Rock and roll is messy. Honestly, if you look at the lineage of Ritchie Blackmore’s Rainbow, it’s less like a band history and more like a high-stakes soap opera with louder amplifiers. Most people hear those opening power chords of Rainbow Since You’ve Been Gone and think of a catchy, radio-friendly anthem. It’s a staple of classic rock radio. You’ve heard it at bars. You’ve heard it in grocery stores. But the reality of how that song came to be—and how it almost tore the band apart—is way more interesting than the polished studio version suggests.
It wasn’t just a hit. It was a pivot point.
Ritchie Blackmore was already a god by 1979. He’d conquered the world with Deep Purple and then walked away to build his own medieval-inspired empire with Rainbow. But by the time the Down to Earth sessions rolled around, the "Man in Black" was bored with the dragons and the wizards. He wanted the charts. He wanted America. To get there, he needed a song that could penetrate the FM airwaves, and that’s where Russ Ballard comes in.
Why Rainbow Since You’ve Been Gone Changed Everything
Before this track, Rainbow was firmly "Dungeons & Dragons" rock. Ronnie James Dio’s departure is the massive elephant in the room here. Dio didn't want to sing pop. He wanted to sing about the "Man on the Silver Mountain." When he left, it created a vacuum that changed the trajectory of heavy metal forever.
Enter Graham Bonnet.
Bonnet was an anomaly. He didn't look like a rock star of the era. He had short hair, wore Hawaiian shirts, and looked more like an insurance salesman than a frontman for a legendary guitarist. But his voice? It was a powerhouse. When Rainbow recorded Since You've Been Gone, they weren't just covering a Russ Ballard track; they were re-engineering their entire DNA. Ballard had originally released it on his 1976 album Winning, and even the band Clout had a go at it. But Blackmore’s version added the grit. It added the menace.
The Friction Behind the Sound
It’s easy to assume everyone was happy to have a hit. They weren't. Cozy Powell, the legendary drummer whose kit sounded like a literal thunderstorm, reportedly hated the song at first. He thought it was too lightweight. Imagine being one of the most respected drummers in rock history and being told you need to play a straightforward, poppy 4/4 beat for a radio single. It felt like a sell-out move to the purists in the camp.
Roger Glover, the bassist and producer, was the glue. Having been sacked from Deep Purple by Blackmore years earlier, his return as a producer and bassist for Rainbow was one of those "only in rock" ironies. Glover knew how to polish Blackmore’s rough edges. He understood that Rainbow Since You’ve Been Gone needed to be punchy. The production on the Down to Earth album is remarkably dry and forward compared to the reverb-heavy mysticism of the Dio era. It’s aggressive pop-rock.
The Graham Bonnet Factor
You cannot talk about this song without acknowledging the vocal performance. Graham Bonnet’s range is borderline terrifying. On the studio recording, he hits those high notes with a chest-voice power that most singers can only reach in falsetto.
But there was a culture clash.
Blackmore famously hated Bonnet’s look. There are stories—real ones, documented by band members—of Blackmore trying to trip Bonnet up on stage or being annoyed that he wouldn't grow his hair out. It was a volatile partnership. Yet, that tension is exactly what makes the song work. It doesn't sound "nice." It sounds like a band trying to burst out of a cage. The song peaked at number 6 on the UK Singles Chart, proving Blackmore’s commercial instincts were right, even if it cost the band its "mystical" reputation.
The Russ Ballard Connection
Russ Ballard is the secret weapon of 70s and 80s rock. The guy wrote "God Gave Rock 'n' Roll to You" (Argent/KISS) and "New York Groove" (Ace Frehley). He had a knack for hooks that stuck in your brain like industrial-strength glue. When Rainbow took on Since You've Been Gone, they followed a blueprint that was already successful, but Blackmore’s guitar tone—that sharp, biting Fender Stratocaster sound—gave it a sophisticated edge that the previous versions lacked.
✨ Don't miss: Dirty Dancing Havana Nights: Why the Prequel Deserves a Second Look
Blackmore’s solo in the middle of the song is a masterclass in restraint. Usually, he’d go off on a neo-classical tear, shredding through scales at light speed. Here? He plays for the song. It’s melodic, rhythmic, and fits the three-minute-pop-song structure perfectly. It showed a side of Ritchie that many fans didn't know existed: the disciplined songwriter.
Misconceptions About the "Pop" Era
A lot of die-hard metalheads dismiss the Down to Earth period as "Rainbow Lite." That’s a mistake.
If you listen to the rest of the album—tracks like "Eyes of the World" or "Lost in Hollywood"—the heaviness is still there. It’s just smarter. Rainbow Since You’ve Been Gone was the Trojan Horse. It got them onto Top of the Pops and into the ears of American teenagers who wouldn't have known a "Stargazer" if it hit them in the face.
The influence of this specific era cannot be overstated. It paved the way for the "pop-metal" explosion of the 1980s. Without the commercial success of this lineup, would we have had the radio-ready versions of Alcatrazz or even the Joe Lynn Turner era of Rainbow? Probably not. It proved that you could be a virtuoso and still have a chorus that people could scream along to in their cars.
The Legacy of a Three-Minute Masterpiece
Does it still hold up? Absolutely.
The song has been covered dozens of times, but nobody captures the sheer "bellow" of the original. Brian May has performed it. Impellitteri did a high-speed shred version. But the Rainbow version remains the definitive one because of that specific alignment of stars: Blackmore’s ego, Glover’s production, Powell’s stomp, and Bonnet’s throat-shredding delivery.
It’s a song about longing, sure. "I get the same old dreams, same old scenarios." It’s a classic heartbreak lyric. But in the hands of Rainbow, it sounds less like a sad guy missing his girlfriend and more like an ultimatum.
What You Should Do Next
If you’ve only ever heard the radio edit, you are missing half the story. To truly appreciate what was happening in 1979, go back and listen to the full Down to Earth album from start to finish.
✨ Don't miss: The Real Story Behind The Conjuring: What Actually Happened in Harrisville
- Listen to "Eyes of the World" immediately after. It provides the dark, symphonic contrast to the pop sensibilities of the hit single.
- Watch the 1980 Monsters of Rock footage. This was the pinnacle of this lineup. You can see the physical tension on stage. Bonnet is in his suit, sweating, screaming his lungs out, while Blackmore looks like he’s playing a different game entirely.
- Compare it to the original Russ Ballard version. It’s a fascinating lesson in how arrangement and "attitude" can transform a song’s meaning.
The story of Rainbow Since You’ve Been Gone isn’t just about a cover song. It’s about a legendary band deciding to survive in a changing musical landscape. It’s about the moment guitar heroics met the Billboard charts and decided they liked each other. It’s loud, it’s catchy, and it’s still one of the most effective pieces of rock songwriting ever put to tape.