When you dive into a mind in Psychonauts 2, it isn’t just the psychedelic art style or the gravity-defying platforming that hits you. It’s the voices. It's that feeling of coming home to a group of friends you haven't seen in sixteen years, yet they haven't aged a day. Honestly, pulling off a sequel over a decade later and keeping the original soul intact is a nightmare for most studios. But Double Fine didn't just bring back the old guard; they sprinkled in some of the biggest names in Hollywood and voice acting to create something that feels massive and intimate at the same time.
The Psychonauts 2 voice actors are the reason this game works. Without Richard Steven Horvitz's specific brand of high-energy vulnerability, Raz is just another kid in goggles. Without the legendary chemistry of the returning cast, the Motherlobe would feel like a hollow museum of nostalgia.
The Return of the Aquatos and the O.G. Crew
It starts with Richard Steven Horvitz. You've heard him as Billy from The Grim Adventures of Billy & Mandy or Zim from Invader Zim. He is Razputin Aquato. What’s wild about his performance here is how he manages to make Raz sound older—more capable, more of a "real" Psychonaut—while keeping that wide-eyed wonder. It’s a delicate balance. If he sounded too mature, we’d lose the charm. If he sounded too much like a toddler, the stakes of the story wouldn't land.
Then you have the mentors.
✨ Don't miss: Professor Layton and the Miracle Mask: Why This 3DS Classic Is Still Worth Your Time
Stephen Stanton returns as Sasha Nein, and he is as dry and clinical as ever. Sasha is the kind of character who could easily become a boring robot, but Stanton gives him these tiny flickers of humanity that make you love him. On the flip side, Alexis Lezin brings Milla Vodello back to life with that effortless warmth. The "mom and dad" energy between Sasha and Milla is essentially the glue that holds the Psychonauts together.
And we can't talk about the original cast without mentioning Nicki Rapp as Lili Zanotto. Lili is a tough character to get right because she’s cynical and "too cool" for everything, but Rapp ensures she never feels mean. Her relationship with Raz is the heart of the series, and their banter in the sequel is arguably some of the best writing in the game.
The New Blood: Celebrity Guests and Surprise Cameos
Double Fine didn't just stick to the classics. They brought in some serious heavy hitters. If you’ve played through the "PSI King’s Sensorium" level, you know exactly what I’m talking about.
- Jack Black as Helmut Fullbear: Jack Black doesn't just "do a voice." He becomes the soul of the level. Helmut Fullbear is a musician and a founding member of the Psychonauts who has been... well, missing his body for a while. Black’s performance is bombastic and heartfelt. He even gets to sing! His rendition of "Cosmic I" is a genuine highlight of the entire game.
- Elijah Wood as Gristol Malik: This was the one that caught many people off guard. Elijah Wood plays Nick Johnsmith (the mailroom guy) but also voices the primary antagonist, Gristol Malik. Wood has this incredible ability to sound perfectly innocent and deeply sinister in the same breath. It's a far cry from Frodo, and it shows off his range in a way that’s honestly kind of terrifying.
Why Psychonauts 2 Voice Actors Matter for immersion
A lot of modern games go for "prestige" acting—very quiet, very grounded, very "HBO." Psychonauts 2 spits in the face of that. It embraces the "cartoony" roots of the first game but uses the actors to ground the heavy emotional themes.
Take David Kaye as Ford Cruller. Ford is a broken man in this game—literally. He’s split into multiple personas because of his shattered mind. Kaye has to play a barber, a bowling alley attendant, and a high-ranking official, all while making them feel like the same person under the surface. It’s a technical achievement that often goes overlooked.
Then there’s the Psychic Six.
Getting veteran actors like Piotr Michael (Otto Mentallis), Stephanie Komure (Cassie O'Pia), and Nick Tate (Compton Boole) was a stroke of genius. These characters are supposed to be legends, and their voices carry that weight. When you hear Compton Boole’s voice crack with anxiety, you feel the decades of trauma the character has endured.
The "Fun" Cameos You Might Have Missed
Double Fine is a small-feeling studio despite their success, and they love bringing in friends. If you listen closely in the casino level, you might recognize some familiar voices from the Rooster Teeth and Funhaus world.
- James and Elyse Willems: They play the "Rich Dad" and "Rich Mom" at the Lady Lucktopus Casino.
- James Willems also voices a very specific toilet (specifically Toilet #4).
It’s these little "if you know, you know" moments that make the world feel like it was built by people who actually like each other.
The Full Cast Breakdown (Who Plays Who?)
If you're looking for a specific name, here is the breakdown of the major players that defined the experience. It's a mix of legendary voice talent and newcomers who absolutely nailed the vibe.
📖 Related: Jack Hammer in Blue Prince: What Most Players Get Wrong
Richard Steven Horvitz is the lead as Razputin "Raz" Aquato. He’s the engine.
Nicki Rapp returns as Lili Zanotto, the pyrokinetic girlfriend-not-girlfriend.
David Kaye takes on the monumental task of Ford Cruller and his various "shattered" versions.
Stephen Stanton and Alexis Lezin are back as Sasha Nein and Milla Vodello.
Nick Jameson reprises his role as Coach Oleander, and he also voices the recurring villain Dr. Loboto.
Darin DePaul brings a regal yet weary energy to Truman Zanotto.
Audrey Wasilewski delivers a powerhouse performance as Nona/Lucrecia Mux, the secret heart of the Aquato family drama.
Piotr Michael plays Otto Mentallis, the gadget-obsessed scientist.
Stephanie Komure gives a haunting, multi-layered performance as Cassie O'Pia.
There’s also Armin Shimerman as Augustus Aquato. Yes, that’s Quark from Star Trek: Deep Space Nine. He brings a surprising amount of pathos to Raz’s dad, especially when you realize his own history with water and the "curse."
The Impact of Voice Direction
We have to give flowers to the voice directors here. In a game where you are literally jumping inside people’s brains to fight their personified "Internal Regrets" and "Bad Moods," the acting could easily become too campy.
But the Psychonauts 2 voice actors were directed with a sense of "emotional realism." When Raz talks to a Mote of Light (Jack Black), he treats it with respect and empathy. The actors don't treat the weirdness like a joke; they treat it like their reality. That’s why the ending hits so hard. When the secrets of the Psychic Six are finally laid bare, the performances shift from whimsical to heartbreaking.
Real Talk: Why This Game is Better with Headphones
If you want to appreciate these performances, you need a good pair of cans. The sound design uses spatial audio to place these voices in the environment. You'll hear the "voices in your head" quite literally as you navigate the mental worlds. The way Cassie O’Pia’s voice echoes through her library of paper memories is something you just don't get from cheap TV speakers.
Actionable Next Steps for Fans
If you’ve finished the game and you’re craving more from this incredible cast, here is what you should do:
- Watch "2 Player Productions" Documentary: They filmed the entire development of the game. You can see the actual recording sessions with Jack Black and Richard Horvitz. It’s on YouTube and it’s called Psychodyssey. It is 32 episodes of pure insight into how these voices were captured.
- Check out the Rhombus of Ruin: If you skipped the VR bridge game between the first and second titles, go back to it. Most of the main cast is there, and it sets up the beginning of Psychonauts 2 perfectly.
- Explore the Cast's Other Work: If you loved Darin DePaul (Truman), go play Overwatch (Reinhardt) or Halo Infinite (Escharum). If you liked David Kaye, check out his legendary run as Megatron in Transformers.
- Replay with "Narrative" Focus: Now that you know the twists regarding Gristol and the Psychic Six, replay the early levels. Listen to the specific inflection in the actors' voices. There are clues hidden in the dialogue delivery that you’ll only catch the second time around.
The casting of Psychonauts 2 wasn't just about getting big names; it was about getting the right voices to tell a very human story about mental health, family secrets, and the messiness of the human mind. They nailed it.