Let’s be real. If you’re a fan of Shawn Spencer’s hyper-observant antics, you probably have a mental list of the "best" episodes, and "Not Even Close Encounters" is almost always sitting pretty in the top ten. It’s the fourth episode of Psych’s fifth season, and honestly, it’s a masterclass in how to do a "is it supernatural or just a crime?" plot without being cheesy. It first aired back in 2010. Feel old yet? Because I definitely do.
This episode isn't just about aliens. It’s about friendship. Specifically, it’s about the strained, nerdy, and deeply relatable friendship between Shawn, Gus, and their childhood buddy Dennis Gogolack, played by the brilliant Freddie Prinze Jr.
The premise is basically peak Psych. A prominent researcher at a local tech firm, who also happens to be a massive UFO nut, vanishes into thin air—or, as Dennis believes, into a tractor beam. Shawn and Gus dive in, mostly because they want to play with high-tech gadgets and relive their childhood "Close Encounters" fantasies. But things get weird. Fast.
The Dennis Gogolack Factor
What makes Psych "Not Even Close Encounters" work so well is the guest casting. Freddie Prinze Jr. wasn't just a random celebrity cameo; he fit the vibe. He plays Dennis, a guy who grew up to be a seemingly boring, high-powered professional with a secret: he’s still a massive nerd. He has a secret room in his house filled with alien memorabilia that he hides from his wife, Molly.
It’s hilarious. It's also kinda sad?
We’ve all been there. You hide your "uncool" hobbies because you think you have to be a "real adult." Watching Shawn and Gus—the two men who never grew up—interact with Dennis is pure comedy gold. They’re basically the devil and the angel on his shoulder, except both are telling him to buy more vintage Star Wars toys.
📖 Related: Why American Beauty by the Grateful Dead is Still the Gold Standard of Americana
Dennis is convinced his colleague was abducted. He provides the "scientific" (term used loosely here) backing for the alien theory. He has the charts. He has the blurry photos. He has the enthusiasm of a kid who just saw E.T. for the first time. This creates the perfect foil for Lassiter and Juliet, who are, as usual, skeptical as hell.
When the Sci-Fi Tropes Hit the Fan
The writers, led by Bill Callahan, clearly had a blast with the references here. You can’t have an episode called "Not Even Close Encounters" without nodding to Spielberg. We get the iconic five-tone sequence. We get the mashed potato mountain—well, okay, maybe not the potatoes, but the vibe is there.
One of the best scenes involves the "abduction site." There’s a crop circle. There are "radiation" readings. Shawn, using his "psychic" powers (which we all know is just him noticing the specific tread on a tire or a stray hair from a lab coat), has to navigate a world where the evidence actually looks otherworldly.
The episode plays with the idea of the "Gray Alien." You know the one. Large head, almond eyes, spindly limbs. It’s a trope that’s been baked into our culture since the 60s. Psych takes that imagery and turns it into a plot point involving high-end tech and corporate espionage. It’s clever because it uses our collective cultural "knowledge" of aliens to distract us from the actual crime, just like it distracts Gus and Dennis.
The Real Mystery: Corporate Greed vs. Little Green Men
Let’s talk about the tech. The "aliens" are actually a cover for something much more grounded: theft. Specifically, the theft of high-altitude surveillance tech. This is where the episode gets smart. It grounds the fantastical in the mundane world of intellectual property theft.
👉 See also: Why October London Make Me Wanna Is the Soul Revival We Actually Needed
The "abduction" was a staged event to cover up a murder. The victim, a guy named Toby, had discovered that his boss was selling secrets. To get rid of him and the evidence, the killer used a specialized "vacuum" system and some clever lighting to make it look like he was beamed up.
I love how the show handles the reveal. Shawn doesn't just say "it's not aliens." He explains how the trick was done. He points out the pressurized seals. He identifies the specific chemical signatures that Dennis mistook for "alien residue." It’s a reminder that Shawn is actually a genius, even if he spends half the episode trying to convince people he’s a space traveler.
Key Moments You Might Have Forgotten
- The Secret Room: Dennis’s "nerd cave" is legendary. It’s the dream of every 90s kid.
- The "Gus" Nicknames: We get some solid ones here. Does "Methuselah Honeysuckle" ring a bell?
- Lassiter's Skepticism: Timothy Omundson plays the "I'm too old for this" trope so well. His reaction to the alien theories is pure gold.
- The Cameos: Beyond Freddie Prinze Jr., keep an eye out for the subtle nods to other sci-fi properties.
Why We Keep Coming Back to This Episode
Psych "Not Even Close Encounters" works because it doesn't mock the fans. Sure, it pokes fun at the absurdity of UFO culture, but it does so with a wink and a nod. It understands the appeal of the unknown.
The relationship between Shawn and Gus is at its peak here. They bicker about Star Wars vs. Star Trek. They argue about the logistics of a tractor beam. It feels like a real conversation you’d have with your best friend at 2 AM after a sci-fi marathon.
Moreover, the episode tackles the theme of authenticity. Dennis learns that he doesn't have to hide who he is from his wife. It’s a sweet, albeit brief, emotional arc that gives the episode more weight than your standard "case of the week."
✨ Don't miss: How to Watch The Wolf and the Lion Without Getting Lost in the Wild
Actionable Insights for Your Next Rewatch
If you’re planning to dive back into this episode, or if you’re a newcomer to the series (lucky you), here are a few things to keep in mind to get the most out of it.
Watch the Background
Psych is famous for its hidden pineapples. There is one in almost every episode. In "Not Even Close Encounters," keep your eyes peeled during the scenes in Dennis's house. It’s a fun game that actually makes you pay closer attention to the set design, which is top-tier in this episode.
Listen for the "Suck It"
The banter in season 5 is particularly sharp. The "Suck It" musical riffs are starting to evolve. Pay attention to the timing between James Roday Rodriguez and Dulé Hill. Their chemistry is the engine that runs the show, and it’s firing on all cylinders here.
Track the Clues
Try to solve the case before Shawn does. Look at the "alien" evidence through a cynical lens. Look for the physical explanations for the lights, the sounds, and the disappearances. It’s a great way to appreciate how well-constructed the mystery actually is.
Recognize the Guest Star Legacy
Freddie Prinze Jr. eventually returned to the Psych universe (though in different capacities/mentions). His presence marked a turning point where the show started attracting bigger "genre" stars who were fans of the show themselves. It changed the energy of the production.
This episode remains a staple of the series because it perfectly balances the "Pineapple" humor with a genuine mystery. It’s a reminder that while the truth might be out there, it’s usually a lot more human—and a lot more greedy—than we’d like to believe. Whether you’re here for the UFOs or just for the Bromance, this one delivers.