Week 15 just blew the doors off the NFL playoff race. If you thought the MVP race was a two-man sprint, you haven't been watching the tape. Honestly, the quarterback landscape right now is a total mess of high-ceiling rookies and grizzled veterans who refuse to age out. While the box scores might tell you one thing, the actual film from this past weekend tells a much weirder story about who is actually playing high-level football.
The Chaos of QB Rankings Week 15
Look at the top of the board. Most people are still putting Patrick Mahomes in the top three based on reputation alone. But have you seen the Chiefs lately? Mahomes hit a legitimate season low against the Texans, completing a measly 42.4% of his passes. No touchdowns. Just a lot of running for his life. In any objective set of qb rankings week 15, he’s sliding. It’s not just a slump; it’s a roster that can’t protect him and a scheme that feels stale.
On the flip side, we have Matthew Stafford. The man is 37 and outplaying guys half his age. In the Rams' 41-34 shootout win over the Lions, Stafford was a surgeon. 368 yards. Two scores. He’s basically the reason the Rams are sitting at 11-3 and looking like a nightmare for anyone in the NFC. He’s leading the league in passing yards for a reason.
The Rookie Wall? Not for These Guys
Drake Maye is doing things in New England that shouldn’t be legal for a second-year player. He's sitting at a 72% completion rate through 13 games. That’s Drew Brees territory. Usually, young QBs start to fray by mid-December when the weather turns and the hits pile up. Maye just looks... bored? Like he’s already solved the NFL.
Then there’s Bo Nix. People were so ready to call him a "system QB" in Denver. But after what he did to the Packers—302 yards and four touchdowns—it’s time to stop the hate. He’s a massive reason the Broncos are 14-3. He isn't just managing games; he's winning them with his arm.
The Statistical Reality vs. The Eye Test
The numbers for qb rankings week 15 show a massive divide. Josh Allen is still the fantasy king because he's essentially a goal-line running back who can also throw 60 yards on a rope. He dropped 40 fantasy points in a snow game against the Patriots. That’s absurd. But if we’re talking pure passing, Trevor Lawrence might actually be the hottest hand in the league right now.
Lawrence just carved up the Jets for 330 yards and five touchdowns. Five! He’s playing with a level of confidence we haven’t seen since his Clemson days. Ever since Liam Coen took over as the OC, Jacksonville has become a "don't want to play them" team. Lawrence has 12 touchdowns in his last four games. If you're building a list of the best passers right now, he's in the top five, no question.
A Quick Look at the Mid-Tier Muddle
- Sam Darnold: He had that one nightmare four-INT game, but he’s still completing 68% of his passes for Seattle. He's revived his career in a way that feels sustainable.
- Jalen Hurts: Rough week. Four interceptions against the Raiders? That’s self-inflicted damage that could cost the Eagles a bye week.
- Jaxson Dart: The Giants rookie is a bit of a head-shaker. He’s scoring tons of fantasy points because of his legs, but the passing is still a work in progress.
Why the MVP Race is Broken
The problem with most qb rankings week 15 is that they weigh wins too heavily. Is Jared Goff a better individual player than Justin Herbert? Probably not. But the Lions are winning, so Goff gets the flowers. Herbert, meanwhile, is out there playing with a messed-up hand, overcoming a relentless Chiefs pass rush, and still dragging the Chargers to a win.
The grit factor is hard to quantify. When you watch Brock Purdy, he’s not the biggest or strongest. But he’s out there hitting 20-yard pump fakes and scrambling out of structure like he’s 2018 Russell Wilson. He finished with 295 yards against the Titans and looked entirely in control.
Survival of the Fittest
Injuries are the invisible hand of these rankings. The Packers are trying to figure out how to survive without Micah Parsons on the defensive side, which puts more pressure on Jordan Love. Love had a great first half against Denver but crumbled in the second. That’s the difference between a Tier 1 guy and a Tier 2 guy. You have to finish.
🔗 Read more: Dynasty Defense Rankings 2024: What Most People Get Wrong
What to Watch Moving Forward
The stretch run is going to be brutal. If you’re looking at qb rankings week 15 as a predictor for the Super Bowl, keep an eye on the turnover margins. Guys like Jalen Hurts and Tua Tagovailoa are trending the wrong way. Tua actually got benched for Quinn Ewers after the Steelers game. That’s a massive fall from grace for a guy who was once an MVP frontrunner.
If you’re managing a roster or just placing bets, you have to look at the offensive line health. Mahomes isn't "bad" all of a sudden; he's just unprotected. Conversely, Stafford and Maye are getting clean pockets, and they are punishing teams for it.
The smartest move right now is to buy high on the Trevor Lawrence resurgence. The Jaguars' scheme is finding ways to get Brian Thomas Jr. and the tight ends open in space that other teams haven't figured out yet. It's a copycat league, but by the time other teams copy Liam Coen, the season might be over.
Focus on the Adjusted Yards per Attempt (AY/A) for the rest of the season. It’s the best indicator of who is actually moving the needle and who is just dinking and dunking. Drake Maye leads the pack at 9.46, which is an elite, hall-of-fame level number for a season.
Start looking at the Week 16 matchups now. The Bills heading to Cleveland is going to be a defensive slog, while the Rams and Lions rematch in the playoffs looks inevitable. Keep your eyes on the guys who can create when the play breaks down. That's the only thing that matters when the temperature drops.