You’ve probably seen it. That bright orange cover with the giant octopus limb curling across the front. It’s everywhere—airport bookstores, your neighbor’s coffee table, and seemingly every book club on the planet. Honestly, when a book gets this much hype, it’s usually either a life-changing masterpiece or a total letdown. But the remarkably bright creatures book—officially titled Remarkably Bright Creatures by Shelby Van Pelt—is one of those rare cases where the hype actually makes sense.
It's a story about a widow, a giant Pacific octopus named Marcellus, and a young man who can’t seem to get his life together. Sounds weird? It is. But it works because it doesn't try to be a high-brow literary puzzle. It’s just... human. Even the parts written from the perspective of an eight-armed mollusk feel more grounded than most contemporary fiction.
🔗 Read more: Most Rated Sci Fi Movies: Why the Classics Still Win (and What’s Changing)
The Marcellus Factor: More Than Just a Gimmick
Most people pick up the remarkably bright creatures book because they heard there’s a talking octopus. Let’s get one thing straight: Marcellus doesn't "talk" to the characters. He isn't a Disney sidekick. He’s a narrator. He’s cynical, observant, and frankly, he thinks humans are pretty dim-witted.
Marcellus lives in a tank at the Sowell Bay Aquarium. He’s bored. He spends his nights escaping his enclosure to snack on nearby exhibits and collect random trinkets. Van Pelt gives him a voice that feels distinct—it’s stiff, slightly formal, and heavy with the weary wisdom of a creature that knows its life is nearing its end.
Giant Pacific octopuses only live about four or five years. That’s a factual biological constraint that Van Pelt uses to drive the stakes. Marcellus knows he’s "dying of old age," and that ticking clock makes his efforts to communicate with Tova Sullivan, the 70-year-old night cleaner, feel urgent. He’s seen things. He knows what happened to Tova’s son, Erik, who disappeared decades ago. The mystery isn't just a "whodunnit"; it’s a "will the octopus manage to tell the human before he runs out of days?"
Tova and Cameron: A Study in Loneliness
Tova Sullivan is the heart of the story. She’s the kind of woman who keeps her house pristine because it’s the only thing she can control. Her husband is gone. Her son has been missing for thirty years. She takes a job cleaning the aquarium at night not because she needs the money, but because she needs to stay busy. Stoicism is her shield.
Then you have Cameron.
He’s in his late twenties, broke, and convinced that the world owes him a break. He travels to Sowell Bay looking for the father he never knew, hoping for a payout that will fix his life. At first, Cameron is annoying. He’s the guy who blames everyone else for his problems. But the remarkably bright creatures book handles his growth with a lot of grace. He’s not a "bad" kid; he’s just a lost one.
The way these three lives—Tova, Cameron, and Marcellus—braid together is what makes the book stick. It’s about the "found family" trope, sure, but it avoids the saccharine sweetness that usually ruins those stories. It’s messy. People make mistakes. They miss obvious signs.
Why the Setting Matters
Sowell Bay isn't a real place, but it feels like every small town in the Pacific Northwest. Cold water. Constant mist. A sense of isolation that mirrors what the characters are feeling. Van Pelt, who grew up in the Pacific Northwest, nails the atmosphere. The aquarium itself becomes a character—a place of confinement for Marcellus, but a place of sanctuary for Tova.
Addressing the "Coincidence" Problem
If you read a lot of literary fiction, you might find the plot of the remarkably bright creatures book a bit... convenient. There are a lot of coincidences. A lot of "just-so" moments where people happen to be in the right place at the right time.
Some critics have pointed this out as a flaw. But honestly? In a book narrated by a sentient octopus, demanding 100% gritty realism seems like missing the point. The book operates on the logic of fate and connection. It’s meant to be a comfort read, not a grueling interrogation of the human condition. If you can accept that an octopus is smart enough to solve a thirty-year-old cold case, you can probably accept that two characters might bump into each other at a grocery store.
The Science Behind the Fiction
One of the coolest things about the remarkably bright creatures book is how much it actually gets right about Enteroctopus dofleini.
- Intelligence: They really are "remarkably bright." They can solve puzzles, recognize human faces, and use tools.
- Escapology: Octopuses in captivity are notorious for escaping. There are documented cases of them climbing out of tanks to eat fish in other tanks and then returning home before the keepers arrive.
- The Three Hearts: Marcellus mentions his three hearts. That’s real. Two pump blood to the gills, while one pumps it to the rest of the body.
- Short Lifespans: As mentioned, their lives are tragically short. This biological reality adds a layer of genuine melancholy to Marcellus’s chapters.
Van Pelt clearly did her homework. She doesn't just treat Marcellus as a human in a costume; she respects the biology of the creature while giving him a personality we can relate to.
Why Is Everyone Obsessed With This Book?
It’s the "Ted Lasso" effect.
We live in a world that feels increasingly fragmented and, frankly, pretty exhausting. The remarkably bright creatures book offers something that isn't cynical. It deals with heavy themes—grief, aging, abandonment, the ethics of captivity—but it does so with a fundamental kindness.
It’s a "low stakes" read in terms of stress, but "high stakes" in terms of emotion. You aren't worried about the world ending; you’re worried about an old woman losing her only friend. That kind of intimacy is why it stayed on the New York Times bestseller list for over 100 weeks. It’s a word-of-mouth juggernaut because it’s a safe bet for a gift. Your grandma will like it. Your edgy teenage cousin will probably like it. You’ll definitely like it.
Moving Beyond the Hype: What to Read Next
If you’ve already finished the remarkably bright creatures book and you’re feeling that post-book void, you have options. You don't have to just sit there missing Marcellus.
- The Soul of an Octopus by Sy Montgomery: This is non-fiction, but it reads like a dream. Montgomery explores the actual consciousness of octopuses. It’ll make you realize that Marcellus isn't as much of a fantasy as you might think.
- A Man Called Ove by Fredrik Backman: If you loved Tova, you’ll love Ove. It’s the gold standard for "grumpy old person with a hidden heart of gold" stories.
- Lessons in Chemistry by Bonnie Garmus: It has a similar blend of quirky humor and deep emotional resonance, plus a very smart dog that serves a similar role to Marcellus.
Putting the Story to Work
Reading is great, but the themes in this book actually have some practical legs. If you found yourself moved by Tova’s journey or Marcellus’s observations, here is how to actually apply those vibes to your own life:
- Volunteer at a local shelter or aquarium: Tova found purpose in work that others found mundane. There is a deep, meditative value in service, especially when you're feeling disconnected.
- Document your family history: The central mystery of the book stems from things left unsaid and records lost. Don't wait for a crisis to ask your older relatives about their lives. Record them. Write it down.
- Practice "Marcellus Observation": Take ten minutes a day to just watch. No phone. No music. Just observe the people and environment around you with the detached, curious eye of an outsider. You'd be surprised what you notice when you stop trying to participate and start trying to see.
- Visit a tide pool: If you’re near the coast, go look for the real-life versions of these creatures. Seeing a sea star or a small octopus in the wild puts the scale of the book into a whole new perspective.
The remarkably bright creatures book isn't just a story about a sea animal. It’s a reminder that we are all, in our own ways, slightly trapped in our own tanks, waiting for someone to notice us. It’s a call to be the person who notices.
Actionable Next Steps
If you haven't read it yet, go to your local independent bookstore and grab a physical copy. The tactile experience of the cover art is part of the charm. If you’ve already read it, pass your copy to someone who is going through a transition—a retirement, a move, or a loss. This book is a tool for empathy. Use it.
Check your local library’s "Read Alike" shelf for titles by Shelby Van Pelt or similar authors like Elizabeth Strout. If you're into audiobooks, the narration for Remarkably Bright Creatures—specifically the parts voiced by Marin Ireland and Michael Urie—is phenomenal. Urie captures Marcellus’s "superior" tone perfectly. That’s probably the best way to experience the story if you’re a multi-tasker.
Stop waiting for a "better" time to dive into a story about a cephalopod. Just start. You’ll thank yourself when you reach the final page and realize you’re looking at the world—and maybe your neighbor—a little bit differently.