You’re standing in the grocery aisle, squinting at a label for cherry-flavored fruit snacks or maybe a bottle of bright red sports drink. You see it. Red 40. Or maybe it’s Red 3. Honestly, most of us just see "red dye" and move on, but there’s a massive gap between these two chemicals that’s currently causing a localized panic in state legislatures and school boards across the country.
The difference between red 3 and red 40 isn't just a number on a bottle. It's the difference between a dye that's been banned from your lipstick for thirty years and one that’s still sitting in roughly half of all dyed snacks in the United States.
Why does one get a pass while the other is being chased out of California by new laws? It’s a mess of 1960s chemistry, bureaucratic loopholes, and some pretty concerning data about how our brains—and our kids' brains—react to these synthetic molecules.
The Chemistry of Red 3 vs Red 40
Let’s get technical for a second, but not too boring.
Red 3, also known as Erythrosine, is an organoiodine compound. It’s derived from petroleum, sure, but its defining feature is that it contains iodine. It’s got this incredibly vibrant, cherry-pink hue. You’ll find it in those bright maraschino cherries that look like they’d glow in the dark, or in seasonal Peeps. It’s sticky. It’s intense. And back in 1990, the FDA actually banned it—but only for use in cosmetics and topically applied drugs.
The weird part? They didn't ban it in food.
Because of a weird legal quirk, the FDA acknowledged Red 3 caused cancer in laboratory rats (specifically thyroid tumors) but allowed it to stay in our food supply while "further studies" were conducted. That was over three decades ago. We’re still waiting.
Red 40, or Allura Red AC, is the heavyweight champion. It is the most common food dye in the world. Unlike its cousin, it’s an azo dye. It doesn't have the iodine; instead, it’s a naphthalene-based substance. If you see something red and it’s not a cherry or a radish, it’s almost certainly Red 40. It’s cheaper to produce and more stable under heat and light, which is why Big Food loves it.
The Thyroid vs. The Brain
When we talk about the difference between red 3 and red 40, we’re really talking about two different types of health risks.
Red 3 is the "cancer" dye. That sounds scary because it is. In the late 80s, studies showed that high doses of Erythrosine led to thyroid secondary tumorigenesis in male rats. The FDA’s own scientists concluded it was a carcinogen. This is why you can't put Red 3 on your skin as a blush, but you can still eat it in a fruit cocktail. Makes total sense, right? Not really.
Red 40 is a different beast. The "C-word" doesn't stick to it as easily, though some consumer advocacy groups like the Center for Science in the Public Interest (CSPI) argue it’s contaminated with low-level carcinogens like benzidine. The real fight over Red 40 is about behavior.
You’ve probably heard a parent say, "My kid goes crazy after eating red cupcakes." For years, doctors dismissed this as the "sugar rush" myth. But a massive 2021 report from the California Office of Environmental Health Hazard Assessment (OEHHA) basically vindicated those parents. After reviewing decades of data, they found that synthetic food dyes, led by Red 40, can absolutely trigger or worsen hyperactivity and attention issues in some children.
It’s not just a "high." It’s a neurochemical disruption.
Why is Red 40 Everywhere While Red 3 is Fading?
Money. It always comes down to that.
Red 40 is incredibly versatile. It gives you that deep, "cool" red in sodas and the "warm" orange-red in nacho cheese chips. Because it’s an azo dye, it blends well. Red 3 is finicky. It’s mostly used when a manufacturer needs a very specific, light-stable pinkish-red that doesn't bleed. Think of the pink frosting on a grocery store cookie.
👉 See also: 82 Kilograms to Pounds: Why This Specific Number Matters in Your Fitness Journey
However, the tide is turning. California recently passed the California Food Free Act, which officially bans Red 3 (along with three other additives) starting in 2027. This is a huge deal. Manufacturers aren't going to make one version of a Skittle for California and another for Nevada. They’ll just change the recipe for everyone.
Noticeably, Red 40 survived that ban. Why? Because the evidence against it is considered "behavioral" rather than "carcinogenic." In the eyes of the law, making a kid hyper isn't the same as giving a rat a tumor.
Spotting Them in the Wild
You have to be a detective to find these.
Red 3 is often hidden in:
- Maraschino cherries (the neon ones)
- Cake decorating gels
- Seasonal candies (Valentine’s hearts, Easter treats)
- Some canned fruits
- Sausage casings (sometimes)
Red 40 is in... everything else.
- Doritos
- Takis
- Gatorade
- Strawberry milk
- Cereals like Lucky Charms or Trix
- Children’s Tylenol and cough syrups
It’s actually wild how many "health" products for kids use Red 40 just to make the medicine look like berries.
The European Divide
If you go to London and buy a bag of Skittles, they look dull. They’re kind of brownish-purple. That’s because the EU basically forced a "soft ban" on these dyes. In Europe, if a product contains Red 40 (Allura Red), it must carry a warning label stating: "May have an adverse effect on activity and attention in children."
Unsurprisingly, most companies decided to just use carrot juice or turmeric for color instead of slapping a warning label on their boxes. In the US, we don't have those labels. We just have the ingredient list in 6-point font.
What Should You Actually Do?
Look, eating a handful of Red 40 chips once a month isn't going to kill you. The human body is pretty resilient. But if you have a kid who struggles with focus, or if you’re trying to minimize your intake of known petroleum derivatives, the difference between red 3 and red 40 matters for your shopping list.
Actionable Steps for the Grocery Store:
1. The "Cherry" Rule
If you’re buying cherries in a jar, look for "Bordeaux" cherries or brands like Tillen Farms that use beet juice. If the ingredients say Red 3, put it back. There is zero reason to eat a known carcinogen just so your garnish looks brighter.
2. Check the "Health" Foods
You’d be shocked how many "low-fat" strawberry yogurts or "fruit" snacks use Red 40 to make up for the lack of actual fruit. If the color looks too perfect to be real, it probably is.
3. Use the 2027 Benchmark
Since California’s ban on Red 3 is looming, many brands are already swapping it out. If you see a brand bragging about "No Artificial Colors," they are usually the safer bet, but verify. Sometimes they swap Red 40 for Carmine.
4. Carmine: The Hidden Third Option
Keep an eye out for "Carmine" or "Cochineal Extract." It’s a natural red dye. But... it’s made from crushed bugs (Dactylopius coccus). It’s perfectly safe for most people, but if you’re vegan or keep Kosher/Halal, you’ll want to avoid this just as much as the synthetic stuff.
The reality is that our food system is slow to change. The FDA moves at a glacial pace, and lobbyists for the chemical industry are powerful. While Red 3 is likely on its deathbed in the US market, Red 40 is going to be around for a long time.
Being aware of the difference between red 3 and red 40 isn't about being a health nut. It’s about knowing what you’re putting into your system. We’ve spent forty years treating these chemicals as "generally recognized as safe," but the more we look at the data, the more that "safe" label starts to look like a placeholder.
🔗 Read more: Travis Jefferies Born With HIV: What Many People Still Get Wrong
Choose the beet-dyed snack. Your thyroid (and your kid's teacher) will probably thank you.
Next Steps for Your Kitchen:
- Scan your pantry for anything containing "Erythrosine" or "Red 3" and consider tossing it, especially if it's past its prime.
- For baking, pick up a bottle of plant-based food coloring (usually made from beets, cabbage, and annatto) to replace the cheap neon dyes.
- Download an app like Yuka or EWG’s Food Scores; they let you scan barcodes to instantly see if a product contains these specific dyes without needing to read the tiny print.