Honestly, the "Robinhood story" feels like a Silicon Valley fever dream that just won't end. One minute you're the hero of the retail investor, and the next, you're handing over a $45 million check to the government while admitting your record-keeping was a mess.
If you've been following the robinhood sec charges violations over the last few years, you know it's not just one thing. It's a pile-on. Just this January 2025, the SEC slapped Robinhood’s subsidiaries with a fresh $45 million penalty. Why? Because they basically dropped the ball on everything from anti-money laundering (AML) to keeping track of employee's "off-channel" text messages.
It's a lot to keep track of.
The 2025 Settlement: A "Broad Array" of Messes
When the SEC uses words like "broad array," they aren't kidding. The latest $45 million settlement—split between Robinhood Securities and Robinhood Financial—is like a greatest hits of regulatory "don'ts."
The most glaring issue was the Electronic Blue Sheets (EBS). Between 2018 and 2024, Robinhood sent over 11,800 deficient reports to the SEC. We're talking about roughly 392 million transactions where the data was just... wrong. Missing timestamps. Incorrect identifiers. It’s the kind of stuff that makes regulators' heads explode because it makes it nearly impossible for them to monitor for actual market manipulation.
Then there’s the AML side. For a long time, Robinhood’s suspicious activity reporting was essentially running on a backlog. At one point, they had over 10,000 unreviewed alerts. Some reports weren't filed for nearly 200 days.
The SEC also caught them failing to preserve about 1.6 billion customer communications. Imagine being a multi-billion dollar financial firm and losing 1.6 billion messages because your archiving vendor hit its limit. It’s kind of wild.
Regulation SHO and the Short-Selling Problem
Short selling is already a lightning rod for controversy. Robinhood made it worse by mislabeling over 15 million short sales as "long" between 2019 and 2023.
They also failed to properly "close out" certain failures to deliver. In plain English: they weren't following the rules designed to prevent abusive short selling. When you're the app that millions of people used to try and "squeeze" hedge funds during the GameStop era, getting caught breaking short-selling rules is a pretty bad look.
The Ghost of 2020: The $65 Million "Best Execution" Lie
We can't talk about current violations without mentioning where the trust started to crack. Back in December 2020, Robinhood paid $65 million to settle charges that it misled customers about its primary revenue source: Payment for Order Flow (PFOF).
For years, Robinhood marketed itself as "commission-free."
Technically true.
But there’s no such thing as a free lunch.
The SEC found that Robinhood’s PFOF rates were unusually high, meaning they were sending orders to market makers who gave customers slightly worse prices on their trades. The SEC estimated this cost users $34.1 million—even after accounting for the $0 commissions. They were essentially telling users they were getting a great deal while quietly skimming off the top through inferior execution.
Crypto, Wells Notices, and the $30 Million NY Fine
The crypto side of the business hasn't been any smoother. In May 2024, Robinhood Crypto received a "Wells Notice" from the SEC.
A Wells Notice is basically a formal way for the SEC to say, "We’ve finished our investigation, and we're probably going to sue you."
Robinhood’s Chief Legal Officer, Dan Gallagher (who is actually a former SEC commissioner), was visibly frustrated. He argued that the assets they list aren't securities and that they’ve spent years trying to play by the rules.
But the regulators in New York didn't wait. The NY Department of Financial Services (NYDFS) had already fined them $30 million in 2022 for failing to staff their AML and cybersecurity departments properly as they scaled.
✨ Don't miss: Dov Charney Net Worth 2025: Why He Isn’t a Billionaire Anymore
Why Does This Keep Happening?
It’s the classic "move fast and break things" mentality. Robinhood grew from 500,000 users to over 30 million in what felt like a blink. Their compliance systems—which were basically spreadsheets and shared folders in the early days—couldn't keep up with the volume.
The 2021 FINRA fine ($70 million) was perhaps the most painful. It wasn't just about money; it was about the human cost. That fine was tied to system outages and the tragic suicide of Alex Kearns, a 20-year-old who mistakenly thought he owed $730,000 due to a confusing interface.
The Real-World Impact for You
If you’re still using the app, you’ve probably noticed it’s changed. The "confetti" is gone. The warnings are more prominent. But the legal baggage remains.
So, what should you actually do?
- Audit Your Own Security: If you have a Robinhood account, ensure your Two-Factor Authentication (2FA) is active. The 2025 settlement mentioned $1 million in fines specifically for identity theft and customer protection failures.
- Look at Trade Execution: If you're a high-volume trader, "commission-free" might be costing you more in "slippage" (the difference between the price you want and the price you get) than a $5 fee would elsewhere.
- Diversify Your Custody: If you hold large amounts of crypto on the platform, remember that Robinhood has faced heat for not letting users withdraw their own coins in the past (like the $3.9 million California settlement in late 2024).
- Keep Your Own Records: Since the SEC has repeatedly flagged Robinhood for poor record-keeping, don't rely on the app to hold your 10-year history perfectly. Download your monthly statements and trade confirmations to a local drive.
The reality is that Robinhood is likely here to stay, but their relationship with the SEC is going to be "it's complicated" for a long time. They’ve admitted to "certain findings" in the 2025 order and are currently undergoing audits for their internal communications. For now, the app is a lot more regulated than it was in 2020, but the history of violations suggests users should keep a skeptical eye on their "free" trades.