If you spend any time around the Shore Conference, you know the vibe. Walking into the Eck Center on a Tuesday night feels a little different than your average high school gym. There’s this heavy, expectant silence right before tip-off that only exists in places where winning isn’t just hoped for—it’s basically the tax you pay for wearing the jersey. Red Bank Catholic girls basketball isn't just a "good program." It’s a machine. But honestly, it’s a machine with a lot of soul, a lot of history, and a chip on its shoulder that never seems to go away regardless of how many trophies they put in the lobby.
The Caseys have this reputation for being "The Empire." You either love them or you're desperately trying to find a way to take them down. Usually, it’s the latter.
The Standard of the Shore
New Jersey high school basketball is a gauntlet. If you aren't ready to play, you get exposed in about four minutes. For Red Bank Catholic, the standard was set decades ago, but it’s the consistency that really messes with people's heads. They don't have "rebuilding years." They have "slightly younger but still dangerous" years.
Look at the 2023-2024 season. People thought maybe, just maybe, there was a window for someone else to slide into that top spot. Then the Caseys go out and grab the Non-Public A state title, finishing with a 26-5 record and a Top 5 ranking in the state. It wasn't just that they won; it was how they did it. They play this suffocating, high-IQ style of ball that makes opponents feel like they’re playing in a phone booth.
Coaching and the Joe Montano Legacy
You can’t talk about RBC without talking about Joe Montano. He’s surpassed 700 career wins. Think about that number for a second. To get to 700, you have to be more than just a good X’s and O’s guy. You have to be a master of culture. Montano has this way of demanding absolute perfection without sounding like a drill sergeant—though he’s certainly capable of that too.
It's about the "extra pass." In an era of AAU highlights and isolation ball, RBC plays a brand of basketball that looks like it was choreographed. They find the open shooter. They rotate on defense like they’re tied together by an invisible string.
The Talent Pipeline is Real
Why does Red Bank Catholic girls basketball stay at the top? It’s not just luck. The school draws from all over Monmouth and Ocean counties. If you’re a serious middle school player in the area, you’re looking at RBC because you know that’s where you go to get recruited.
✨ Don't miss: What Time Did the Cubs Game End Today? The Truth About the Off-Season
- Tessa Carman: A name that has been ringing in the ears of Shore fans for years. She’s the prototype of a modern Casey—tough, versatile, and high-motor.
- Addy Nyemchek: Coming into her own as one of the most lethal guards in the state. Her ability to handle pressure is what keeps the offense humming.
- The Depth: This is where they kill you. Most teams have two stars. RBC has a rotation of eight girls who could all start for 90% of the other teams in the state.
I remember watching a game against St. John Vianney—the eternal rivalry—and noticing that even when the Caseys' starters were catching a breather, the intensity didn't drop. That’s the "next man up" philosophy in its purest form. It’s also why they tend to pull away in the fourth quarter. They just wear you down.
Breaking Down the "SJV vs. RBC" Rivalry
If you want to understand the soul of Jersey hoops, you have to watch Red Bank Catholic play St. John Vianney. It’s the Yankees vs. Red Sox of the Shore. It’s personal.
For years, SJV had this incredible stranglehold on the No. 1 spot, but RBC has been the primary antagonist in that story. Every time they meet, the gym is over capacity. People are standing in the aisles. It’s loud. It’s hot. It’s glorious. The 2024 Shore Conference Tournament final was a perfect example. While RBC fell short in a 41-35 defensive struggle, the level of play was basically college-level. The defensive rotations were so crisp it felt like watching a chess match where the pieces were moving at 20 miles per hour.
Why the Non-Public A Title Mattered So Much
Winning the Non-Public A title in 2024 over Immaculate Heart Academy (IHA) was a statement. It wasn't just a trophy; it was a reminder. RBC won 63-43, and it wasn't even that close. They shot the lights out.
That game showed the world that RBC isn't just a "Shore team." They are a state powerhouse. When you can dismantle a program like IHA on a neutral floor in a championship setting, you've reached a different level of elite.
It’s also about the schedule. Montano doesn't schedule cupcakes. He’ll take the girls to play national powerhouses in D.C. or Delaware just to see how they handle the heat. They take losses in January so they can take trophies in March. It’s a calculated risk that almost always pays off.
🔗 Read more: Jake Ehlinger Sign: The Real Story Behind the College GameDay Controversy
The Mental Game
Most people focus on the shooting or the rebounding. Honestly? The biggest advantage Red Bank Catholic girls basketball has is mental.
They expect to win.
When a team walks into the gym and sees "RBC" on the jersey, they’re already down by five points. There’s a psychological weight to playing against a legacy. The Caseys know this. They use it. They play with a level of confidence that borders on arrogance, but they back it up with a work rate that is honestly kind of exhausting to watch from the sidelines.
The Future of the Program
Is the dynasty slowing down? Short answer: No.
The youth movement in Red Bank is strong. The freshman and sophomore classes currently in the building are loaded with multi-sport athletes who bring a level of physicality that’s hard to teach. Plus, the school's commitment to the program is top-tier. The facilities, the scouting, the film sessions—it’s run like a mid-major college program.
If you’re a parent of a young player or just a fan, here is what you need to keep an eye on:
💡 You might also like: What Really Happened With Nick Chubb: The Injury, The Recovery, and The Houston Twist
- Transition Offense: Watch how fast they turn a defensive rebound into a layup. It's usually under four seconds.
- Corner Threes: RBC has mastered the geometry of the court. They almost always have a dead-eye shooter waiting in the corner.
- The Press: They don't always use it, but when they do, it’s a trap-heavy 1-2-2 that causes absolute chaos for inexperienced point guards.
Real Talk: The Challenges
It’s not all sunshine and banners. The pressure to perform at RBC is immense. These girls are balancing high-level academics with a basketball schedule that looks like a professional itinerary. There’s also the target on their back. Every single night, they get the opponent’s absolute best game. Teams circle the RBC game on their calendar the moment the schedule is released.
That constant pressure can lead to burnout, but the coaching staff seems to manage it by keeping the atmosphere around the team tight-knit. They call it a "sisterhood" for a reason. You see the alumni coming back for games. You see former players coaching in the local Shore leagues. The circle stays small.
How to Follow the Caseys
If you want to actually see what the hype is about, you've got to get to a game. Following them on social media is fine, but the atmosphere is the real draw.
- Check the Schedule: Use the NJSIAA or Shore Conference websites.
- The Big Games: Look for the matchups against St. John Vianney, Manasquan, or Rumson-Fair Haven. Those are the ones that matter.
- Streaming: Many games are now on the NFHS Network or local Shore sports YouTube channels if you can’t make the drive to Red Bank.
The reality of Red Bank Catholic girls basketball is that it’s a blueprint for how to build something that lasts. In a world where kids transfer every five minutes and coaches quit after two seasons, RBC stands as this weirdly stable, incredibly successful outlier.
Actionable Steps for Aspiring Players and Fans
To truly understand or engage with a program of this caliber, you have to look beyond the scoreboard. Whether you're a player hoping to wear the green and gold or a fan of the sport, here’s how to lean in:
- Study the "Off-Ball" Movement: If you’re a young player, don't watch the girl with the ball when you go to an RBC game. Watch the other four. Watch how they set screens and cut to the basket. That’s why they win.
- Attend the Summer Camps: RBC runs some of the best clinics in the state. It’s the best way to get a feel for the coaching style and the expectations of the program.
- Support Shore Hoops: The Caseys are part of a larger ecosystem. Supporting the Shore Conference as a whole elevates the competition for everyone, which is exactly what keeps RBC sharp.
- Focus on Defense First: If you want to play for a guy like Montano, you have to be able to guard. He’s gone on record multiple times saying that defense is the price of admission to his rotation.
The story of the Caseys isn't over—not by a long shot. Every season is just another chapter in a book that’s already several hundred pages deep. Whether you're rooting for them or against them, you have to respect the grind. They’ve earned it.
Keep an eye on the state rankings as the season progresses. The Caseys are usually lurking right near the top, waiting for the playoffs to prove everyone right (or wrong) all over again.
Next Steps for the Savvy Fan:
To keep up with the latest roster changes and mid-season stats, regularly check the Asbury Park Press (APP) sports section and NJ.com's high school sports database. These outlets provide the most granular detail on box scores and player performance for Red Bank Catholic throughout the winter months. If you're looking to see them in person, ticket priority is often given to students and families, so plan your arrival at least 45 minutes early for high-profile rivalry games to secure a seat in the bleachers.