You know that feeling when you're standing in the checkout line and you see that bright orange packaging, but the color scheme is a little... off? It’s not the classic yellow-and-brown. It’s a stark, bright white. You grab it.
Reese's white creme peanut butter cups are basically the "cool younger sibling" of the candy world. They’re polarizing. People either think they’re a gift from the snack gods or a total betrayal of the original 1928 recipe. Honestly, I get it. If you grew up on the milk chocolate version, switching to the white creme can feel like a glitch in the matrix.
But there is a massive secret hiding in plain sight on that wrapper.
It's Not Actually White Chocolate
Most people call them "white chocolate Reese's." I’ve done it. You've probably done it. Even some store displays do it. But if you look at the actual name on the package, it says "White Creme."
This isn't just Hershey being fancy with words. There's a legal reason for this.
To be called "white chocolate" in the United States, the FDA requires a product to contain at least 20% cocoa butter. Reese's white creme peanut butter cups don't use cocoa butter as the primary fat source. Instead, they use a blend of vegetable oils—usually palm, shea, sunflower, or palm kernel oil. This keeps the texture ultra-smooth and the color that iconic "paper white" shade.
Why the "Creme" Label Matters
- The Melt Factor: Because it uses vegetable oil instead of cocoa butter, the coating melts differently on your tongue. It’s often described as "waxier" by critics, but fans love it because it doesn't overpower the peanut butter.
- The Sugar Hit: White creme is notoriously sweeter than milk chocolate. Since there are no cocoa solids to provide bitterness, the sweetness of the sugar and the saltiness of the peanut butter are the only two notes playing.
- The Color: Real white chocolate is actually a pale ivory or yellowish color. Reese’s white creme is bright white, which makes it look great in a candy bowl, even if it’s technically a "confectionery coating."
Does the lack of cocoa butter make it "fake"? Not really. It just makes it a different beast entirely. Think of it as the difference between a high-end steak and a really good smash burger. Both are great; they just hit different parts of your brain.
The Peanut Butter Ratio Struggle
If you’re a Reese’s nerd, you know that the ratio of "chocolate" to peanut butter is the only metric that matters.
Reese's white creme peanut butter cups changed the game here. Because the white creme is so much sweeter and richer than the standard milk chocolate, the peanut butter inside actually tastes saltier. It’s a weird sensory trick.
The original milk chocolate version has that iconic "snap" when you bite into it. The white creme version is softer. It’s almost pillowy.
Breaking Down the Variations
- The Standard 2-Pack: This is the baseline. It’s got the classic fluted paper cup and that crumbly, salty peanut butter we all know.
- White Creme Thins: These are for people who want the flavor without the commitment. They are about 40% thinner than the original, which actually increases the "creme-to-PB" ratio. If you like the white coating more than the filling, these are your best bet.
- White Creme Miniatures: These are dangerous. Because they're smaller, the "walls" of the cup are thicker relative to the center. You get a lot of white creme in every bite.
- White Creme Big Cups: Only for the brave. These are massive. They often include "mix-ins" now, like pretzels or potato chips, though the plain white creme Big Cup is a staple for the true fanatics.
A History of "White" Reese's
The Reese's brand has been around since H.B. Reese started making "Penny Cups" in his basement in the 1920s. But the white version is a relatively recent addition to the permanent lineup.
It officially became a year-round staple in December 2003.
Before that, white peanut butter treats were mostly seasonal. You’d see the white eggs at Easter or white ghosts at Halloween. Hershey realized that people weren't just buying them because they looked like ghosts; they actually liked the taste.
💡 You might also like: US Presidents by Height: Why We Keep Electing the Tallest Guy in the Room
There was a brief period where they did use a formula closer to white chocolate, but as costs rose and consumer tastes shifted toward that specific "creme" texture, the current recipe took over. It was a business move, sure, but it also created a unique flavor profile that no other brand has quite managed to copy.
Nutrition: Let's Be Real
Nobody is eating these for their health. We’re all adults here. But if you’re curious how they stack up against the classic version, the numbers are pretty similar.
A standard 1.39 oz pack of two white creme cups usually clocks in around 210 calories.
You're looking at about 12 grams of fat and 18 grams of sugar. The "Thins" version drops the calories per piece, but honestly, most people just end up eating three of them instead of one regular cup, so it’s a wash.
The main difference is the sodium. Reese's are famously salty, and the white creme version feels even saltier because the coating is so sugary. It’s that hit of 140mg-150mg of sodium that keeps you coming back for a second cup. It’s addictive. Basically science.
Why Do People Get So Mad About Them?
Food tribalism is real. If you go on Reddit or Twitter, you’ll find heated debates about these cups.
One side argues that the white creme is "cloying" and "tastes like sweetened candle wax."
The other side—my side, honestly—argues that it’s the ultimate evolution of the sweet-and-salty combo. Because the white creme lacks the "earthiness" of cocoa, the peanut butter is allowed to be the star of the show.
It’s also a texture thing. If you like your candy to have a bit of a "crunch" or "snap," you’ll hate these. They’re soft. They melt quickly. They’re messy if you leave them in your pocket for more than three minutes.
Pro-Tip: The Freezer Method
If you find the white creme a bit too sweet or "soft," put them in the freezer for exactly 20 minutes.
It hardens the vegetable oils in the creme and gives it a snap that rivals the milk chocolate version. Plus, it slows down the eating process so you actually taste the salt in the peanut butter.
The Future of White Creme
In 2024 and 2025, we saw a massive explosion in "White Creme" variations. We’ve seen the Reese's Medley, which mixes white creme with pretzels and blueberries, and the Oreo x Reese's collaborations that use white creme as a base.
The brand is clearly leaning into the "white" aesthetic because it stands out on the shelf. In a sea of brown chocolate bars, that white-and-orange combo is a beacon.
Also, white creme is generally easier to work with for seasonal shapes. That’s why the White Creme Pumpkins and Ghosts often look a bit more "defined" than the milk chocolate ones. The oil-based coating holds its shape in the mold a little better during mass production.
Actionable Snack Advice
If you’ve been on the fence about trying these, or if you’re a die-hard fan looking to up your game, here’s what you do:
- Check the "Best By" Date: Because white creme uses vegetable oils, it can go "stale" or pick up other flavors faster than dark or milk chocolate. Always get the freshest pack.
- Pair with Coffee: The bitterness of a black coffee perfectly cuts through the intense sweetness of the white creme. It’s a top-tier mid-afternoon snack.
- Use them for S'mores: Swap your Hershey bar for a white creme Reese's cup. The way the peanut butter melts into the marshmallow is life-changing.
- Look for the "Big Cup with Pretzels": If you think the plain white version is too sweet, the addition of the salty pretzels in the Big Cup version fixes the balance perfectly.
Next time you see that white wrapper, don't just call it "white chocolate." Call it what it is: a salty, sugary, oil-based masterpiece that shouldn't work as well as it does. Grab a pack, throw them in the freezer, and decide for yourself which side of the candy war you’re on.