band 3 songs library right now:
- Check your "Ready to Install" list: If you bought DLC ten years ago, it’s likely still tied to your account. Redownload it now before licenses shift further.
- Calibrate, Calibrate, Calibrate: Modern TVs have way more "lag" than the old LCDs of 2010. Use the manual calibration tool in the settings. Don't rely on the "auto" sense; do it by ear. It makes a world of difference on fast tracks like "Space Oddity."
- Explore the "Pro" features: Even if you don't have the keyboard, you can play "Pro" drums with a standard kit plus expansion cymbals. It changes the game from a button-matching exercise to an actual rhythmic skill.
- Look into the Milestones: RB3 has a deep career mode. Instead of just playing Quickplay, go through the "Road Challenges." It forces you to play songs you might otherwise skip, and you’ll find some hidden gems in the tracklist that you never appreciated before.
Rock Band 3 remains the high-water mark for the genre because it treated music with respect. It didn't just use songs as "levels" to be beaten. It used them as experiences to be shared. Whether you’re screaming the lyrics to "Misery Business" or trying to survive the guitar solo in "Free Bird," the game remains a masterclass in digital curation. It's a reminder of a time when gaming felt a little more social, a little more loud, and a lot more melodic.