You've probably done it. You held hands in a shaky circle, skipped until you were dizzy, and then collapsed onto the grass while shrieking "we all fall down!" It’s a childhood rite of passage. But if you spend five minutes on the internet, someone will inevitably tell you that the ring a ring o roses nursery song is actually a macabre checklist of symptoms for the Great Plague of 1665.
It sounds perfect. Too perfect, honestly.
The "rosy" rash, the "posies" of herbs to ward off the smell of death, the "sneezing" (a-tishoo!) as a final symptom before the "fall" into a grave. It's a dark, edgy twist on a sweet childhood memory. People love a good secret history. The problem? Most folklore experts and historians think the whole plague connection is complete nonsense.
It’s a classic urban legend.
Why the Plague Theory Doesn't Hold Water
If the ring a ring o roses nursery song was really about the Black Death or the 1665 outbreak, you’d expect to find it in the history books from that time. You don't. In fact, the earliest version of the rhyme doesn't show up in print until the late 1800s. Specifically, it appears in Kate Greenaway’s Mother Goose in 1881.
That’s a massive gap.
Think about it. We’re talking about a gap of over 200 years. If a song was so culturally significant that it survived for centuries, surely someone would have written it down before the Victorian era? Folklorists like Iona and Peter Opie, who basically wrote the bible on children's games (The Singing Game), pointed out that the symptoms described in the rhyme don't actually match the medical reality of the Bubonic plague.
📖 Related: What Does a Stoner Mean? Why the Answer Is Changing in 2026
The plague didn't typically start with a red rash in a ring shape. It started with "buboes"—massive, painful swelling of the lymph nodes in the groin or armpit. Not exactly "rosy." And while "sneezing" is part of the modern British version, many older versions of the song use different words entirely. Some versions involve curtsying, others involve shaking or "hushing."
Basically, the plague theory only works if you look at one specific, modern version of the lyrics and squint really hard.
Variations That Ruin the Legend
The American version often goes "Ring around the rosie, a pocket full of posies, ashes, ashes, we all fall down." The "ashes" bit is usually used as the "smoking gun" for cremation of bodies.
Except cremation wasn't a thing in 1665 London.
The church insisted on Christian burials. They weren't burning piles of bodies in the streets. Furthermore, the German, Italian, and French versions of the rhyme have nothing to do with ashes or sneezing. In some European variations, the "roses" are actually "elderberry bushes" or "willow trees." In others, the song ends with the children simply sitting down to eat or jumping up and down.
If the song was a pan-European memory of a pandemic, the lyrics would likely be more consistent across borders. Instead, what we see is a playground game that evolved locally over time, probably starting as a simple dancing game.
👉 See also: Am I Gay Buzzfeed Quizzes and the Quest for Identity Online
Where Did the Song Actually Come From?
So, if it’s not about death and decay, what is it? It’s a game. Kids like to spin. They like to fall down. It’s a sensory experience.
Folklorists suggest the ring a ring o roses nursery song likely grew out of 19th-century "play-party" games. In some religious communities, dancing was considered sinful. But "games" were okay. These games often involved forming circles and moving to a rhythmic chant.
The "rosie" might just be a reference to a rose tree or a May Day celebration. The "posies" were likely just flowers. Simple. Sweet. No hidden corpses.
The Evolution of the Lyrics
Lyrics are fluid. They change because a kid mishears a word or because a certain sound is more fun to shout.
- 1881 (Greenaway): Ring-a-ring-a-roses, A pocket full of posies; Hush! hush! hush! hush! We’re all tumbled down.
- 1883 (Shropshire): A ring, a ring o' roses, A pocket full o' posies; One for Jack and one for Jim and one for Little Moses! A-tishoo! A-tishoo!
- 1898 (Massachusetts): Ring around the rosy, Pocket full of posies, One, two, three—squat!
Notice how the "sneezing" doesn't even appear in the earliest version? It shows up later. If the sneezing was the "symptom" that proved the plague theory, why wasn't it there at the start? It’s much more likely that "A-tishoo" was added because it’s a fun, rhythmic sound that gives children a cue to drop to the floor.
Why We Want it to be About the Plague
There is a psychological phenomenon at play here. We love the idea that something innocent has a dark underbelly. It feels like "insider knowledge." It’s the same reason people believe The Wizard of Oz is an allegory for the gold standard or that Disney movies are full of hidden messages.
✨ Don't miss: Easy recipes dinner for two: Why you are probably overcomplicating date night
The plague theory for the ring a ring o roses nursery song didn't even exist until after World War II. It first gained real traction in the late 1940s and 1950s.
It’s a modern myth.
James Wright, a noted folklorist, has argued that the "plague explanation" became popular because it’s easy to remember and satisfying to tell. It turns a boring nursery rhyme into a ghost story. But as far as historical evidence goes, it's thinner than a Victorian lace handkerchief.
Practical Takeaways for Parents and Educators
If you’re teaching this song to kids or using it in a classroom, you don't need to feel weird about it. You aren't teaching them a "death march."
- Embrace the physical play. The song is great for developing gross motor skills. The skipping, the sudden stop, and the controlled "fall" are all excellent for toddler coordination.
- Explore the variations. Show kids how the song changes in different countries. It’s a great way to talk about culture and how stories evolve.
- Correct the myth (gently). If an older child mentions the plague, use it as a lesson in "fact-checking." Ask them: "If this song was about the plague, why didn't anyone write it down for 200 years?" It’s a perfect introduction to historical skepticism.
- Keep it light. At its core, the rhyme is about the joy of moving in a circle with friends. That’s why it has survived for over a century, regardless of what the "hidden" meaning might be.
The ring a ring o roses nursery song is a piece of living history, but that history is about play, not pathology. Next time you see a group of kids falling down on the grass, you can rest easy knowing they’re just being kids—not reenacting a 17th-century medical disaster.
Check the dates. Look at the lyrics. The roses are just roses.