August 14, 1936. Owensboro, Kentucky. A scorching Friday morning.
You’ve probably heard of the "Wild West" and the rough justice of the frontier, but the last hanging in America didn’t happen in a dusty 1800s cowtown. It happened in the mid-1930s, during the era of the Great Depression, swing music, and the rise of Hollywood’s Golden Age. Rainey Bethea, a 26-year-old Black man, was the center of a media circus that eventually pushed the United States to rethink how it executed its citizens.
It was a mess. Honestly, it was a complete disaster.
The crowd was estimated at 20,000 people. People traveled from out of state. They brought picnic baskets. They treated a man’s death like a county fair, and the aftermath was so gruesome and the optics so poor that it effectively killed the practice of public executions in this country forever.
Why the Last Hanging in America Wasn't a "Normal" Execution
We have this idea that legal proceedings back then were slow and methodical. They weren't. Bethea was arrested for the rape and murder of a 70-year-old woman named Elsbeth Edwards. The evidence was fairly definitive—he had left a ring at the crime scene that was later identified—but the trial lasted only a few hours.
The legal hook here is important. Under Kentucky law at the time, if a person was convicted of murder, they were executed by the electric chair at the state penitentiary in Eddyville. But, if they were convicted of rape, the punishment was hanging in the county where the crime occurred. Prosecutors chose the rape charge specifically to ensure a public hanging.
They wanted a show. They got a riot.
Journalists from all over the country descended on Owensboro. They were looking for a story, and they found one in Florence Thompson. She was the sheriff of Daviess County, having taken over the role after her husband died. The media went wild with the "Lady Sheriff" narrative. They imagined a woman in a sunbonnet pulling the lever, a trope that sold newspapers but wasn't exactly grounded in the grim reality of the task.
The Media Frenzy and the "Drunken" Hangman
When we talk about the last hanging in America, we have to talk about Arthur "Phil" Hanna. He was an "expert" hangman from Illinois who claimed he did it out of a sense of duty, not for money. He was supposed to ensure a "clean" execution.
💡 You might also like: Como van elecciones en USA: Lo que nadie te cuenta del caos político de 2026
He failed.
The morning of the hanging, the crowd was restless. Some reports say people were drinking through the night. When Bethea was led to the gallows, the atmosphere wasn't somber. It was predatory. Hanna, reportedly under immense stress or perhaps intoxicated—accounts from witnesses like reporter Lawrence Ashby suggest the executioner was not in his right mind—failed to properly coordinate the drop.
When the trapdoor finally opened, it wasn't a quick break of the neck. It was a slow strangulation that took over ten minutes.
The Myth of the Souvenir Hunters
You’ll often read in history books that the crowd tore Bethea’s clothes off for souvenirs while he was still hanging. That's a bit of an exaggeration, but the truth is still pretty dark. People did rush the gallows. They tore small pieces of the black hood used to cover his head. They wanted a piece of the "event."
The national press, particularly the New York Times and Chicago Tribune, used this behavior to paint Owensboro as a town of barbarians. They called it "The Kentucky Carnival."
This is where the shift happened. The local Kentucky papers were furious. They felt the "Yankee press" was unfairly judging a legal execution. But the damage was done. The sheer vulgarity of 20,000 people cheering for a death made the "civilized" world recoil.
It wasn't that people suddenly became anti-death penalty. Not at all. They just didn't want it to be a public spectacle anymore. They wanted it behind closed doors, sanitised and hidden.
The Legal Aftermath of the Bethea Case
The last hanging in America directly led to a change in Kentucky law. By 1938, the state legislature moved all executions to the electric chair inside the prison walls. They realized that public hangings weren't acting as a "deterrent" as they had long claimed. Instead, they were becoming "mobs with a permit."
It’s a weird quirk of history that Missouri actually had a hanging in 1937, and some local jurisdictions might have had small, private hangings later, but Bethea’s is the one that sticks. It was the last one held in public view under a specific state mandate.
📖 Related: Lima Ohio News Today: What Most People Get Wrong About Our Current Headlines
Think about that. In 1936, you could watch a man die on your way to get groceries.
What This History Teaches Us Today
History isn't just a list of dates. It's about the evolution of what we find acceptable. The Bethea case highlights three specific things:
- The Power of the Press: The way the "Lady Sheriff" was portrayed (she didn't actually pull the lever; she stayed in her car) shows how media creates a narrative to sell papers, often at the expense of the truth.
- The Racial Component: We can't ignore that the last person publicly hanged was a Black man in the South, accused of a crime against a white woman, in front of a predominantly white crowd. The racial dynamics of the 1930s justice system are inseparable from this event.
- The Move Toward "Humane" Execution: This event accelerated the push for lethal injection and the electric chair, though many argue these methods just hide the violence rather than eliminate it.
If you want to understand the modern American justice system, you have to look at these messy transitions. The Bethea hanging was the end of an era of "theater of the gallows."
To dig deeper into this, you should look for the book The Last Public Hanging in America by Perry T. Ryan. He’s a former assistant attorney general for Kentucky who did the deep-dive research into the court transcripts that most people ignore. Also, the Daviess County Public Library has an archive of the original newspaper clippings from 1936 that show just how differently the local vs. national media viewed the event.
Next Steps for Researchers and History Buffs:
Visit the Daviess County Courthouse in Owensboro if you’re ever in Kentucky. There aren't many plaques for this—towns don't usually brag about their "last hanging"—but the geography of the town still reflects the era.
Verify the primary sources. Don't just trust a viral tweet or a short YouTube clip. Look at the 1936 Kentucky Revised Statutes. See how the law was written. Check the death certificate of Rainey Bethea, which is a matter of public record.
Understand the context. 1936 was the same year as the Berlin Olympics. While the world was watching Jesse Owens, this was happening in a small town in Kentucky. History is always happening in parallel, and the last hanging in America is a grim reminder of how recently "the old ways" were still the law of the land.