You're in the middle of a heated argument. Maybe you forgot to pay a bill, or perhaps you snapped at your partner after a long day. Instead of saying, "Yeah, my bad," you find yourself saying, "Well, if you hadn't been nagging me all morning, I wouldn't have been so stressed!"
That right there? That is deflection in psychology.
It’s a pivot. A sidestep. A verbal smoke bomb. Basically, it's a defense mechanism where a person redirects focus away from their own behavior and onto someone else’s perceived flaws. It feels like a survival instinct in the moment, but in reality, it’s one of the fastest ways to erode trust in a relationship.
We all do it. Honestly, if you say you’ve never deflected, you’re probably deflecting right now. But when it becomes a chronic habit, it turns into a major barrier to emotional intelligence and genuine connection.
What Is Deflection in Psychology, Really?
At its core, deflection is an unconscious maneuver used to avoid the discomfort of shame or guilt. Sigmund Freud’s daughter, Anna Freud, did a lot of the heavy lifting in defining these sorts of defense mechanisms. She noted that the ego—that part of us trying to keep things balanced—uses these tricks to protect us from "ego threats."
When someone points out a mistake you made, it threatens your view of yourself as a "good" or "competent" person. To keep that self-image intact, your brain decides the best defense is a good offense.
Think of it like a game of hot potato. The "potato" is the responsibility for a mistake. It’s burning your hands. You don't want to hold it, so you toss it to the person across from you as fast as you can. "I’m not the problem," you're essentially saying. "You are."
The Narcissism Connection
It’s important to distinguish between the occasional "I'm having a bad day" deflection and the calculated deflection seen in personality disorders. While everyone deflects sometimes, individuals with Narcissistic Personality Disorder (NPD) use it as a primary tool for "image management."
For a narcissist, admitting a mistake isn't just an inconvenience; it feels like a total annihilation of their self-worth. So, they don't just redirect; they often gaslight. They make you question your own reality so they never have to face theirs. This is why conversations with chronic deflectors feel like walking through a hall of mirrors. You start by talking about their lateness and end up apologizing for your tone of voice three years ago.
Why Do Our Brains Love This Shortcut?
Our brains are wired for efficiency and safety. Admitting fault requires "limbic friction"—that internal resistance we feel when we have to do something hard.
- Vulnerability Avoidance: Being "wrong" feels vulnerable. For many, vulnerability is synonymous with weakness.
- Childhood Conditioning: If you grew up in a house where mistakes were met with harsh punishment or ridicule, you learned early on that "owning it" wasn't safe. Deflection became a survival strategy.
- Cognitive Dissonance: This is a big one. If I believe I am a kind person, but I just did something unkind, my brain experiences a painful glitch. To fix the glitch, I have to either change my self-view (hard) or blame the external environment (easy).
Most people choose easy.
Real-World Examples of Deflection in Action
Let’s look at how this actually sounds in the wild. It’s rarely as simple as "No, you!" It’s usually much more subtle.
The "Whataboutism" Strategy
Person A: "Hey, I noticed you didn't do the dishes like you said you would."
Person B: "Well, what about last week when you left your gym bag in the hallway for three days? I didn't say anything then!"
Notice how Person B never addressed the dishes. They just dragged a past grievance into the present to even the score.
The Victim Play
Person A: "It really hurt my feelings when you made that joke at dinner."
Person B: "Oh, so now I'm just a terrible person? I can't do anything right in this house. I guess I'll just stop talking entirely."
By exaggerating the critique into a personal attack, Person B forces Person A to stop expressing their hurt and start comforting Person B. It’s a brilliant, if toxic, redirection.
The "Legalistic" Deflection
This is where someone focuses on a tiny, irrelevant detail of your argument to avoid the broader point. If you say, "You've been coming home at 2:00 AM every night this week," and they respond with, "Actually, on Tuesday it was 1:45 AM, so you'm clearly exaggerating," they are deflecting. They are arguing about the clock to avoid arguing about the commitment.
The Cost of the Pivot
The problem with deflection in psychology is that it works in the short term. You get out of the hot seat. You don't have to feel bad.
But in the long term? It’s a disaster.
When you deflect, you deny yourself the opportunity for growth. If you never admit you're wrong, you never learn how to be right. Relationships die because the other person eventually realizes that their feelings will never be validated. They stop bringing things up. They withdraw. The "peace" you get from deflecting is actually just the silence of a dying connection.
Research by Dr. John Gottman, a famous relationship expert, suggests that "defensiveness"—which includes deflection—is one of the "Four Horsemen" that predict the end of a relationship. It's that serious.
Breaking the Cycle: How to Stop Deflecting
If you’ve realized that you’re a bit of a deflector, don't panic. Awareness is literally 90% of the battle here. Most people who deflect do it so fast they don't even realize they've done it until the argument is over.
✨ Don't miss: Walking in the Rhythm: Why Your Pace Matters More Than Your Step Count
1. The Five-Second Rule
When someone brings a concern to you, your nervous system will likely go into "fight or flight." Your chest might tighten. You might feel a flash of heat.
Wait. Count to five before you speak. This allows the prefrontal cortex (the logical part of your brain) to catch up with the amygdala (the emotional alarm system).
2. Validate One Small Piece
You don't have to agree with everything the other person is saying. But to stop the deflection, find one grain of truth in their statement.
"You're right, I did forget the dishes."
Period. No "but." No "because." Just the facts. It’s incredibly disarming.
3. Watch Your "Buts"
The word "but" is a linguistic eraser. Everything you say before the "but" doesn't count.
"I'm sorry I was late, but traffic was insane."
That’s not an apology; it’s an explanation disguised as one. Try replacing "but" with "and."
"I'm sorry I was late, and I know it frustrated you."
4. Curiosity Over Certainty
Instead of defending your position, ask a question.
"Can you tell me more about why that bothered you?"
This shifts the dynamic from a courtroom (where you're the defendant) to a laboratory (where you're both researchers trying to solve a problem).
How to Handle a Deflector
Dealing with someone else's deflection is like trying to catch a greased pig. Every time you think you've made a point, they slip away.
The trick is to stay on the "Main Road." When they try to bring up something you did three months ago, say: "I’m happy to talk about that later, and I hear that you're upset about it. But right now, I want to finish talking about [the current topic]."
Don't follow them down the rabbit hole. If they keep trying to change the subject, name the behavior.
"I feel like we're moving away from the topic. Can we stay on this for just another minute?"
The Path Forward
Understanding deflection in psychology isn't about shaming yourself or others. It’s about recognizing that we are all deeply afraid of not being "enough." We deflect because we want to be loved and respected, and we fear that our mistakes make us unlovable.
The irony? We are most respected when we own our mess. There is a profound power in saying, "I messed up, I see how it hurt you, and I want to do better."
Actionable Steps for Today:
- Audit your last argument: Think back to the last time you felt defensive. Did you bring up a counter-complaint? Did you minimize the issue? Just acknowledge it to yourself.
- Practice "The Mirror": Next time someone gives you feedback, repeat it back to them before responding. "So, what I'm hearing is that you felt ignored when I stayed on my phone during dinner. Is that right?"
- Check your physical cues: Start noticing if your jaw clenches or your heart rate spikes when you're criticized. That's your "Deflection Alert."
- Read up on Cognitive Dissonance: Understanding why your brain wants to lie to you makes it easier to tell the truth. Leon Festinger’s work on this is a great place to start.
Real growth doesn't happen when we're comfortable. It happens in that sweaty, awkward moment where we choose to stay in the conversation instead of running away. Own your "hot potato." It’s the only way to cool it down.