You’ve been burning through Nook Miles Tickets for hours. Your eyes are bloodshot. You’re staring at a dodo bird who seems way too happy about your dwindling life savings. All you want is one specific cat. Or maybe a certain smug squirrel. But the game keeps giving you the same three jock gorillas. It feels like the game is rigged, right?
Honestly, the way we talk about rare animal crossing characters is kinda broken. We use the word "rare" as a synonym for "popular," but in the actual code of Animal Crossing: New Horizons, rarity is a math problem, not a status symbol. If you’re hunting for a specific neighbor, understanding how the game actually rolls the dice will save you a lot of heartbreak. Or at least it’ll explain why you’ve seen Zucker five times and Raymond zero.
👉 See also: Finding All Stunt Jump Locations GTA 5 Style Without Losing Your Mind
The Math Behind Rare Animal Crossing Characters
Here is the truth that hurts: No single villager is programmed to be "rarer" than another in a vacuum. The game doesn't have a "1% drop rate" for Raymond and a "50% drop rate" for Barold.
Instead, the game uses a two-step rolling process whenever you land on a Mystery Island. First, it picks a species. There are 35 species in the game. It doesn't matter if there are 3 octopuses or 23 cats; the game treats both groups as equal 1-in-35 chances.
Once the species is chosen, the game then rolls for a specific individual within that species.
This is where the "rarity" comes in. Because there are only three octopuses in the base game (Marina, Octavian, and Zucker), your chance of finding a specific one is actually quite high once the game decides you're visiting an "Octopus Island."
Mathematically, you have a 1/35 chance to hit the octopus category, and then a 1/3 chance to get Marina. That’s a 1/105 total chance.
Compare that to the cats. There are 23 cats. To get Raymond, you first need to hit that 1/35 species roll, then survive a 1/23 individual roll. That is a 1/805 chance.
That is why cats, dogs, and frogs feel impossible to find. They aren't "rare" because Nintendo hates you; they’re rare because their families are too big.
The Amiibo Card Factor
For a long time, "rare" meant "does not have an Amiibo card." If you couldn't just buy a pack of cards and scan a villager into your campsite, they were functionally much harder to get.
When New Horizons first launched, characters like Raymond, Judy, Sherb, and Audie were the holy grails. You had to find them "naturally." This created a massive black market on sites like Nookazon, where players were trading hundreds of millions of Bells or thousands of Nook Miles Tickets for a single business cat.
Then came the Series 5 Amiibo cards.
👉 See also: Why the Witcher 3 Crones of Crookback Bog Are Still the Most Terrifying Bosses Ever Made
Suddenly, Sasha, Shino, and Ione were accessible to anyone with a few dollars and a card reader. Does that make them less rare? Technically, yes. But in the eyes of the community, the "rare" label stuck. We still treat the Series 5 newcomers as premium assets because their designs are so distinct from the older villagers.
Why Some Characters Still Feel Impossible to Find
If you’re looking for a specific personality type to fill a gap in your DIY recipe collection, the Campsite is your best friend—and your worst enemy.
The Campsite has a "cool-down" and a "bias" system. The game is more likely to spawn a villager with a personality type that is currently missing from your island. If you have no Smug villagers, the game will try its hardest to give you a Smug visitor.
However, even with this bias, the pool is still huge.
If you’re hunting for Marshal (Smug), but you already have three other Smug villagers on your island, your odds of seeing him at the campsite drop through the floor. Most players don't realize that they are accidentally sabotaging their own "rare" finds by keeping too many villagers of the same personality type.
Are Special Characters Actually Rarer?
We usually talk about villagers, but what about the NPCs? Characters like Brewster or Redd show up on a schedule. There isn't really a "rare" NPC anymore, though back in the older games, meeting someone like Wisp felt like a genuine urban legend.
In the 2026 gaming landscape, we've basically datamined the mystery out of the game. We know exactly when Celeste is going to show up based on weather patterns. We know Redd’s fake art patterns.
The only thing that remains truly "rare" is the perfect alignment of a villager’s personality, their house exterior, and how well they fit your island's specific aesthetic.
Insights for Your Next Hunt
Stop thinking about rarity as a fixed stat. It’s a logistics game.
If you want an octopus, go to Mystery Islands. Your odds are great.
If you want a cat or a squirrel, save your tickets. Use the "Move-Out" method to force a bubble onto a villager you don't want, then look for someone trading that cat on a community forum. Trying to find a specific cat via Nook Miles Tickets is a statistical nightmare that usually ends in tears.
Also, check your personality balance. If you're desperate for a "rare" Smug or Sisterly villager, make sure you actually have an open slot and no other villagers of that type. It tilts the RNG in your favor, even if it’s just a little bit.
Don't let "popularity tier lists" dictate who stays on your island. A "rare" villager you hate is just taking up space. Honestly, some of the most charming designs in the game are the ones sitting in "Tier D" that nobody talks about.
To maximize your chances of getting a specific high-demand character, clear out any villagers who share their personality type before you start your next major hunt. This forces the campsite algorithm to prioritize that specific category, significantly shortening the time you'll spend waiting for a visitor.