Honestly, trying to guess what Sony is going to drop on the PS Plus Extra catalog feels a bit like trying to predict the weather in a video game—sometimes it’s a clear blue sky, and other times a random dragon shows up. You've seen the threads. You've seen the "leaks" that look like they were made in MS Paint. But as we look toward the PS Plus Extra September 2025 predictions, things are actually starting to crystallize in a way that makes sense if you look at the patterns.
September is usually a transitional month. Kids are back in school, and Sony often tries to bridge the gap between the summer lull and the massive holiday rush. In 2024, we saw the day-one launch of The Plucky Squire, which was a huge get. If history repeats itself—and it usually does with Sony’s licensing deals—we’re looking at a mix of high-profile third-party titles and maybe a "hidden gem" indie that everyone will claim they liked before it was cool.
Why the PS Plus Extra September 2025 Predictions are Tricky
Most people get this wrong by assuming Sony just picks games out of a hat. It's much more about contract cycles. Typically, games hit the service roughly 12 to 18 months after their initial release. That’s why you’ll see people banging the drum for titles that launched in early 2024.
Think about it. We’re deep into 2025. Sony has to keep the momentum going because Game Pass is still breathing down their neck, despite the recent price hikes across all tiers. People are picky now. If the lineup is just a bunch of shovelware and sports games from three years ago, the Reddit pitchforks come out immediately.
👉 See also: Free Roblox Avatar Ideas That Actually Look Good Without Robux
The AAA Heavy Hitters We Might See
Let’s talk about the big ones. Everyone wants the blockbusters. Based on how Sony has been moving, Assassin’s Creed Mirage is a prime candidate. Ubisoft and Sony have a relationship that’s tighter than a pair of skinny jeans. Mirage has been out long enough that Ubisoft is likely looking for a final injection of players before they fully pivot to their next massive project.
Another name that keeps popping up in the rumor mill is Resident Evil Village. Yes, it’s been around for a while, but Capcom likes to cycle their hits through subscription services to drive sales for the next sequel. It fits the "spooky season is coming" vibe that starts to creep in during late September.
- Potential Frontrunner: Assassin’s Creed Mirage (PS4/PS5)
- The "Long Shot": Star Wars Outlaws (Probably too early, but hey, stranger things have happened)
- The "Safe Bet": Atomic Heart
The "Day One" Indie Factor
Remember Sea of Stars? Or The Plucky Squire? Sony loves to secure a "Day One" indie for the Extra tier to justify the subscription cost. For September 2025, the buzz is centering around smaller, highly-stylized titles.
💡 You might also like: The Animal Crossing New Horizons Museum Is Better Than Most Real Ones
There’s a specific kind of "Sony Indie" feel—games that are atmospheric, maybe a bit moody, and definitely photogenic. If a game like Sword of the Sea or a similar Giant Squid production is slated for a late Q3 release, it wouldn't be shocking to see it land directly in the Game Catalog. It’s a win-win. The devs get a massive player base instantly, and we get something fresh to play without dropping $30.
Don't Sleep on the Simulator Crowd
I know, I know. Not everyone wants to pretend they’re a power washer or a goat. But Sony loves adding niche simulators to the Extra catalog. They’re great "podcast games"—you just zone out and click things. Expect at least one game where you either build a city, fix a car, or manage a farm. It’s basically a law of nature at this point.
What's Actually Confirmed (and What Isn't)
Let's be real for a second. Until the PlayStation Blog post goes live—usually on the second Wednesday of the month—everything is educated guesswork. However, we do know that Sony has been pushing the PS VR2 titles into the Premium tier more aggressively. For the Extra tier specifically, the focus remains on the "hits of yesterday."
If you’re looking at PS Plus Extra September 2025 predictions, you have to look at what’s leaving the service too. Usually, when a big franchise title leaves, another one from the same publisher arrives to take its place. If a bunch of Square Enix titles are scheduled to exit, keep an eye out for something like Crisis Core: Final Fantasy VII Reunion to make an appearance.
The Timing You Need to Know
Sony typically announces the Extra and Premium additions on the Wednesday following the Essential game release.
- Announcement Date: Likely around September 10, 2025.
- Release Date: Likely Tuesday, September 16, 2025.
Addressing the "Bad Month" Complaints
Every single month, without fail, someone calls the lineup "the worst ever." It’s a tradition. But usually, these "bad months" are just months where the games don't align with the mainstream AAA crowd. If September 2025 leans heavily into JRPGs or survival games—like Green Hell or Fate/Samurai Remnant did in previous cycles—half the internet will be thrilled and the other half will be miserable.
Nuance matters here. A month that gives us a niche masterpiece like Crow Country is arguably better than a month with a mediocre AAA shooter that everyone already played two years ago.
Actionable Next Steps for Subscribers
- Check your "Expiring Soon" list: Before you get excited about the new games, make sure you haven't missed out on titles leaving in September. Use the "Last Chance to Play" section on your console.
- Don't buy Ubisoft games in August: If you're eyeing Mirage or Avatar: Frontiers of Pandora, just wait. They are the most likely candidates to hit the service in the coming months.
- Clear some hard drive space: These catalogs are getting bigger, and with 2025's file sizes, you're going to need a decent SSD. If you haven't upgraded your internal storage yet, now is the time before the holiday releases start eating your gigabytes.
Keep your expectations in check, but keep an eye on those Ubisoft and Capcom catalogs. They’re the most consistent indicators of where the service is headed next.