You probably think you know the story. Iowa State football is that "scrappy" team from Ames that occasionally ruins a Big 12 powerhouse's season on a Thursday night. It's the "loyalty" and "process" talk. But if you're looking at the ranking of Iowa State football through the lens of ten years ago, you’re missing the actual reality of 2026. This isn't just a spoiler team anymore. It’s a program that has fundamentally shifted its floor.
Honestly, the "little engine that could" narrative is dead.
The 2024 season was the turning point that nobody—even some die-hard Cyclone fans—fully expected to be that historic. We’re talking about the first 11-win season in the program’s 133-year history. For over a century, the "10-win barrier" was a ghost that haunted Jack Trice Stadium. Then Rocco Becht and a defense that refused to break finally kicked the door down. They finished No. 15 in the final AP Poll. That was huge. It wasn't a fluke, but it was the end of an era.
The Post-Campbell Reality and Current Standing
Matt Campbell is gone. He’s at Penn State now. That’s the elephant in the room when we talk about where Iowa State ranks today. He left after the 2025 season with a 72-55 record, making him the winningest coach in school history. He didn't just win games; he made Iowa State a permanent resident in the "Others Receiving Votes" category at worst, and a Top 15 mainstay at best.
So, where do they sit right now?
In the most recent 2025-2026 cycle, Iowa State finished 8-4. They weren't in the College Football Playoff, but they remained a tough out. They actually climbed as high as No. 12 in the AP Poll during the 2025 season after a massive win over Kansas State in Dublin, Ireland. Yeah, they’re playing international games now. That’s a long way from the days of hoping to just get to the Insight.com Bowl.
🔗 Read more: Men's Sophie Cunningham Jersey: Why This Specific Kit is Selling Out Everywhere
- Final 2024 Ranking: No. 15 (AP/Coaches)
- 2025 Peak Ranking: No. 12 (AP)
- All-Time High: No. 7 (Preseason 2021) / No. 6 (Regular Season 2020)
People forget that in 2020, they finished No. 9 in the world after crushing Oregon in the Fiesta Bowl. That remains the gold standard. But the 2024 run was arguably more impressive because they didn't have the "COVID year" asterisks or the senior-heavy roster of the 2020 squad. They did it with a sophomore quarterback and a bunch of three-star recruits who played like All-Americans.
Why the Recruiting Rankings Don't Tell the Whole Story
If you look at 247Sports or Rivals, you’ll see the ranking of Iowa State football recruiting classes hovering around 50th or 60th nationally. For the 2026 class, they’re sitting right at No. 50. To a casual fan, that looks mediocre. If you’re a blue-blood, 50th is a disaster.
But Ames is a developmental lab.
They signed 26 players for the 2026 class, mostly three-star guys. The "expert" consensus is that they’re middle-of-the-road. However, the Big 12 isn't won by five-stars anymore—at least not since Texas and Oklahoma bailed for the SEC. It’s won by guys like Jeffrey Roberts (the top recruit from West Des Moines) and a bunch of kids from Nebraska and Ohio who have chips on their shoulders.
The program’s internal "ranking" of talent is clearly different than the national media’s. They look for "fits." It sounds like a cliché, but when you see a defense rank in the top three of the Big 12 for scoring for seven straight years (which they did under Jon Heacock), you stop questioning the star ratings.
💡 You might also like: Why Netball Girls Sri Lanka Are Quietly Dominating Asian Sports
The Ranking Ceiling: Can They Ever Reach No. 1?
Probably not. Let's be real.
To reach No. 1, you need a level of sustained blue-chip talent that Iowa State just doesn't pursue. They don't play the NIL bidding war the same way Miami or Oregon does. When they beat Miami 42-41 in the 2024 Pop-Tarts Bowl, it was a victory of "culture" over "cash." Miami had the higher-ranked players, but Iowa State had the better team.
The highest they’ve ever climbed is No. 6 in the AP Poll (November 2020). They’ve never reached the Top 5. To do that, they’d likely need to be undefeated heading into November in a year where the SEC and Big Ten are cannibalizing each other. It’s possible in the new 12-team (and soon to be 14-team) playoff era, but the margin for error is razor-thin.
What Actually Affects the Ranking Now?
- The "Iowa" Factor: The Cy-Hawk game is a massive ranking pivot. If they beat Iowa (like they did in 2024 with a 54-yard field goal by Kyle Konrardy), the national media pays attention. If they lose, they’re dismissed as a "regional story."
- Conference Perception: The Big 12 is now a league of parity. Winning 7 conference games is harder than it looks because there are no "easy" Saturdays.
- The Quarterback Stability: Rocco Becht’s development has been the single biggest driver of their recent Top 25 appearances. When the QB is efficient, the defense keeps them in every game.
What Most People Get Wrong
The biggest misconception is that Iowa State is "slipping" because Matt Campbell left. Jimmy Rogers (the new head coach as of late 2025) inherited a program that is lightyears ahead of where it was in 2015.
The "floor" used to be 2 wins. Now, the floor is 6 or 7 wins.
📖 Related: Why Cumberland Valley Boys Basketball Dominates the Mid-Penn (and What’s Next)
When you're looking at the ranking of Iowa State football, don't just look at the number next to the name. Look at the turnover margin (usually Top 20) and the penalty yards (often the lowest in the nation). They win in the margins. In 2024, they averaged only 3.8 penalties per game. That’s how a team with "50th ranked recruits" ends up "15th in the nation."
Actionable Insights for Fans and Bettors
If you’re tracking this team for the upcoming season, here is what you actually need to watch to predict where their ranking is headed:
- Early Season Momentum: They open the 2025 season in Ireland. A win there usually catapults a team into the Top 25 purely based on visibility.
- The November Stretch: Iowa State historically plays its best football when the temperature drops. If they are 6-2 entering November, expect them to finish in the Top 15.
- Home Attendance: They just set a record with over 60,000 fans per game. Jack Trice is a legitimate hostile environment now, which helps them over-perform against ranked opponents.
Keep an eye on the turnover margin in the first three weeks. If they are +3 or better, they’ll likely be ranked by October. The "experts" will keep putting them at the bottom of the Top 25, but as we saw in 2024, they have a habit of staying there much longer than anyone expects.
The days of being surprised by a ranked Iowa State team are over. This is just who they are now.
To get the most accurate picture of where they stand next week, check the updated "Others Receiving Votes" section before the AP Poll drops on Sunday; the Cyclones almost always show up there first before making a leap. Track the health of the linebacker corps specifically, as that has been the one position where injuries have historically dropped them out of the rankings mid-season. Finally, watch the recruiting "Industry Rankings" rather than just one site—it gives a much better feel for the three-star gems that usually end up as All-Big 12 selections by their junior year.