Let’s be real for a second. You probably spent hours hunting down that White Arabian up by Lake Isabella because some YouTuber told you it was the best horse in the game. You braved the snow, did the slow-walk taming dance, and felt like a god.
Then you got into a shootout or saw a wolf, and that "best" horse bucked you faster than Arthur can say "outta the way."
Finding the right Red Dead Redemption horses isn't actually about looking at the highest speed bar in the menu. Rockstar Games packed so much hidden math and "feel" into these animals that the stats are almost a lie. I've spent hundreds of hours in the saddle, across both the main story and Online, and the truth is that a horse's bravery and frame size matter way more than a tiny sliver of top speed that you'll barely notice across the heartlands.
The Arabian Trap and Why Speed is Overrated
Speed is a scam. Well, not a total scam, but it's definitely not what you should base your entire playthrough on. If you compare a horse with 4 speed to one with 7 speed over a long distance—say, from Saint Denis to Valentine—the difference is usually only a handful of seconds. It's negligible. What actually kills you in this game isn't being slow; it's running out of stamina or getting tossed into the mud because your horse got spooked by a literal pebble.
The White Arabian is the poster child for this. It’s fast. It’s pretty. It’s also tiny. Arthur looks like he’s riding a pony, and the Arabian’s temperament is famously skittish. If a cougar even breathes in your direction, an Arabian is going to panic.
Better alternatives for the early game
If you want something that won't lose its mind during a bounty hunt, look at the Dutch Warmblood or the Thoroughbred. The Thoroughbred you can occasionally find in the wild or steal has decent height and solid acceleration. It feels like a "real" horse. The Dutch Warmblood, specifically the Sooty Buckskin you can get early on, is a workhorse. It doesn't have the "Elite" handling of the Arabian, but it’s sturdy.
Honestly, the Hungarian Halfbred is one of the most slept-on Red Dead Redemption horses. It’s a War horse class. That means it’s built to stay calm when guns start going off. You can find these during certain early-game missions or just by poking around the stables in Valentine later on.
Hidden Stats: Bravery and Size Matter
There has been a long-standing debate in the RDR2 community about whether "Bravery" is a real, coded stat or just placebo. While it’s not a visible bar in the UI like Health or Stamina, the way different breeds react to predators is night and day.
Take the Shire. It’s the biggest horse in the game. It’s "slow." But there is something deeply satisfying about trampling through a forest on a literal tank. When you’re on a Shire, you feel untouchable. If you’re playing the story, Hosea gives you a black Raven Black Shire in Chapter 2. The game tells you to sell it. Don't. You can't get that specific coat again, and it’s one of the most imposing animals in the entire world of RDR2.
Handling Types Explained
- Standard: Most horses. Reliable, predictable.
- Race: Very twitchy. They turn on a dime but can feel "thin" or fragile.
- Work: Slower to turn, but they don't lose stamina as quickly when doing heavy lifting.
- Heavy: These feel like driving a bus, but they are incredibly stable.
- Elite: Only the Arabians. Extremely responsive, almost to a fault.
You’ve gotta find the balance. For me, the Turkoman is the sweet spot. It’s a mix of War and Race. It has the speed of a top-tier mount but the courage of a soldier’s horse. You won't get it until later in the game (unless you use the Saint Denis horse spawn glitch, which Rockstar has mostly patched out anyway), but it's worth the wait.
The Best Red Dead Redemption Horses by Use Case
Not everyone plays the same way. If you’re just a collector, you want the rare coats. If you’re a hunter, you want something that won’t bolt when you fire a Springfield rifle.
🔗 Read more: LEGO Skywalker Saga Cheat Codes: What Most Players Actually Get Wrong
For the Story Mode Completionist
The Missouri Fox Trotter is widely considered the actual "best" horse by high-level players. Specifically the Amber Champagne or Silver Dapple Pinto. It has a high base speed but, crucially, it’s a Work/Race hybrid. It’s got a bit more backbone than the Arabian. You usually can't buy it until Chapter 4, but if you see one, grab it.
For the Online Grinder
In Red Dead Online, things change a bit because of the Mustang. After the Bounty Hunters update a while back, the new Mustang coats (like the Buckskin or Red Dun Overo) became absolute beasts. They have full Health and Stamina bars at Level 4 bonding. That is insane for a horse that doesn't cost gold bars.
For the Aesthetic
If you just want to look cool, the Andalusian (Rose Gray) or the Ardennes are the way to go. These are thick, muscular horses. They look like they belong in a Western. There is something fundamentally wrong about Arthur Morgan—a man who eats plain griddle cakes and sleeps in the dirt—riding a dainty, pampered Arabian.
Bonding: It's More Than Just a Level
You need to hit Level 4 bonding as fast as possible. Most people know this. But people forget that bonding unlocks the actual mechanics that make Red Dead Redemption horses usable.
- Level 2: The Rear. Useful for looking cool, but also for making quick turns if you’re trapped in a corner.
- Level 3: The Skid Turn/Skid Stop. This is vital. If you’re galloping toward a cliff or a tree, the skid stop saves your life.
- Level 4: The Piaffe. Basically a side-step. It’s great for repositioning during a gunfight without turning your whole body.
To level this up quickly, don't just ride. Lead your horse. If you get off and lead the horse by the bridle while walking, the bonding points tick up significantly faster than just riding. Also, brush them. Every time you get off, brush and feed. It’s a tiny time investment that pays off when your horse gains that extra heart tank that saves you from a stray O'Driscoll bullet.
Saddles: The Secret Weapon
If you have a mediocre horse, a great saddle can make it top-tier. In the base game, the pre-crafted saddles from the Trapper are actually better than almost anything you can buy at the stable. The Panther Trail Saddle is arguably the best in the game. It gives you massive boosts to stamina regeneration.
In Red Dead Online, it's the Nacogdoches saddle. Period. Pair it with the Hooded Stirrups. It’s ugly as sin, but it basically gives your horse infinite stamina. You can gallop from Tumbleweed to Annesburg without ever stopping. It breaks the game’s balance, honestly, but if you’re trying to make money, it’s a necessity.
What Most People Get Wrong About Horse Death
It’s heartbreaking. We’ve all been there. You’re riding through the woods, a cinematic camera kicks in, and suddenly you’ve flown off a bridge.
Always carry at least three Horse Revivers. You can buy them at any stable or general store. If your horse goes down, you have a limited window to save them. If you’re in a gunfight and your horse is downed, ignore the enemies for a second and get that medicine into the horse. You can replace a hat. You can’t replace a fully bonded Missouri Fox Trotter without spending another 10 hours of your life.
📖 Related: Why an Odds to Probability Calculator is Your Only Real Edge in Betting
Also, be careful with trains. The AI for Red Dead Redemption horses is usually okay, but they have a weird tendency to get sucked into the physics of a moving train if you whistle for them while you’re onboard. I’ve lost more horses to the Saint Denis trolley than I care to admit.
Actionable Steps for Your Next Session
If you’re tired of your current mount and want to upgrade your experience, follow this specific path:
- Check your stable: If you're still on the Chapter 1 horse, go to the wild area near the "A" in Ambarino. Look for the Percheron or a wild Mustang. They are tougher and will give you a better feel for the game's physics.
- Visit the Trapper: Stop wasting money on basic stable saddles. Hunt a perfect Beaver or Panther pelt and get a custom saddle. The stamina drain reduction is a game-changer.
- Manual Save: This is the "expert" tip. The game’s autosave is aggressive. If your horse dies, it often saves immediately after. If you care about your horse, make a manual save every time you start a session.
- Calm while riding: Get into the habit of clicking the Left Stick (L3) rhythmically while galloping. This "calms" the horse and actually restores a small chunk of stamina. You can keep a horse at a full gallop indefinitely if you time your clicks with the gallop's rhythm.
- Evaluate the "Fit": Stand Arthur next to the horse. If it looks like a toy, it's going to act like a toy in a fight. Look for the breeds with "War" in the description if you plan on doing a lot of bounty hunting or story missions.
The best horse isn't the one with the highest price tag. It's the one that stays under you when the bullets start flying and the wolves start howling. Stop chasing the Arabian and find a mount that actually fits the life of an outlaw.