So, you’ve seen the price tag on the PS5 Pro. It’s steep. Sony isn't exactly making it easy on our wallets this time around, especially when you realize that $700 (or more if you're in the UK or EU) doesn't even get you a disc drive or a vertical stand. Naturally, your first thought is probably: "How much can I get for my old console?" A PS5 Pro trade in is basically the only way most of us are going to justify this upgrade without feeling a massive pit of guilt in our stomachs. But here is the thing. If you just walk into a store today and hand over your launch-day console, you’re likely leaving a couple hundred bucks on the table.
Timing is everything.
Right now, the secondary market is in a weird spot. Retailers like GameStop, Best Buy, and even specialized sites like Gazelle or Back Market are constantly shifting their valuations based on how much stock they’re sitting on. If everyone trades in their base PS5s the week the Pro launches, the value drops. Supply and demand—it’s a basic concept, but it hits hard when you're trying to fund a mid-gen refresh. Honestly, I’ve seen trade-in values swing by $50 in a single afternoon just because a specific retailer hit their quota for used hardware.
Where the Best PS5 Pro Trade In Deals Are Hiding
Let's look at the big players. GameStop is the obvious choice for most, and they know it. They often run "Pro Member" specials where you get an extra 10% or 20% on trade-ins. If you aren't a member, it might actually be worth paying the $25 membership fee just to secure an extra $60 in trade value. It’s math.
Best Buy is another heavy hitter. Their trade-in program is surprisingly solid, though they give you store credit via a gift card. This is fine if you're buying the PS5 Pro from them anyway. However, their online estimator is notoriously finicky. If your controller has even a tiny bit of stick drift, they might dock you significantly more than you'd expect. I’ve heard horror stories of people being offered $250 online and then walking into the store only to be told it's worth $180 because of a scratch they didn't even notice.
Then you have the "sell it yourself" route. eBay, Swappa, or Facebook Marketplace.
🔗 Read more: Free games free online: Why we're still obsessed with browser gaming in 2026
You’ll always get more cash this way. Always. A base PS5 with a disc drive can still pull $350 to $400 on the private market if it's clean and has the original box. Compare that to the $225 to $275 retailers are offering. But—and this is a big "but"—you have to deal with the "is this still available?" messages at 3:00 AM and the risk of getting scammed. For many, the convenience of a retail trade-in is worth the $100 "tax" they lose in potential profit.
Why Your PS5 Slim Might Be Worth Less Than a Launch Model
This sounds counterintuitive, right? Usually, newer means better. But in the world of trade-ins, the original "fat" PS5 with the disc drive is often the gold standard. Collectors and casual gamers alike still value that chunky aesthetic and the perceived reliability of the early cooling systems.
When you go for a PS5 Pro trade in, retailers are looking at the SKU. If you have the Digital Edition, prepare for a haircut on the price. The digital-only consoles have always had lower resale value because the buyer is locked into the PlayStation Store. With the PS5 Pro being a premium, enthusiast-grade machine, the people buying used consoles are often looking for the cheapest entry point possible, which keeps the Digital Edition prices suppressed.
Also, check your cables.
Retailers will ding you for missing the HDMI 2.1 cable or the USB-C charging cord. If you don't have the original Sony-branded ones, find some high-quality replacements before you go in. They usually won't check if the HDMI cable is the exact one from the box, but it needs to look the part and support the bandwidth.
💡 You might also like: Catching the Blue Marlin in Animal Crossing: Why This Giant Fish Is So Hard to Find
The "Dirty" Secret of Refurbishment Fees
Ever wonder why your trade-in quote drops the second the clerk touches your console? It's the "Refurb Fee."
If your PS5 looks like it’s been living in a woodshop, they’re going to charge you to clean it. Dust in the vents is a dealbreaker. Before you even think about a PS5 Pro trade in, get a can of compressed air. Take the plates off. It takes five minutes. Clean out the "dust catchers" that Sony so graciously included in the design. A clean console looks like a well-cared-for console, and that can be the difference between a "Good" rating and a "Fair" rating.
And for the love of everything, fix your controller.
Stick drift is the silent killer of trade-in value. Most retailers test the controllers on a PC using software that detects input errors. If your sticks are jittering, they’ll either reject the trade or deduct $40-$50 for a "defective" controller. If you're handy, you can sometimes fix minor drift with some isopropyl alcohol around the base of the stick, but if it's a hardware failure, you might be better off buying a cheap used controller that works perfectly and trading that in instead.
Retailer Comparison (Estimated Values)
- GameStop: Usually offers around $250 for a Disc version, potentially $300+ during promo events.
- Best Buy: Ranges from $225 to $280 depending on the week.
- Back Market/Gazelle: Often lower ($180-$210) but they offer cash instead of credit.
- Private Sale (FB Marketplace): The sweet spot is usually $350, assuming you have the box.
Preparing Your Data for the Big Swap
Don't just hand over your life's work. You need to back up your saves. If you have PlayStation Plus, this is easy—everything is in the cloud. But if you don't, or if you have a ton of 4K captures and screenshots you don't want to lose, you’ll need an external drive.
📖 Related: Ben 10 Ultimate Cosmic Destruction: Why This Game Still Hits Different
The most important step? Deactivate as Primary Console. Go into your settings and make sure you sign out and deactivate the console before you factory reset it. If you don't, you might run into licensing issues on your new PS5 Pro. It’s a headache you don't want. After that, perform a full initialization. Not the "quick" one. The full one. It takes a couple of hours, but it ensures your data is actually gone and not just hidden.
Once that's done, your console is ready for its next life.
Is the Upgrade Actually Worth the Trade?
This is the $700 question. The PS5 Pro offers the new PSSR (PlayStation Spectral Super Resolution), which is basically Sony's version of DLSS. It makes games look sharper without killing the frame rate. For people with 120Hz OLED TVs, the difference is noticeable. For people playing on a 27-inch 1080p monitor they bought in 2018? Honestly, you probably won't see much of a difference.
If you are a "Performance Mode" addict who hates seeing 30fps, the trade-in is a no-brainer. The Pro is designed to hit that 60fps target with "Fidelity" level visuals. But if you're happy with how Spider-Man 2 or God of War Ragnarok looks right now, you might want to wait. Trade-in values for the base PS5 aren't going to crater overnight. They’ll stay relatively stable for at least another year.
Actionable Steps to Maximize Your Trade
- Monitor the "Trade Days": Retailers like GameStop frequently run "Trade-In Marathons" where values spike by 20%. Follow their social media or check their app daily starting about two weeks before you plan to buy.
- Deep Clean the Vents: Take the faceplates off. Use a soft brush and compressed air. A "Like New" appearance prevents the clerk from reflexively clicking the "Fair" button on their terminal.
- Bundle Wisely: If you have games you'll never play again, trade them with the console. Sometimes a "bundle" trade-in gets you a slightly better percentage on the total value.
- Test Your Controller: Use a site like gamepad-tester.com to check for drift. If it's failing, try to fix it or swap it before you head to the store.
- Check Local Pawn Shops: This is a wildcard. Sometimes local, high-end pawn shops are desperate for current-gen consoles and will pay more in cash than a big-box retailer will in credit. It’s worth a five-minute phone call.
- Verify the Disc Drive: If you are moving to a PS5 Pro, remember it doesn't come with a disc drive. If you have a library of physical discs, you'll need to buy the $79.99 add-on drive. Factor this into your trade-in math—you might need to trade in even more gear just to break even on your physical library access.
Taking these steps ensures you don't walk into a store and get lowballed. Knowledge is the only thing that keeps your money in your pocket when hardware cycles shift. The PS5 Pro is a luxury item, and treating your trade-in like a business transaction is the only way to make the numbers make sense.