New York City’s political machine is a beast that rarely sleeps. If you've been following the recent upheaval at City Hall, you know that being the republican candidate for nyc mayor in 2025 was basically like trying to sell a parka in the Sahara. Tough. Really tough. While the headlines were dominated by the dramatic exit of Eric Adams and the eventual victory of Zohran Mamdani, the Republican story—specifically that of Curtis Sliwa—gets overlooked far too often. Honestly, it's kinda wild how much the narrative shifted from "law and order" to a strange three-way battle for the city's soul.
Most folks outside the five boroughs think a Republican in NYC is a myth, like a polite subway conductor or a $5 sandwich in Manhattan. But they're here. And in the 2025 cycle, the GOP's hopes rested once again on the man in the red beret.
Who Exactly Was the Republican Candidate for NYC Mayor?
Curtis Sliwa isn't just a name; he’s a walking, talking piece of NYC history. You’ve probably seen him. He’s the guy who founded the Guardian Angels back in 1979 when the subways were basically a scene from an action movie. This time around, Sliwa ran on a platform that felt like a throwback to the Giuliani era, but with a weird, modern twist involving animal rights and a massive colony of rescue cats in his apartment.
He won the Republican primary on June 24, 2025, without much of a sweat. Who else was going to do it? Joe Borelli, the Staten Island powerhouse, decided to jump ship early in the year to go into the private sector. Eric Ulrich was dealing with his own legal headaches. That left Sliwa to carry the banner. He didn't just run as a Republican, though; he also grabbed the "Protect Animals Party" line because, well, that's just Curtis.
👉 See also: How Has Presidential Power Changed Over Time: What Most People Get Wrong
The Sliwa Strategy: "Moshpit" Politics
Sliwa describes his campaigning style as a "moshpit." He spends 20 hours a day on the trains, talking to anyone who will listen. His main pitch was simple: we need more cops. Specifically, he wanted to hire 7,000 more officers to bring the force up to about 40,000. He argued that the city was slipping back into the "bad old days," a message that usually resonates in parts of Staten Island and southern Queens but struggles to find traction in a gentrified Brooklyn.
Why the 2025 Race Went Totally Sideways
If this had been a normal Republican vs. Democrat race, we might be talking about a different outcome. But 2025 was anything but normal. First, you had Mayor Eric Adams withdrawing from the race in September due to tanking poll numbers and federal investigations. Then, Andrew Cuomo—yes, that Andrew Cuomo—decided to run as an independent after losing the Democratic primary to Zohran Mamdani.
This created a bizarre dynamic for the republican candidate for nyc mayor. Suddenly, Sliwa wasn't the only "conservative-leaning" option. Even though Cuomo is a Democrat, his "Fight and Deliver" party line appealed to the same moderate and right-leaning voters who might have otherwise considered a Republican.
- The Trump Factor: In a move that shocked almost no one but annoyed everyone, Donald Trump actually endorsed Andrew Cuomo late in the game. He called for Sliwa to drop out to consolidate the "anti-socialist" vote against Mamdani.
- Sliwa’s Refusal: Curtis didn't budge. He called Cuomo "Zohran lite" and stayed in the race until the bitter end. He told anyone who would listen that he was the only one actually standing between the city and a socialist takeover.
The Numbers Nobody Talks About
When the dust settled on November 4, 2025, the results were pretty bleak for the GOP. Sliwa pulled in about 7% of the total vote. That’s a massive drop from the 28% he got against Adams in 2021. Why the nose-dive? Basically, Cuomo ate his lunch.
Likely voters who usually lean Republican or Independent were faced with a choice: vote for a colorful radio host who most polls showed had no chance, or vote for a former Governor with massive name recognition who was positioned as the only real threat to Mamdani. According to a late October Quinnipiac poll, about 45% of Republicans were actually backing Cuomo, while only 44% stayed loyal to Sliwa. That split was the final nail in the coffin for the GOP's chances.
What Sliwa Campaigned On (Besides Cops)
It wasn't just about the NYPD. Sliwa actually had some surprisingly nuanced takes on the environment. He was the only candidate screaming at developers to keep their "grubby hands" off the wetlands and parks. He famously stood with his wife, Nancy Regula, to try and save the Elizabeth Street Garden from being turned into senior housing. He argued that you can't just bulldoze beauty to check a bureaucratic box.
He also pushed for:
- Massive property tax cuts for homeowners.
- A "no-kill" policy for city animal shelters.
- Direct referendums so people could vote on things like sanctuary city status.
What Most People Get Wrong About the NYC GOP
The biggest misconception is that the republican candidate for nyc mayor is always a carbon copy of the national party. In New York, that just doesn't work. To even stand a chance, a Republican has to be a "fusion" candidate. You have to talk about labor, you have to talk about rent, and you have to be socially moderate enough not to scare off Manhattan.
Nicole Malliotakis, the only Republican currently representing NYC in Congress, has been the loudest critic of the new administration. She’s already blasting Mayor Mamdani’s "socialist" agenda from the House floor. But even she had to acknowledge the reality of the 2025 race: the Republican brand in the city is currently in a state of flux.
Actionable Insights for the Future
If you’re looking at the political landscape and wondering where the GOP goes from here, keep these things in mind:
🔗 Read more: How Many People in Congress Are Jewish: What Most People Get Wrong
- Watch the Primaries: The next big shift won't happen in a general election; it'll happen when the Republican party finds a candidate who can bridge the gap between the "MAGA" base and the "Common Sense" moderate voters in Queens and Brooklyn.
- Follow Local Issues: The GOP wins in NYC when they focus on the "Breadline Issues"—the cost of groceries, property taxes, and subway safety. When they get bogged down in national culture wars, they lose.
- Staten Island is the Bellwether: If you want to know if a Republican has a shot, look at the margins in the 51st Council District. If they aren't winning there by 30+ points, they have no path to Gracie Mansion.
The 2025 election proved that in a city as blue as New York, a split on the right is a guaranteed win for the left. For the next republican candidate for nyc mayor to succeed, they’ll need more than a red beret and a love for cats. They’ll need a way to convince New Yorkers that they aren't just an opposition party, but a viable alternative for a city that feels like it's perpetually on the edge.
To stay updated on the 2026 legislative sessions and how the new Republican minority in the City Council is handling the Mamdani administration, you should regularly check the NYC Board of Elections and City & State NY for the latest committee reports and polling data.