You’re riding through the Heartlands, minding your own business, when you hear a raspy voice shouting about a "valuable document." Most people just keep riding. That’s their first mistake. In Red Dead Redemption 2, those red dead treasure maps aren't just collectibles meant to pad out your completion percentage; they are the fastest way to turn Arthur Morgan from a broke outlaw into a man with thousands of dollars in his satchel.
It's honestly wild how many players struggle with these. They stare at a drawing of a rock that looks like every other rock in New Hanover and eventually give up, Googling the answer five minutes later. But there’s a specific logic to how Rockstar Games designed these hunts. They aren't random. They are grounded in the game's geography, often using "weird" landmarks that you've probably passed a dozen times without a second thought.
If you’ve ever found yourself squinting at the Jack Hall Gang map trying to figure out which twin hill it’s talking about, you aren't alone. It’s supposed to be hard.
The Reality of Hunting Red Dead Treasure Maps
Let’s be real: the rewards are insane. We’re talking gold bars. In a world where a decent horse costs a few hundred bucks and a bounty can be cleared for fifty, finding a stash of three or four gold bars—which sell for $500 each at any Fence—is a literal game-changer.
Most people start with the Jack Hall Gang maps. You meet a guy named Maximo on a cliffside early in Chapter 2. He tries to sell you the map for ten dollars. Buy it. If you kill him or rob him, that's fine too, but get the paper. This specific hunt teaches you the "language" of the game's treasure system. It points you toward Caliban's Seat. You have to look at the profile of the mountain, not just the top of it.
👉 See also: Why Too Many Kid YouTubers Try to Steer Them to Roblox and What Parents Miss
The verticality of these hunts is what usually trips people up. You aren't just looking for a spot on the ground. You’re looking for a crevice in a rock face or a hollowed-out tree that requires a bit of platforming. Arthur isn't exactly a parkour master, so one wrong step at Cotorra Springs or the cliffside of the High Stakes treasure usually ends in a "Game Over" screen and a very dead horse.
Why the High Stakes Map is a Total Nightmare
The High Stakes treasure is probably the most frustrating one for casual players. First, you have to find the Random Encounter with the grumpy old explorer. He’s usually near Wallace Station or Cumberland Falls, muttering to himself and looking through binoculars. If you don't grab him when you see him, he can be a pain to track down again.
The final location? It’s tucked away on a narrow ledge at Monto's Rest. One slip. That's all it takes.
The map itself is a mess of scribbles that barely resemble the actual terrain. This is where the game gets clever. It forces you to recognize silhouettes. If you aren't looking at the horizon lines, you’re going to get lost. It’s also worth noting that these maps are tiered. You can't just run to the final location and dig. The game’s code won't let the gold "spawn" until you have the physical map for that specific step in your inventory. You have to do the work. No shortcuts allowed, which is kinda annoying but keeps the immersion intact.
The Le Tresor Des Morts Controversy
There is a bit of a weird situation with the Le Tresor Des Morts map. If you didn't pre-order the Special or Ultimate Edition, or if you aren't playing on PC/Stadia (rest in peace), you basically can't get it. It’s a bummer because it’s one of the few treasures that actually takes you into the burnt-out remains of Limpany and the docks of Saint Denis.
It feels different from the others. It’s more urban. More "National Treasure" than "Mountain Man." If you do have access to it, the payout is five gold bars. That is $2,500. You can basically buy every upgrade for the camp in one go.
Landmarks That Aren't Just Scenery
To master red dead treasure maps, you have to stop looking at the world as a playground and start looking at it as a map.
Take the Poisonous Trail hunt. This is the big one. It starts way up north at Cairn Lake, inside a frozen cabin. The final destination is behind a waterfall at Elysian Pool. But it’s the middle steps that mess with people. Face Rock? It actually looks like a face. If you’re riding too fast, you miss the geological features that Rockstar spent years rendering.
- The Obelisk: Found on the far western edge of the map, north of Owanjila. It’s a key part of the Landmark Riches hunt.
- The Sundial: Located on the peak of Mount Shann. It’s not just for UFO sightings; it’s a directional tool for the Mended Map.
- The Church: The tiny church in Lakay. It’s creepy, sure, but it’s also a landmark for several smaller hidden stashes.
Honestly, the sheer detail is overwhelming. You might find a map tucked into a chimney of a ruined house (like the one at Burned Town) or hidden under a loose floorboard. The game rewards curiosity, but it punishes impatience.
The Strange Statues Puzzle: The "Secret" Map
Technically, this isn't a traditional paper map hunt, but it functions exactly like one. In a cave near Donner Falls, there are seven statues surrounding a central figure. It’s a math puzzle. You have to count the fingers.
Wait, let me rephrase that: you have to count the fingers that aren't broken off.
It’s the most "Indiana Jones" moment in the entire game. If you press the buttons in the right order (2, 3, 5, 7—the prime numbers), the center statue opens up. You get three gold bars. It’s fast, it’s lucrative, and most players never find the cave because the entrance is a tiny slit in the rock that looks like a texture glitch.
How to Actually Succeed Without a Guide
If you want to do this the "real" way, stop using your mini-map.
Seriously. Pull out the physical map in Arthur's hand. Look at the drawings. Look at the trees in the drawing—are they pine trees or oaks? If they’re pines, you’re too far south. Are there mountains in the background? Look at the shape of the peaks. If the peak on your map has a "thumb" shape and the one in front of you doesn't, turn around.
📖 Related: Why Everyone Gets the Witch of the Willows Wrong
Also, use your binoculars. They aren't just for scouting O'Driscoll camps. From a high vantage point, you can often spot the exact rock formation from a map miles away.
Common Mistakes and Misconceptions
One of the biggest lies people believe is that you can find these treasures as John Marston only. That’s false. Arthur can get almost all of them, except for the ones strictly locked in New Austin (like the Elemental Trail). In fact, it’s better to get them as Arthur. Why? Because the money helps you buy better gear, better horses, and more ammunition for the mid-game missions where the difficulty spikes.
Another mistake? Selling the maps. Don't do it. You can't really "sell" them in a traditional sense to most vendors, but people sometimes discard them or forget them in the satchel.
Also, keep an eye on your "Treasure Hunter" challenge rank. Finding these is the only way to level up that specific branch of the Explorer challenges, which eventually grants you the Explorer Holster and increased stamina. It’s all connected.
Actionable Steps for Your Next Session
If you’re sitting at your console or PC right now, here is exactly what you should do to maximize your haul:
- Head to Limpany first. It’s the burnt-out town near Horseshoe Overlook. There’s a gold bar in the Sheriff’s office under the desk. No map required for this one, but it’s the "seed money" you need.
- Find Maximo. He’s on the cliffs overlooking the Dakota River. Buy the Jack Hall Gang Map 1.
- Go to Caliban's Seat. Don't go to the top; look for the path that leads around the side of the cliff. Look for the white chalk markings.
- Check the "Strange Statues" cave. It’s east of Donner Falls, tucked into the mountainside. Use a lantern. The prime number sequence (2, 3, 5, 7) will give you $1,500 in about two minutes.
- Visit the Fence. Never carry more than two gold bars at a time if you’re playing "dishonorably." If you get killed by bounty hunters, you won't lose the gold, but it’s always better to have the cash converted and "banked" by buying upgrades or clothing.
The world of Red Dead is massive, but it’s the small, hand-drawn squares of paper that make it feel alive. These maps force you to slow down. They make you look at the sunset not just because it’s pretty, but because the light hitting a certain rock might just reveal the location of a fortune. Happy hunting. Look for the rocks that look like they don't belong. They usually don't.