Finding the rdr2 grave locations map isn't just about checking off a box for the "Best in the West" achievement. Honestly, it’s one of the most somber, quiet moments in the entire game. You’ve spent a hundred hours with these people. You’ve shared stew, fought off O’Driscolls, and watched the gang slowly implode. Then, once the dust settles in the epilogue, you’re left with nothing but a journal and some memories.
Rockstar didn’t make it easy. These graves aren't marked on your map with a big "X." You have to actually stand in front of them and "Inspect" to make it count toward the Paying Respects trophy. If you’re pushing for that 100% completion in 2026, you probably know that feeling of riding through the Grizzlies, squinting at a snow-covered hill, wondering if that’s a cross or just a jagged rock.
📖 Related: Dragon Link Golden Century: What Most Players Get Wrong About This Slot
Most people get frustrated because they miss one or two. Usually, it's Jenny or Eagle Flies. Here’s the deal: you can’t actually finish this until you reach the Epilogue. Some characters don't... well, they don't meet their end until very late in the story.
The Grizzlies and Ambarino: The Coldest Farewells
Up north, the map is brutal. It’s fitting that the first and last people we lost are tucked away in the snow and the cliffs.
1. Jenny Kirk
Jenny is a name you hear more than a person you see. She’s the girl who didn’t make it off the mountain after the botched Blackwater job. Her grave is way up in Spider Gorge. If you head north from Colter, follow the river. Look for a small clearing in the snow just above the "e" in the word "Gorge" on your map. It’s a lonely spot. Just a simple wooden cross.
2. Davey Callander
Davey is the one you see on the table in the opening cutscene. He’s buried right in Colter. Just walk behind the ruined church in that abandoned mining town. There's a little graveyard there, and his is the one with the most stones piled on top. It’s easy to find, but easy to forget if you aren't paying attention.
3. Eagle Flies
This one is tucked away near Donner Falls. You’ll want to look on the cliffside facing the falls. It’s not a traditional grave with a cross; it’s a pile of stones with a sash tied to a branch. The view is incredible, which makes sense for him. He deserved a vista like that.
4. Arthur Morgan
The big one. Arthur’s final resting place is northeast of Bacchus Station, right near the Mysterious Hill Home (that little hobbit-looking house). You have to climb up the mountain a bit. If you played with High Honor, the grave is covered in flowers. If you were a bit of a villain, it’s just plain dirt. It’s a gut punch either way.
Lemoyne and the Heartlands: Where the Heists Went Wrong
Moving south into the humidity and the marshes, the graves get a bit closer together. This is where the gang really started to fall apart.
💡 You might also like: Finding the Real Catnap: Why Everyone is Searching for This Poppy Playtime Character
5 & 6. Hosea Matthews and Lenny Summers
These two are buried side-by-side. It’s probably the saddest spot on the rdr2 grave locations map. You’ll find them north of Saint Denis, right on the edge of the Bluewater Marsh. They’re under a massive, beautiful tree. You have to interact with both graves individually for the game to count them. Don't just look at one and ride off.
7. Sean MacGuire
Our favorite loud-mouthed Irishman. Sean is buried north of Clemens Point (the Chapter 3 camp). If you head northwest from Rhodes, look for a small cluster of trees overlooking the water of Flat Iron Lake. It’s a peaceful spot for a guy who was anything but peaceful.
8. Kieran Duffy
Kieran's grave is out in a quiet field east of Braithwaite Manor. It’s basically between Shady Belle and the Bolger Glade ruins. It’s a simple, unremarkable grave. Honestly, the gang never really gave Kieran the credit he deserved while he was alive, and his grave reflects that sort of "outsider" status he always had.
New Hanover: The Final Matriarch
9. Susan Grimshaw
Miss Grimshaw is the last one most people find. She’s buried in the middle of New Hanover, specifically between the "V" and "E" of the word "Hanover" on the map. She’s on top of a steep hill overlooking the valley near the Elysian Pool. It’s a tough climb, but Susan was a tough woman.
Why 100% Completion Often Glitches Here
I’ve seen a lot of players complain that the "Paying Respects" trophy doesn't pop even after they've visited all nine. Usually, the culprit is the "Inspect" prompt. You can't just ride past them on your horse. You have to get off, walk up to the headstone, and wait for the prompt to appear. Arthur (or John) will usually mutter something or tip his hat.
Also, check your progress in the menu. Under Progress > Total Completion > Collectibles, there is a specific tab for Graves. If it says 8/9, you probably missed one of the two in the snow or forgot to click on both Hosea and Lenny.
Actionable Next Steps for Outlaws
- Manual Save: Before you head out on this "grave tour," make a manual save. Occasionally, the interaction prompt can get wonky if there’s a random encounter (like a cougar attack) happening nearby.
- The Order Matters (For Vibes): While the game doesn't care about the order, most players save Arthur for last. There's a certain weight to finishing your journey at that cliffside.
- Use the Journal: After you visit a grave, John will often sketch it in his journal. It’s a great way to verify you’ve actually "completed" that specific location.
- Time of Day: Visit Eagle Flies or Arthur at sunrise. The lighting engine in RDR2 is still industry-leading even years later, and those specific spots are designed to look breathtaking in the morning light.
Once you’ve ticked off all nine, that’s one major chunk of the 100% checklist done. It’s a long ride, but it’s the best way to say goodbye to the Van der Linde gang properly.