Robert Heinlein wrote a short story in 1958 that still makes people’s heads hurt. It’s called "—All You Zombies—" and no, it has absolutely nothing to do with the walking dead or George Romero. If you came here looking for advice on how to survive a brain-eating apocalypse, you're in the wrong place. But if you want to understand the most twisted, logically impossible, and arguably brilliant time-travel story ever written, stay put.
Most people encounter this story today because of the 2014 movie Predestination starring Ethan Hawke. The film is a remarkably faithful adaptation, but the original text is where the real grit is. Heinlein reportedly wrote the whole thing in one day. One single day. It’s a 3,000-word punch to the gut that explores the "solipsism" of a person who is their own mother, father, lover, and assassin.
The title "—All You Zombies—" is a bit of a trick. It refers to the narrator’s feeling that everyone else in the world is just a hollow shell, a "zombie" compared to the singular, self-created loop of their own existence.
The Plot Loop That Defies Logic
Let’s get into the weeds of the plot. It starts in a bar. A bartender, who we later learn is a member of the "Temporal Bureau," strikes up a conversation with a bitter writer known as "The Unmarried Mother." This writer tells a tragic life story. They were born a girl named Jane, left at an orphanage, grew up as an outcast, and eventually fell in love with a mysterious stranger. That stranger got Jane pregnant and then vanished. During the C-section, doctors discovered Jane was intersex—having both sets of organs—and because of complications, they had to transform her into a man to save her life.
Then it gets weird.
The bartender takes Jane (now a man) back in time. This man meets his younger, female self. He becomes the "mysterious stranger" who gets her pregnant. He literally fathers himself. The bartender then kidnaps the resulting baby and drops it off at an orphanage years in the past. That baby is Jane.
It's a "bootstrap paradox" taken to the absolute extreme. In physics, this is often discussed as a Closed Timelike Curve (CTC). Basically, there is no beginning. There is no end. The character has no ancestors and no descendants other than themselves. Heinlein wasn't just trying to be edgy; he was exploring the horrifying isolation of a life that exists outside the normal flow of human cause and effect.
Why All You Zombies Is the Ultimate Solipsism Study
Solipsism is the philosophical idea that only one's own mind is sure to exist. In the story, the narrator looks at the rest of us and sees ghosts. "I know where I came from—but where did all you zombies come from?" he asks. It’s a haunting line. When you realize you are the source of your own life, everyone else starts to look like a background extra in a movie that only you are starring in.
Critics like James Gifford have pointed out that Heinlein was obsessed with the idea of the "Self-Made Man." Usually, that's a metaphor for business success. Here, Heinlein makes it literal. The protagonist is quite literally self-made.
There’s a lot of debate about the gender politics of the story. Written in the 50s, the language Heinlein uses regarding intersex individuals and gender reassignment is obviously dated and reflects the medical understanding of that era. However, for 1958, the fact that he was even engaging with these themes was radical. He wasn't treating it as a joke; he was using it to construct a mechanical, logical puzzle that had never been seen in literature before.
The Science of the Paradox: Is It Actually Possible?
If we look at the physics of time travel, specifically the Novikov self-consistency principle, Heinlein’s story actually "works." The principle suggests that if a person travels back in time, the laws of physics would prevent them from doing anything that would change the present. Basically, you can't kill your grandfather because you didn't kill your grandfather.
In "—All You Zombies—," every action the protagonist takes in the past is exactly what already happened to create their future. There is no "changing" history. There is only fulfilling it.
- The Ring: The protagonist wears a ring depicting the Ouroboros—the snake eating its own tail. This isn't just a cool accessory; it's the entire theme of the story.
- The Temporal Bureau: The organization in the story exists to ensure these loops stay closed. They aren't "fixing" time; they are policing the inevitable.
- The Date: Pay attention to the date 1970 in the story. Heinlein chose his dates carefully to align with the character's aging process across the loops.
Honestly, the story is depressing if you think about it too long. It’s about a person trapped in a prison of their own making, unable to ever experience a genuine connection with another human being because everyone they meet is just another version of themselves.
Common Misconceptions About the Story
I see people online all the time getting "—All You Zombies—" confused with other time travel tropes. This isn't Back to the Future. There are no fading photographs. There's no "Save the Clock Tower."
One big mistake people make is thinking there was an "original" Jane who had regular parents. According to the logic of the story, there wasn't. The loop has always existed. It’s what physicists call a "jery-rigged universe." Another misconception is that the "zombies" in the title are literal. Again, they aren't. The narrator uses the term as a derogatory slur for "normal" people who have mothers and fathers and don't understand the cosmic loneliness of being a self-created entity.
🔗 Read more: Why The Three Musketeers 93 Is Actually The Best Version For 90s Kids
If you're going to read it for the first time, pay attention to the dialogue in the bar. Heinlein hides the ending in plain sight within the first three pages. The bartender’s casual remarks aren't just filler; they are the blueprint for the entire circular narrative.
Actionable Takeaways for Sci-Fi Fans and Writers
If you’re a writer or just a fan of high-concept fiction, there are a few things you can actually do to appreciate this work more deeply.
First, read the story alongside Heinlein’s other time-travel masterpiece, "By His Bootstraps." It deals with similar themes but focuses more on the mechanics of multiple versions of the same man interacting. It’s like a warm-up for the complexity of "—All You Zombies—."
Second, watch the movie Predestination. It’s one of those rare cases where the film adds emotional depth to a very cold, intellectual story. The performance by Sarah Snook is incredible and helps humanize the tragedy of Jane’s transformation.
👉 See also: Getting Local: Why Movie Listings Athens GA Are Harder to Find Than You Think
Third, look into the "Grandfather Paradox" vs. the "Bootstrap Paradox." Understanding the difference will change how you watch almost every sci-fi movie. The Grandfather Paradox is about changing the past; the Bootstrap Paradox (like Heinlein's story) is about the past being unchangeable and self-causing.
Finally, if you’re interested in the philosophy, check out the concept of the "Closed Timelike Curve" in general relativity. It’s the closest thing we have to a scientific basis for the kind of loop Heinlein dreamed up.
Basically, "—All You Zombies—" is a reminder that the most terrifying thing in the universe isn't a monster under the bed. It’s the idea that we might be completely alone, living in a loop of our own making, with no way to break the cycle. It’s a classic for a reason. It doesn't give you a happy ending; it gives you a headache and a existential crisis. And in science fiction, that’s usually a sign of a job well done.