The idea of a "Red Room" is basically the internet's favorite campfire story. You've probably heard the pitch: pay a bunch of Bitcoin, log into a specific Tor onion site, and watch a live "murder show" where the audience votes on what happens to the victim. It sounds like a scene straight out of a low-budget horror flick. People obsess over it. They scour Reddit threads and YouTube documentaries looking for proof that these things actually exist.
But here is the reality.
Most of what people call "deep web murder shows" are just sophisticated phishing scams designed to separate edgy teenagers from their cryptocurrency. If you go looking for one, you aren't going to find a live broadcast. You’re going to find a countdown timer and a Bitcoin wallet address. Once that timer hits zero, the site disappears, and so does your money.
Why the Deep Web Murder Show is Technically Impossible
Let’s talk about how the technology actually works for a second. The Tor network—which is what most people mean when they talk about the "Deep Web"—is slow. It’s painfully slow. Because your connection is being bounced through three different nodes across the globe to hide your identity, you lose a massive amount of bandwidth.
Ever tried to stream 4K video over a dial-up connection? You can't.
Live streaming requires a high bit rate and low latency. The Tor network, by design, provides neither. If someone were trying to broadcast a high-definition live video feed on an onion site, it would be a stuttering, unwatchable mess of pixels. It would lag every few seconds. The "interactive" element where users vote in real-time? Forget about it. The lag alone makes the concept of a "murder show" technically unfeasible in the way it's described in urban legends.
Security experts like Chris Monteiro, who has spent years debunking dark web myths, have repeatedly pointed out that these sites are honeypots or scams. There has never been a verified, documented case of a live-streamed murder for hire or "Red Room" discovered by law enforcement. Not one.
The Infamous Cases People Get Wrong
People often bring up Peter Scully or the "A0P3" site as "proof" that these shows are real.
Let's look at Peter Scully. He was a real-life monster who produced horrific videos in the Philippines. However, he wasn't live-streaming. He was recording content and then distributing the files later. That’s a massive distinction. The horror of his crimes is real, but it wasn't a "Red Room" interactive show.
📖 Related: Weird things in the sky: Why most sightings aren't actually aliens
Then you have the sites like "Shadow Web" or "Cruel World." These sites popped up with flashy graphics and terrifying descriptions. They asked for 1 BTC for entry. When people paid, they got nothing. Or, they were redirected to a video of a jump-scare. These are "scares" or "LARPs" (Live Action Role Plays) designed to build a reputation or just troll the curious.
The internet thrives on mystery. We want to believe there’s a secret, dark corner of the web where the laws of physics and society don't apply. But the "deep web murder show" is largely a creation of creepy-pasta writers and bored forum users.
The Mechanics of the Scam
How do these scammers actually catch people? Usually, it starts on a forum like Dread or a random clearnet site like 4chan. Someone posts a link to a "hidden" service.
- The site usually has a minimalist aesthetic.
- Black background, red text—very cliché.
- A "Rules" page that sounds like it was written by a 14-year-old.
- A massive Bitcoin or Monero address.
They rely on the "forbidden fruit" effect. You feel like you're seeing something you're not supposed to see. That adrenaline rush makes people ignore the red flags. Honestly, if you're willing to pay money to watch someone get hurt, you're probably not the type to report the scam to the police. The scammers know this. It’s the perfect crime because the victim is legally and morally compromised just by trying to access the content.
Real Dark Web Dangers vs. Fiction
The dark web is a real place with real problems, but it’s mostly boring stuff like stolen credit card numbers, drug marketplaces, and database leaks.
The focus on "murder shows" actually distracts from the real digital threats. While people are looking for mythical Red Rooms, they're ignoring the fact that their own data is being sold for five cents on a forum that looks like it was made in 1995.
We also have to consider the psychological impact of these myths. They create a "boogeyman" version of the internet that prevents people from understanding how digital privacy and encryption actually work. Tor is a vital tool for journalists and whistleblowers in oppressive regimes. When we associate it exclusively with "murder shows," we play into a narrative that suggests encryption is only for criminals.
The Bottom Line on Red Rooms
So, are there "Red Rooms"?
If you define it as a live-streamed, interactive snuff film on the Tor network: No. If you define it as a way for scammers to trick people out of their crypto: Yes.
The technology doesn't support it, the evidence doesn't exist, and the logistics make no sense. Think about it. Why would a criminal risk the massive digital footprint of a live stream when they could just record a file and sell it on an encrypted messaging app like Telegram? They wouldn't. It’s a bad business model.
How to Protect Yourself and Stay Informed
If you're curious about the dark web or cybersecurity, don't go chasing urban legends. You’ll likely end up with malware or a drained wallet. Instead, focus on the real mechanics of online safety.
📖 Related: The Final Frontier Meaning: Why We Can’t Stop Looking at the Stars
- Use a VPN and Tor for privacy, not for "sightseeing." Understand the tools before you use them.
- Verify sources. Sites like DarknetStats or reputable cybersecurity blogs track real threats, not ghost stories.
- Don't send crypto to unknown addresses. This should go without saying, but if a site asks for payment before showing you anything, it’s 100% a scam.
- Educate yourself on "Creepypasta" vs. Reality. Distinguish between entertainment (like the "NoEnd House" or "The Russian Sleep Experiment") and actual criminal reports from agencies like Interpol or the FBI.
The most dangerous thing on the deep web isn't a mythical murder show—it's your own curiosity leading you into a very real financial trap. Stay skeptical. If it sounds like a movie plot, it probably is.