When we talk about football, we usually talk about the glory. The Sunday afternoon lights, the miraculous catches, and the way a stadium shakes when a running back breaks a tackle for a forty-yard gain. But there is a different side to that story. A darker, quieter, and frankly heartbreaking side that doesn't make the highlight reels. If you really want to understand the human cost of the NFL, you have to watch Requiem for a Running Back.
This isn't just another sports documentary. It is a daughter’s journey into the literal brain of her father.
Rebecca Carpenter, the filmmaker, didn't set out to make a scientific manifesto. She set out to find out why her dad, Lewis Carpenter—a man who won three consecutive NFL championships with the Detroit Lions and the Green Bay Packers—became someone she barely recognized toward the end of his life. Lew was a legend. He played ten seasons in the league. He coached for thirty-one more. But by the time he passed away in 2010, the man inside that massive frame was fading.
What Requiem for a Running Back reveals about the "Warrior Culture"
Honestly, the most striking thing about the film is how it tackles the culture of "toughness." We grew up being told that football players are modern gladiators. They are supposed to play through the pain. If you get your "bell rung," you shake it off and get back in the huddle. Requiem for a Running Back shows us exactly what happens forty years after that huddle breaks.
When Lew Carpenter died, his family made the heavy decision to donate his brain to the VA-BU-CLF Brain Bank. That is where Dr. Ann McKee works. She is the neuropathologist who has become the face of CTE (Chronic Traumatic Encephalopathy) research. When she looked at Lew’s brain, the results were undeniable. He had Stage 4 CTE. That is the most advanced stage. Basically, his brain was riddled with tau protein deposits that look like tangles of dark ink under a microscope.
It explains everything. The irritability. The memory loss. The "ghosts" that seem to haunt retired players.
But Rebecca doesn't just stop at her father's diagnosis. She goes on a road trip. She talks to other legends. People like Mike Ditka and James Lofton. You see these giants of the game grappling with a reality they weren't prepared for. They were trained to ignore injury, but you can't "tough" your way through a degenerative brain disease.
📖 Related: Matthew Berry Positional Rankings: Why They Still Run the Fantasy Industry
The science is messy and uncomfortable
One thing people often get wrong is thinking CTE is only about big, bone-crushing concussions. It’s not. It’s the sub-concussive hits. It’s the 1,000 times a running back puts his head down to gain an extra yard. It is the cumulative effect of a decade spent in a high-speed car crash every Sunday.
The film does a great job of showing how the NFL handled this—or, more accurately, how they didn't. For a long time, the league's stance was one of denial. They had their own "Mild Traumatic Brain Injury" committee that basically told players they were fine. It’s a bit like the tobacco industry in the 70s. If you tell people it's safe long enough, they’ll keep buying the product.
But players weren't fine.
Rebecca talks to Junior Seau’s family. She talks to Dave Duerson’s family. These were men who reached the pinnacle of human achievement and then fell into a pit of depression and cognitive decline. It makes you look at a Saturday afternoon college game a little differently. You start wondering which of those kids will be able to remember their grandkids' names when they’re sixty.
Why this story is different from "Concussion"
You've probably seen the Will Smith movie Concussion. It’s a Hollywood dramatization. It’s good for what it is, but Requiem for a Running Back feels more raw. It’s personal. It’s not about a doctor discovering a disease; it’s about a family living through the consequences of that disease.
The documentary shows the "old guard" of the NFL. These guys didn't make $20 million a year. They played because they loved it, and they did it for relatively modest paychecks compared to today's stars. When the game was done with them, they were often left with broken bodies and no real medical infrastructure to help them deal with the neurological fallout.
👉 See also: What Time Did the Cubs Game End Today? The Truth About the Off-Season
There is a specific scene where Rebecca is looking at old footage of her dad. He’s young, vibrant, and incredibly athletic. Then it cuts to the reality of his later years. The contrast is jarring. It forces the viewer to confront the "transaction" we make as fans. We pay for the entertainment, and they pay with their lives. Sorta heavy, right? But it's the truth.
The ripple effect on families
We focus on the players, but the families are the ones in the trenches. They are the ones who deal with the mood swings. They are the ones who have to watch a brilliant man lose his car keys for the fifth time in an hour.
Rebecca’s perspective as a daughter is what gives the film its soul. She isn't angry at her father for being difficult; she's angry that he was stolen from her while he was still standing right in front of her. CTE doesn't just kill you; it erases you. It’s a slow, agonizing "fading away."
The film also explores the "denial" phase. Many former players don't want to admit they are struggling. Their entire identity is built on being the toughest guy in the room. Admitting your brain is failing feels like an admission of weakness. That is the wall that researchers and family members are constantly hitting.
Is football still worth it?
This is the big question Requiem for a Running Back leaves you with. The film doesn't necessarily say "ban football." That would be too simple. Instead, it asks for honesty. It asks the NFL to stop the gaslighting. It asks for better equipment, better protocols, and a total shift in how we view "toughness."
The game has changed a bit since Lew Carpenter’s day. There are "targeting" rules now. There are independent neurologists on the sidelines. But is it enough?
✨ Don't miss: Jake Ehlinger Sign: The Real Story Behind the College GameDay Controversy
When you see the microscopic slides of Lew’s brain, it’s hard to say yes. The damage is so extensive. It’s not just a few "bruises" on the brain. It’s a systemic breakdown of the organ that makes us who we are.
Key takeaways from the documentary
- CTE is a cumulative disease: It’s not just about the big hits that make the "C’mon Man!" segments. It’s the daily grind of practice and minor collisions.
- The NFL’s history of denial: The league spent decades discrediting doctors who tried to sound the alarm.
- The emotional toll: Families are the "second victims" of brain trauma in sports.
- The legacy of the greats: Players like Lew Carpenter paved the way for the modern NFL but paid a price that was never fully disclosed to them.
Practical steps for athletes and fans
If you are a parent of a kid playing contact sports, or if you’re a former athlete yourself, you can't just ignore this. The "glory" isn't worth a lifetime of cognitive decline.
First, educate yourself on the actual symptoms. It’s not just headaches. It’s impulsivity. It’s unexplained anger. It’s a loss of "executive function"—your ability to plan and organize your day. If you or someone you love is showing these signs after a career in contact sports, seek out specialists who understand TBI (Traumatic Brain Injury) and CTE.
Second, support the research. Organizations like the Concussion Legacy Foundation are doing the actual work to find a way to diagnose CTE in living patients. Right now, we can only confirm it after someone dies. That has to change. If we can see it coming, we can manage it.
Finally, change the conversation. Stop praising the player who goes back in the game after a "stinger." Start praising the coach who has the guts to pull a star player because he looks a little "off." The culture of the game needs to value the person more than the points on the scoreboard.
Requiem for a Running Back is a difficult watch, but it’s a necessary one. It’s a tribute to a father, a warning to a league, and a wake-up call for every fan who cheers for a big hit without thinking about what happens when the cheering stops.
To take action, start by visiting the Concussion Legacy Foundation website to learn how to recognize the early signs of brain trauma. If you are an athlete, consider signing up for a brain donation registry to help future generations. For fans, advocate for safer protocols at the youth and high school levels, where the brain is most vulnerable. Understanding the risks is the only way to truly honor the players who gave everything to the game.