If you spend more than five minutes in a wrestling forum or scrolling through "Wrestling Twitter," you’re going to see it. A grainy clip of AJ Styles looking absolutely bewildered, or maybe a screenshot of a search result. It’s a joke that has lived for nearly two decades. But honestly, the "Randy Orton gay community" connection is a lot weirder—and actually a lot more wholesome—than the internet trolls make it out to be.
Most people think it’s just a meme. A punchline. Something to throw at fans who post photos of Orton’s legendary physique. But if you dig into the history of how Randy Orton actually treats his LGBTQ+ fans, you find a story that’s way more interesting than a viral clip from a 2003 radio show.
Where the "Gay Community" Meme Actually Came From
Let’s get the elephant in the room out of the way. When people talk about Randy Orton and the gay community, they are usually referencing a specific, chaotic moment in wrestling history that technically had nothing to do with Orton at first.
It was 2003. AJ Styles, long before he was the "Face that Runs the Place" in WWE, was doing a phone-in interview on a radio show. A caller got through and asked him, point-blank, how he felt about having such a large following in the "gay community."
AJ’s reaction was... intense.
He shouted back, "THE GAY COMMUNITY?!" with a mix of shock and confusion that instantly became legendary. It wasn’t necessarily malicious, but it was loud. For years, that audio clip was used to prank wrestlers or mock the "old school" mindset of the business.
So, how did Randy get dragged into it?
🔗 Read more: Sexiest Man Alive 2002: Why Ben Affleck and the Bennifer Frenzy Still Matters
Basically, the internet did what the internet does. Fans started noticing that if you looked at search trends or social media engagement, Randy Orton actually did have a massive following within the LGBTQ+ community. Maybe it was the "Legend Killer" persona. Maybe it was the fact that he spent 20 years wrestling in nothing but tiny trunks and baby oil. Whatever the reason, the data backed it up.
Eventually, the two things merged. Fans started using the AJ Styles audio to talk about Orton. It became a meta-joke: Triple H even joked about it during a promo once, subtly acknowledging that Randy was a hit with "certain communities."
Why Randy Orton Is Actually a Low-Key Ally
It’s easy to look at the memes and laugh, but Randy Orton’s real-life track record with the gay community is pretty solid.
Remember 2013? That was the year Darren Young (Fred Rosser) came out as the first openly gay active wrestler in WWE. At the time, the wrestling world was a different place. There was a lot of anxiety about how the "locker room leaders" would react.
Randy Orton was one of the first guys to step up.
Darren Young has gone on record multiple times saying that Randy—along with CM Punk—was incredibly supportive. Orton reportedly told him, "Hey man, if you have any issue, you let me know, and I’ll take care of anyone in the locker room."
That’s not just PR talk. In the world of pro wrestling, "taking care of it" usually means a 250-pound man making it very clear that bullying won't be tolerated.
The Evolution of the Viper
Orton hasn't always been the most "politically correct" guy. He’d be the first to tell you he was a total jerk in his 20s. He was young, rich, and had a massive ego. But as he’s aged, he’s turned into this weirdly protective "Dad" figure for the WWE roster.
- He’s been vocal about mental health.
- He’s defended younger talent from online harassment.
- He’s consistently shown respect to fans from all walks of life.
When a fan reached out to him on Instagram a few years back about struggling with their identity and depression, Randy didn't ignore it. He didn't give a "thoughts and prayers" response. He actually engaged, offering genuine advice.
The "Amazing Thighs" and Internet Subcultures
We have to talk about the "thighs" thing.
There’s a famous post on a wrestling board from years ago where a user wrote a massive, 10-paragraph essay on WWE booking. Right in the middle—totally out of context—they just typed: "Randy Orton has amazing thighs." It became a legend. It’s the kind of weird, specific detail that the gay community and fitness enthusiasts alike latched onto. People started realizing that Orton’s "look" was practically designed for a specific kind of admiration.
Orton, to his credit, seems to find the whole thing hilarious. He’s never been the guy to get "offended" by being a sex symbol for men. He’s comfortable enough in his own skin that he just leans into it. He’s even poked fun at AJ Styles on Twitter (X) about the whole "community" thing.
💡 You might also like: Why Everyone Is Obsessed With Bosch Legacy Episodes Season 3 Right Now
Why This Matters in 2026
Wrestling is changing. We’re seeing more diverse performers than ever. But for a guy like Randy Orton—a third-generation wrestler who grew up in the "old school" system—to be so openly accepting is a big deal.
It’s not about being "woke" or whatever buzzword people are using this week. It’s about the fact that Randy Orton knows who his audience is. He knows that his fan base isn't just "tough guys" and kids. It’s everyone.
If you’re a fan and you happen to be gay, Randy Orton is probably one of the safest bets for a "locker room leader" who has your back.
What You Should Take Away From This
The randy orton gay community connection is a mix of three things: a funny meme, genuine data-backed popularity, and a wrestler who actually cares about his fans.
If you want to support the progress being made in the industry, here is how you can actually engage:
- Watch the real interviews: Check out Darren Young’s interviews where he discusses the support he received from the WWE locker room. It gives a lot of context to who these guys are behind the scenes.
- Separate the meme from the man: Enjoy the "THE GAY COMMUNITY?!" clips, but recognize that Randy’s actual relationship with his LGBTQ+ fans is rooted in respect, not just jokes.
- Follow the "New" Randy: If you only know Orton from his 2005 "Legend Killer" days, check out his more recent interviews on podcasts like The Journey or with Sam Roberts. He’s a completely different, much more thoughtful person now.
The Viper might be cold-blooded in the ring, but he's proven that he’s got a lot more heart than people give him credit for.