Finding a decent place to shop in downtown Fort Myers used to be a bit of a headache. Honestly, for years, if you lived in the historic district or near the riverfront, you were basically forced to drive out to the suburbs just to find a fresh head of lettuce that didn't look like it had been through a war. That changed when the Publix Super Market at First Street Village opened its doors. It wasn't just another grocery store; it was a signal that the downtown area was finally growing up.
It's located at 2160 McGregor Blvd.
Most people just call it the "Downtown Publix." It sits right at that awkward but vital intersection where First Street meets McGregor Boulevard, acting as a gateway between the high-rise condos of the River District and the leafy, palm-lined streets of the historic neighborhoods. If you've ever tried to navigate that intersection during season, you know it’s a mess. But the store itself? It’s a sanctuary.
Why Publix Super Market at First Street Village Actually Matters
For the locals, this specific location solved a massive "food desert" problem. Before this Publix arrived, the options were either overpriced convenience stores or a long trek down Cleveland Avenue. Now, you’ve got a full-scale supermarket that actually fits the aesthetic of the area. It’s got that classic Floridian stucco look, plenty of parking (thank god), and an atmosphere that feels a bit more "upscale neighborhood" than "corporate warehouse."
What makes the Publix Super Market at First Street Village stand out isn't just the location, though. It's the layout.
Unlike the massive, sprawling Publix "Sabor" stores or the giant suburban prototypes, this one feels manageable. You can actually run in for a gallon of milk and a Pub Sub and be out in fifteen minutes. Try doing that at some of the bigger locations during the winter rush—you’ll be stuck behind three tourists trying to figure out how a BOGO works for half an hour.
The Pub Sub Culture in Downtown
We have to talk about the deli. It’s basically the heartbeat of the store. If you arrive around 12:15 PM on a Tuesday, you’re going to see a line of lawyers from the nearby courthouse, construction workers in neon vests, and retirees in golf shirts all waiting for a Chicken Tender Sub. It’s the great equalizer of Fort Myers.
A pro tip for this specific location: use the Publix app.
👉 See also: Sleeping With Your Neighbor: Why It Is More Complicated Than You Think
Seriously. The deli at First Street Village gets slammed because of the proximity to the downtown offices. If you walk up to the counter and order a custom sub during the lunch rush without an online order, you’re making a mistake. You'll be standing there staring at the Boar’s Head meat display for twenty minutes while the person behind the counter frantically assembles three "Buffalo Chicken" subs for people who aren't even in the building yet.
The Layout and Local Finds
The produce section at the Publix Super Market at First Street Village is usually tighter and more curated than what you'll find at the bigger stores on Six Mile Cypress. They know their audience. You'll see more organic options and "grab-and-go" meals tailored for the condo dwellers across the street who don't always feel like cooking a four-course meal in a galley kitchen.
I’ve noticed the wine selection here is surprisingly deep. It’s clearly geared toward the "Sunset on the balcony" crowd. They stock a lot of higher-end Napa cabs and Italian whites that you won't always find at the budget-friendly grocers. It’s a smart move. They know that if someone is spending $800,000 on a condo at St. Tropez or Beau Rivage, they probably aren't looking for the cheapest jug wine on the shelf.
The bakery is another story.
Those mini-croissants? Dangerous. The "First Street" bakery team seems to have a better handle on the Cuban bread than some other locations in the county. It’s always crusty, never soggy. If you’re hosting a brunch, grabbing a loaf of their sourdough and some of the whipped honey butter is a low-effort win that makes you look like a gourmet.
Parking: The Great Fort Myers Struggle
Let’s be real—parking in downtown Fort Myers is usually a nightmare. At the Publix Super Market at First Street Village, the parking lot is designed in a way that’s mostly functional, but people still manage to mess it up. The entrance off McGregor can be tricky because of the traffic flow coming from the bridge.
If you’re coming from the Edison & Ford Winter Estates side, just be patient. The pedestrians here are often tourists who are more interested in the banyan trees than your car's front bumper. There is plenty of shaded parking near the back of the lot if you don't mind a thirty-second walk. Your car’s interior temperature will thank you in July.
✨ Don't miss: At Home French Manicure: Why Yours Looks Cheap and How to Fix It
Navigating the "Season" at First Street
Between January and April, everything in Fort Myers changes. The Publix Super Market at First Street Village is no exception. The "Snowbird" influx is real.
During these months, you have to change your strategy. Shopping on a Saturday morning is basically an Olympic sport. If you can, go on a Tuesday evening after 7:00 PM. The store is quiet, the shelves are usually restocked for the next day, and you don’t have to engage in a low-speed cart battle in the cereal aisle.
One thing I appreciate about this location is the staff. Many of them have been there for years. In an era where customer service feels like it’s dying, you still get that "Where shopping is a pleasure" vibe here. They actually help you find the weird ingredients, like where they hid the tahini or which aisle has the specific brand of gluten-free crackers your spouse insisted on.
Sustainability and Community Impact
Publix as a corporation has been pushing more sustainability initiatives lately, and you see it here. The plastic bag recycling bins are always full, and they’ve transitioned to more eco-friendly packaging in the prepared foods section.
The store also acts as a bit of a community hub.
The bulletin board near the exit isn't just for show. You’ll see flyers for local charity 5Ks, lost pets in the Dean Park area, and notices for neighborhood association meetings. It’s a reminder that even though it’s a big chain, this specific store is woven into the fabric of the neighborhood. It’s where you run into your neighbors and end up talking about the local school board for twenty minutes by the frozen peas.
What to Know Before You Go
There are a few quirks to keep in mind. The pharmacy at the Publix Super Market at First Street Village is excellent, but it’s busy. Like, really busy. If you’re transferring a prescription, do it early.
🔗 Read more: Popeyes Louisiana Kitchen Menu: Why You’re Probably Ordering Wrong
- Check the weekly ad on Thursdays. That’s when the new BOGO deals drop.
- The "Aprons" cooking station often has samples. Don't be shy; it's usually the best way to figure out what to cook for dinner when you have zero inspiration.
- If you need dry cleaning, there’s a service right there, which is a lifesaver for the professionals working in the city center.
The liquor store is separate but attached. Florida laws are weird like that. If you need a bottle of bourbon, you have to walk outside and enter through a different door. It’s a minor inconvenience, but the selection is solid and the prices are standard Publix—which is to say, fair but not "liquor warehouse" cheap.
Actionable Steps for Your Next Visit
If you want to master the Publix Super Market at First Street Village experience, stop just "winging it." Start by downloading the Publix app and clipping your digital coupons before you even leave the house; the reception inside can sometimes be spotty depending on your carrier.
Plan your trip for mid-week, ideally Wednesday evening or Thursday morning, to catch the best of the produce and the fresh rotation of sales. If you are a fan of the deli, use the "Pre-O" system. It saves you at least 15 minutes of standing around.
For those living in the nearby high-rises, consider walking or biking if you only need a few items. There are bike racks available, and it beats fighting the McGregor traffic for a five-block trip. Finally, take advantage of the "Special Order" capability at the meat counter. If you need a specific cut for a weekend BBQ, call them a day ahead. They are surprisingly accommodating and will have it wrapped and ready with your name on it.
This store is a tool for better living in downtown Fort Myers. Use it right, and it makes the urban lifestyle a whole lot easier.
Keep an eye on the seasonal floral arrangements near the entrance too. They often get locally sourced tropical plants that hold up much better in the Florida humidity than the standard roses you find at a gas station. It’s the little details that make this specific Publix feel less like a chore and more like a part of the local lifestyle.