Everything in Pittsburgh feels a little upside down right now. Just 24 hours ago, the city was still buzzing with that nervous, playoff-energy hope that comes when you’ve got a first-ballot Hall of Famer under center. But today? Today is a total reset. After a demoralizing 30-6 loss to the Houston Texans in the Wild Card round, the qb of the steelers situation has gone from "win-now mode" to "what on earth happens next?"
Aaron Rodgers is 42. He spent the 2025 season in the black and gold trying to prove that age is just a number and that the Jets made a massive mistake. For a while, it actually looked like he might pull it off. He led the Steelers to an AFC North title, clinching it with a gritty Week 18 win over the Ravens. He finished the regular season with 24 touchdowns. Sure, that was four fewer than he had in 2024, and his yardage dipped by nearly 600, but he was winning.
Then Monday happened. The Texans didn't just beat the Steelers; they dismantled them. Rodgers looked every bit his age, finishing 31-for-47 but failing to find the end zone once.
The Reality of the QB of the Steelers Depth Chart
Honestly, the depth chart behind Rodgers doesn't exactly scream "future dynasty." If Rodgers decides to retire—or if the front office decides they can’t pay a 42-year-old another $13 million—the options are... slim.
🔗 Read more: Vertical Leap: What Most People Get Wrong About Jumping Higher
- Mason Rudolph: The ultimate survivor. He’s back for what feels like his tenth stint in Pittsburgh. He knows the system, but we’ve seen his ceiling.
- Will Howard: The rookie out of Ohio State. He was a sixth-round flyer in the 2025 draft. He’s got the size, but is he ready to start in the AFC North? Probably not.
- Skylar Thompson: Currently sitting on IR and mostly a depth piece.
The most shocking news isn't even about the quarterback, though. It’s about the guy who has been calling the shots for 19 years. Mike Tomlin just announced he’s stepping down. For the first time since 2007, the qb of the steelers won't be answering to Tomlin. That changes everything.
What happened to Russell Wilson and Justin Fields?
It’s easy to forget that just a year ago, this room was a revolving door of "bridge" options. Russell Wilson and Justin Fields both had their shot in 2024. Wilson was the "polished" guy, while Fields was the "high-upside" guy. Neither one stuck. The Steelers chose not to re-sign them, opting for the high-stakes gamble on Rodgers.
Rodgers brought "intangibles." That’s the word the analysts love to use. He brought a swagger that the locker room desperately needed after years of middling offensive production. But intangibles don't win games when you can't score a single touchdown in a playoff game.
💡 You might also like: U of Washington Football News: Why Jedd Fisch’s Roster Overhaul Is Working
Why the 2025 season felt different
This year wasn't about building for the future. It was a blatant, unapologetic "Last Dance" attempt. The front office went out and got DK Metcalf and Adam Thielen to give Rodgers some weapons. They beefed up the line with Zach Frazier and Troy Fautanu. On paper, it was a Super Bowl contender.
In reality, it was a team that relied too heavily on a defense that eventually got tired and a quarterback who couldn't escape the pocket anymore. Rodgers was basically a statue out there. He threw for 294 yards against Baltimore in the finale, showing flashes of the old MVP self, but those flashes were too few and far between.
The Path Forward: Finding the Next Franchise QB
The Steelers are now in a position they haven't been in since Terry Bradshaw retired or since Ben Roethlisberger started fading. They are truly starting from zero. No head coach. No long-term answer at quarterback.
📖 Related: Top 5 Wide Receivers in NFL: What Most People Get Wrong
Basically, the 2026 offseason is going to be the most important three months in the history of the modern franchise. General Manager Omar Khan said it himself: "At some point, we have to find the long-term solution."
If you're looking for what the team does next, keep an eye on these specific moves:
- The Retirement Watch: If Rodgers doesn't announce his plans by March 1, his contract status becomes a major cap headache.
- The Draft Strategy: With a new coach coming in, do the Steelers trade up for a top-tier signal-caller, or do they let Will Howard compete for the job?
- The Free Agent Market: Names like Sam Darnold or even a reunion with a younger vet could be on the table, though the "Rodgers experiment" might make them wary of old stars.
The era of the "legendary" qb of the steelers is currently on pause. Whether Aaron Rodgers comes back for one more ride or the team moves on to a total rebuild, the standard in Pittsburgh has shifted. It's no longer about just "not having a losing season." The fans are restless. Seven straight playoff losses is a heavy weight to carry, and whoever takes the snaps in 2026 will be carrying all of it.
To keep tabs on the situation, you'll want to watch the NFL Scouting Combine results in late February, as that's where the Steelers typically signal their interest in the next generation of passers. Additionally, monitor the coaching search; a defensive-minded coach might prefer a game manager, while an offensive guru will almost certainly demand a high-round draft pick at quarterback.