When you look back at the glossy, diamond-encrusted history of the 90210, most people point to the "Dinner Party From Hell" or the arrival of Erika Jayne as the show's defining moments. But honestly? Real Housewives of Beverly Hills Season 4 is where the tectonic plates actually shifted. It was messy. It was uncomfortable. It gave us some of the most bizarre casting choices in the history of Bravo, and yet, it serves as the blueprint for every "gang up" storyline we’ve seen since.
If you weren't there in 2013, it's hard to describe the vibe. The show was coming off a heavy, dark third season dominated by Taylor Armstrong’s tragic personal life and Adrienne Maloof’s litigious exit. We needed a palate cleanser. Instead, we got a civil war.
The Witch Hunt That Redefined the Show
Carlton Gebbia. Just saying the name brings back images of gothic crosses, pentagrams, and a very confused Kyle Richards. Season 4 of the Real Housewives of Beverly Hills introduced Carlton as the "Wiccan" housewife, and she was basically Kyle’s worst nightmare. It wasn’t just about the religion, though that played a huge part in the friction. It was about the fact that Carlton seemed to decide, before even meeting Kyle, that she was going to be her antagonist.
This season marked the first time we saw a housewife—Kyle—genuinely afraid of another woman’s "energy." Remember the dream? Carlton claimed she had a dream about Kyle being a "bigot," and that was basically the end of their relationship. It sounds ridiculous now, but at the time, it created this weird, supernatural tension that the show hasn't really revisited. It felt less like a reality show and more like a low-budget horror movie filmed in a mansion with a stripper pole in the bedroom.
The Fall of the Lisa Vanderpump Empire
Most fans forget that Real Housewives of Beverly Hills Season 4 was the first time we saw the "Goodbye, Kyle!" energy directed at Lisa Vanderpump. Before this, Lisa was the untouchable queen. She had the witty one-liners, the tiny dogs, and the perfect husband. But the Puerto Rico trip changed everything.
🔗 Read more: All I Watch for Christmas: What You’re Missing About the TBS Holiday Tradition
You've got Brandi Glanville, who was once Lisa’s fiercest soldier, turning on her. The accusation? That Lisa had put "tabloids" in Brandi’s suitcase to stir up drama about Mauricio Umansky’s alleged infidelity. Whether she did it or not is still debated in Reddit threads today, but the impact was massive. It was the first time the "Dream Team" (Lisa, Brandi, and Yolanda) completely disintegrated. Watching Yolanda Hadid—then Foster—calmly tell Lisa that she was "the puppet master" was a turning point. It stripped away the invincibility of the Vanderpump brand.
Joyce Giraud and the Branding Problem
Then there was Joyce. Joyce Giraud de Osmann was a former Miss Puerto Rico, stunningly beautiful, and had hair that literally had its own zip code. On paper, she was the perfect housewife. In reality, she was eaten alive by the veterans.
Brandi Glanville’s behavior toward Joyce was, frankly, hard to watch. From the "Jacqueline" name-calling to the comments about Joyce not being able to swim because she’s "Black"—it was a PR disaster for the network. Brandi’s "truth cannon" started looking more like a liability. It exposed a certain undercurrent of the show that wasn't just "catty drama"; it was genuinely mean-spirited. Joyce tried to fight back with her "You can never be too thin, too rich, or too beautiful" mantra, but she was outmatched by the sheer aggression of the group.
Why the Reunion Was a Bloodbath
Andy Cohen looked tired during this reunion. You can see it in his eyes. Usually, there’s a bit of fun, but the Season 4 reunion was a four-hour (okay, it felt like four hours) exercise in isolation. Lisa Vanderpump was on an island. Carlton was defensive. Brandi was spiraling.
💡 You might also like: Al Pacino Angels in America: Why His Roy Cohn Still Terrifies Us
The most telling part of this era was the lack of resolution. Usually, these women find a way to "move forward," even if it’s fake. After Season 4, the producers realized they couldn't keep this cast together. Both Carlton and Joyce were fired after just one season. It remains one of the few times Bravo has done a "double firing" of the new girls, essentially admitting that the chemistry was completely broken.
The Subtle Excellence of Kim Richards
While everyone was fighting about tabloids and spells, Kim Richards was actually having her most lucid season. We saw her navigating sobriety, dealing with her children growing up, and trying to find her own voice outside of Kyle’s shadow. Her interactions with Ken Todd—Lisa’s husband—at the reunion were legendary. When Ken called her "crazy," Kim didn't skip a beat. She stood her ground in a way that signaled she wasn't the "weak" sister anymore.
Real Housewives of Beverly Hills Season 4 Legacy
If you're rewatching now, pay attention to the editing. This was the year the producers started leaning into the "meta" aspect of the show. They started showing the behind-the-scenes mechanics more—the whispered conversations off-camera, the tensions between the husbands. It paved the way for the high-gloss, heavily produced seasons that followed.
It also solidified the "Beverly Hills Style" of takedown. In Orange County, they scream. In Atlanta, they read. In Beverly Hills, they slowly isolate a target until that person has no choice but to quit or be fired. We saw it with Lisa Vanderpump here, and we’d see it again years later with Denise Richards and Lisa Rinna.
📖 Related: Adam Scott in Step Brothers: Why Derek is Still the Funniest Part of the Movie
How to Watch and Analyze Like a Pro
If you want to truly understand the evolution of reality TV, go back and binge this specific season with a critical eye. Don't just watch for the wine-throwing. Watch for the power shifts.
- Look for the "Magazine Gate" origins. This wasn't just about Mauricio; it was about the housewives realizing they could use the press as a weapon against each other.
- Observe the shift in Yolanda. This was before the Lyme disease journey took over her storyline. She was the "moral compass" who ended up being one of the most strategic players on the board.
- Study the casting. It’s a masterclass in what happens when you cast for conflict rather than organic friendship. It rarely works long-term, but it makes for explosive television.
The reality is that Season 4 isn't the most "liked" season, but it is the most important one for understanding why the show looks the way it does today. It was the end of the "early years" and the beginning of the "war of the brands."
To get the most out of a rewatch, track the "allegiance" of Brandi Glanville. She starts the season as Lisa’s best friend and ends it as her greatest enemy. It’s a fascinating study in how fast things move when cameras are rolling and egos are bruised. If you're looking for where the "real" went in "Real Housewives," you'll find the last gasps of it right here in Season 4.
Check the episodes on Peacock or Hayu, and pay special attention to the "Sur" dinner where the crossover with Vanderpump Rules began. That was the moment Bravo realized they didn't just have a show; they had a cinematic universe.
What to Do Next
- Watch the "Witchy Done" Episode: Specifically, look for the scene where Carlton gets a tattoo and compare her reaction to Kyle’s "peace offering" at the party. It tells you everything about their dynamic.
- Compare the Reunion to Season 9: Notice the parallels between how the women treated Lisa Vanderpump in Season 4 versus how they treated her during "Puppygate." The seeds of her eventual exit were sown right here.
- Cross-reference with Vanderpump Rules Season 2: These two seasons filmed simultaneously. Watching them together gives you a 360-degree view of the Lisa Vanderpump empire at its peak stress level.