You ever just stare at your game shelf and realize you're missing a chunk of your own history? That’s basically what happened to a lot of us before 2015. Then Microsoft and Rare dropped this absolute unit of a collection. Honestly, Rare Replay Xbox One isn't just a disc with some old ROMs on it; it’s a time machine that somehow manages to fit 30 years of British gaming madness into a single install.
But here is the thing. Most people talk about it like it’s just a "greatest hits" album. It’s not. It’s a messy, beautiful, sometimes frustrating archive of a studio that went from making 8-bit games in a garden shed to defining what a first-person shooter looks like on a console.
The Heavy Hitters vs. The Ones You Forgot
If you’re picking up the Rare Replay Xbox One collection, you’re probably doing it for the "Big Three." You know the ones. Banjo-Kazooie, Perfect Dark, and Conker’s Bad Fur Day. These are the legends. Playing Banjo today on an Xbox Series X (via the original Xbox One disc) feels surprisingly modern because the textures are clean and the frame rate doesn't chug like it did on the N64 back in '98.
But you've got to look at the weird stuff. That’s where the real soul is.
Have you actually tried Blast Corps recently? It’s a game about driving a bulldozer into buildings to clear a path for a leaking nuclear carrier. It is chaotic. It is stressful. It is peak Rare. Then you have Viva Piñata. People laughed at it in 2006 because it looked like a "kid's game," but honestly, it’s one of the deepest garden sims ever made. If you haven't lost three hours trying to convince a Horstachio to move into your garden, have you even lived?
The collection covers everything from 1983’s Jetpac (which is still addictive as hell) to 2008’s Banjo-Kazooie: Nuts & Bolts. Yeah, people hated the cars, but in 2026, we can finally admit the physics engine was ahead of its time.
Why 2026 is the year to finally play Rare Replay
We are living in a digital-first world now. Most of the new Xbox consoles don't even have disc drives. This makes the physical copy of the Rare Replay Xbox One collection a bit of a relic, but a valuable one. If you have a Series X, popping that disc in gives you access to a library that would cost hundreds of dollars to assemble piece-by-piece on eBay.
There's a technical side to this too. The Xbox 360 games in the bundle—like Kameo: Elements of Power and Perfect Dark Zero—actually run as separate installs. They aren't "emulated" in the traditional sense; they use the Xbox backward compatibility layer. This means they get all the perks of modern hardware. I'm talking Auto HDR and significantly faster load times. In Nuts & Bolts, those brutal load screens that used to let you go make a sandwich? They’re basically gone now.
The "Missing" Games (The Elephant in the Room)
We have to talk about what isn't here. It’s the question everyone asks: "Where is GoldenEye?" or "Where is Donkey Kong Country?"
Look, licensing is a nightmare. Since Nintendo owns the Donkey Kong IP and the James Bond rights are a tangled mess of movie studios and estate lawyers, they couldn't make the cut for the original 2015 release. Even though GoldenEye 007 eventually limped its way onto Game Pass and Switch recently, it’s still not "officially" part of the Rare Replay interface. It’s a bummer, sure, but the 30 games that are here—including the arcade version of Battletoads which was a huge "get" at the time—more than make up for it.
The Milestone System is a Grind (But Worth It)
Rare didn't just dump these games on a menu. They built a whole theater-themed wrapper around them. You earn "stamps" for completing milestones in each game. These stamps rank you up and unlock "Rare Revealed" videos.
These videos are the real treasure for nerds. We’re talking about:
- Footage of Kameo 2 (the sequel that never happened).
- The truth about the "Stop 'n' Swop" feature in Banjo-Kazooie.
- Concept art for unreleased projects like Black Widow.
Getting all 10,000 Gamerscore is basically a full-time job. Some of those ZX Spectrum games from the early 80s, like Knight Lore or Underwurlde, are brutally difficult. They don't hold your hand. They don't explain the controls. They just drop you in. Thankfully, Rare added a "Rewind" feature for the older titles. You can literally hold a button to undo a death. It's a lifesaver, especially in the infamous Turbo Tunnel in Battletoads.
How to actually get through this collection
Don't try to play these in order. You’ll get stuck on a 1984 platformer and give up. Jump around. Start with the N64 era to get your bearings, then dip into the 360 games. Save the ZX Spectrum stuff for when you want a "history lesson" or a quick 5-minute challenge.
💡 You might also like: Why The Beatles Rock Band PS3 Version Is Still the Gold Standard for Music Games
The "Snapshots" mode is perfect for this. It takes specific parts of the older games and turns them into mini-challenges, sort of like NES Remix. It’s the best way to experience the older games without the frustration of 40-year-old difficulty spikes.
Actionable Advice for New Players
- Check your storage: The full collection is huge because it triggers downloads for all the 360 titles. Make sure you have about 50GB free if you want the whole "theater" experience.
- Use the Rewind: Don't be a hero. The older games were designed to eat quarters in arcades or keep you busy for months because you only got one game a year. Use the rewind button to see the ending.
- Look for the physical disc: Even in 2026, you can find used copies of Rare Replay for under $20. It is arguably the best value-per-dollar in gaming history.
- Play Battletoads Arcade: Most people only know the NES version. The Arcade version is way more violent, looks better, and is actually fair (mostly).
Rare Replay is a weird, clunky, brilliant museum. It reminds us that before they were the Sea of Thieves studio, Rare was a group of people who just wanted to see if they could make a skeleton dance on a screen or a bear fly with a bird in his backpack. It’s a essential piece of any Xbox library, whether you’re a nostalgic 40-year-old or a kid wondering why everyone is so obsessed with a foul-mouthed squirrel.
Go find a copy. Clear your weekend. And seriously, don't sleep on Viva Piñata.