Week 1 is basically a fever dream. We spent all summer drafting based on "vibes" and spreadsheets, and then the actual games happened. Now, your group chat is a disaster zone. Half the league is panic-trading, and the other half is convinced their backup QB is the next coming of Drew Brees. If you’re staring at the waiver wire wondering how to fix your roster, you’re in the right place.
The qb fantasy rankings week 2 aren't just about who threw the most touchdowns on Sunday. It’s about context. It’s about realizing that a bad Week 1 doesn't mean a bad season, but a bad matchup in Week 2 can absolutely kill your chances of going 2-0.
Honestly, the biggest mistake people make right now is overreacting to "box score scouting." You see a quarterback with 12 points and assume he’s toast. You see a guy with 28 points and think he’s a lock for the Pro Bowl. Neither is usually true. Let’s break down the reality of the Week 2 landscape.
The Elite Tier: No Questions Asked
There are a few guys you just start. Period.
Josh Allen and Lamar Jackson remain the gold standard. Even if the Bills or Ravens have a weird afternoon, their rushing floors are so high that they’ll almost always finish as a top-10 option. In Week 2, Allen faces a Jets defense that can be stingy, but you aren't benching him. Jackson is coming off a massive Week 1 against Buffalo where he looked fully recovered from that training camp foot scare. He faces Cleveland this week. It's a divisional grind, but his mobility makes him matchup-proof.
Jalen Hurts is in this group too. The "Tush Push" (or whatever they’re calling it this year) is still the most efficient goal-line play in football. If the Eagles are inside the five-yard line, Hurts is probably getting six points.
Why QB Fantasy Rankings Week 2 Look Different This Year
We have some serious injuries to deal with. Joe Burrow is likely out for a significant stretch with turf toe—the kind of injury that ruins a season for a pocket passer. If you were banking on Burrow, you’re officially in the "streaming" market.
Then there’s the Brock Purdy situation. Reports out of San Francisco suggest he’s a "longshot" for Week 2 with a toe and shoulder issue. If Mac Jones gets the start against the Saints, the entire 49ers' offensive outlook shifts. You’re likely not starting Mac Jones in a 1-QB league, but it makes guys like Ricky Pearsall (who had a huge debut) a lot riskier.
The "Rushing Upside" Trap
Everyone wants the next Jayden Daniels. In Week 1, Daniels showed exactly why he was a first-round fantasy pick—his legs are a cheat code. However, heading into Week 2 against the Packers, you have to wonder if Green Bay will sell out to stop the run and force him to win from the pocket.
📖 Related: Upcoming UFC Fights 2025: Why This Year Changed Everything
Justin Fields is another name popping up in the qb fantasy rankings week 2 discussion. Now with the Jets, his rushing ability is undeniable, but he’s currently in concussion protocol. If he clears, he’s a high-ceiling play against a Bills defense that can occasionally lose contain. If he doesn’t, you’re looking at Tyrod Taylor, which is a massive downgrade for the entire offense.
The Mid-Tier Muddle: Who to Trust?
This is where the real decisions happen.
- Dak Prescott: He’s coming off a quiet game against the Eagles but gets a "get right" game against the Giants. The Giants' secondary looked vulnerable in the opener. Dak is a top-5 play this week because the volume should be there.
- Jordan Love: He looks like the real deal. Facing the Commanders in Week 2 is a dream matchup. Washington's defense has been a "funnel," meaning they stop the run okay but get shredded through the air. Love is a "must-start" if you have him.
- Baker Mayfield: Seriously? Yes, seriously. Baker threw 3 touchdowns in Week 1. He looks comfortable in that Bucs system. He’s playing the Texans this week in what could be a high-scoring shootout. Don't let the name on the jersey scare you away from the points.
Streaming Options for the Desperate
If you’re the Burrow owner or you drafted Anthony Richardson and are worried about his accuracy, you might be looking at the waiver wire.
Bo Nix is an interesting case. He’s playing the Colts this week. The Colts' defense is... fine. But Nix has shown a willingness to run near the goal line, and in fantasy, rushing yards are worth more than passing yards. He’s a "sneaky" start if you’re in a 2-QB league or a very deep 1-QB league.
On the flip side, avoid Tua Tagovailoa this week if you can. He’s facing the Patriots. Bill Belichick might be gone, but the defensive DNA is still there, and they historically have Tua’s number. Plus, Tua is coming off a rough Week 1 where he struggled with interceptions.
Real Evidence: The Numbers That Matter
When looking at qb fantasy rankings week 2, pay attention to Pressure Rate. If a quarterback was under pressure on more than 40% of his dropbacks in Week 1, and he’s facing a heavy-blitzing team in Week 2, he’s going to struggle.
For example, Matthew Stafford is playing the Titans. Stafford is a legend, but he’s dealing with a banged-up offensive line. The Titans' front four is no joke. If Stafford doesn't have time to find Puka Nacua or Davante Adams, he’s going to have a long day.
Actionable Next Steps for Your Roster
- Check the Concussion Protocol: If you own Justin Fields, you need a backup plan by Thursday. Check for Sam Darnold or even Geno Smith on the wire.
- Monitor the 49ers' Injury Report: If Purdy is out, don't just blindly start the 49ers' pass-catchers. Mac Jones changes the timing of that offense significantly.
- Don't Chase Last Week's Points: Baker Mayfield's three touchdowns were great, but don't bench a Tier 1 guy like Patrick Mahomes just because he only had one. Mahomes is playing the Eagles in a Super Bowl rematch. He’s going to be aggressive.
- Verify the Weather: It’s September, so we usually don't have to worry about snow, but keep an eye on wind speeds in outdoor stadiums. Anything over 15 mph starts to affect the deep ball.
The quarterback position is the highest-scoring spot on your roster. Don't overthink it, but don't be lazy either. Use the data, watch the injury reports, and trust your gut. If a guy looks like he’s "seeing ghosts" on the field, he probably is. Cut him loose and find someone who isn't. High-volume passing and goal-line rushing are the only two things that actually matter at the end of the day. Matchups just tell us how likely those two things are to happen.