Honestly, if you grew up with the Narnia movies, you probably think of Caspian as a bearded, slightly moody Spanish-sounding guy played by Ben Barnes. And that’s fine. But it’s also a bit of a lie. When C.S. Lewis first sat down to write Prince Caspian, he wasn't thinking about cinematic franchises or "darker sequels." He was trying to figure out how to get four kids back into a world that had moved on without them.
It’s a weird feeling, right? Going back to a place you loved only to find out everyone you knew is dead and the castle is a ruin. That’s the emotional core of these books. Prince Caspian and The Voyage of the Dawn Treader are often lumped together because they form the "Caspian Cycle," but they are wildly different animals. One is a war story about reclaiming a stolen heritage. The other is a psychedelic sea voyage toward the edge of the world.
The Continuity Gap We All Ignore
Most people forget that there's a huge time jump between these two adventures. In our world, it’s only been a year. In Narnia? Thousands of years passed before Caspian, and then another three years go by before the Dawn Treader pulls the kids back in.
Lewis was kinda obsessed with this idea of "Narnian time." He never wanted it to be a 1:1 ratio. He liked the idea that you could be a king for forty years and come back to England in time for tea. But when Edmund and Lucy return in The Voyage of the Dawn Treader, Caspian isn't the scared kid hiding in the woods anymore. He's a king. He's got a beard (finally). He’s also looking for his father's friends who were essentially exiled by his murderous uncle, Miraz.
Why the Movies Fumbled the Vibe
Let's be real: the Prince Caspian movie tried too hard to be Lord of the Rings. It added a weird romance between Susan and Caspian that literally never happened in the books. Why? Because Susan is technically older than him in spirit but Caspian is a literal teenager. It was messy.
Then you have the Dawn Treader movie. It tried to invent a "seven swords" plot to give the story a traditional villain, but the book isn't about a villain. It’s an odyssey. It’s episodic. You visit an island, you deal with a dragon or a gold-water pool, and you move on. By trying to make it a "save the world" epic, the films lost the "spiritual travelogue" feel that Lewis intended.
💡 You might also like: Greatest Rock and Roll Singers of All Time: Why the Legends Still Own the Mic
Eustace Scrubb: The Character Everyone Loves to Hate
You can't talk about The Voyage of the Dawn Treader without talking about Eustace Clarence Scrubb. And he almost deserved it. That’s how the book starts. Lewis has a field day mocking Eustace’s "progressive" upbringing. His parents are vegetarians, non-smokers, and they wear "special underwear."
Eustace is the audience surrogate for the skeptic. He doesn't believe in Narnia even when he's standing on the deck of a ship. It takes him literally turning into a dragon—a physical manifestation of his greedy, prickly soul—to realize he’s a jerk.
The "undragoning" scene is arguably the most famous moment in the entire series. Aslan has to peel off the dragon skin with his claws. It’s visceral. It’s painful. Lewis was making a point about how hard it is to actually change your nature. You can't just "decide" to be better; sometimes you need a giant lion to scratch the scales off.
The Secret Influence of "Immram"
Ever heard of a Celtic Immram? Probably not unless you’re a medieval literature nerd like Lewis was. These are old Irish tales about sea voyages to the "Otherworld." Think The Voyage of Saint Brendan.
Lewis wasn't just making up random islands. He was tapping into a very specific tradition of "wandering on the water."
📖 Related: Ted Nugent State of Shock: Why This 1979 Album Divides Fans Today
- The Lone Islands: A critique of bureaucracy and the slave trade.
- The Island of Voices: A weird, surreal look at invisible creatures (Dufflepuds) who are obsessed with looking "correct."
- The Dark Island: Where dreams come true. Not the good dreams. The nightmares.
This isn't "baby's first fantasy." It’s actually pretty dark. The Dark Island is basically a psychological horror trope written in 1952. If you've ever woken up in a cold sweat, you know exactly what the crew of the Dawn Treader felt when they realized their worst thoughts were becoming physical.
Reepicheep is the Real Hero (Don't @ Me)
Caspian is the King, but Reepicheep is the soul of the ship. A two-foot-tall mouse with a rapier and a death wish. In Prince Caspian, he's almost a comic relief character until he loses his tail and his fellow mice offer to cut theirs off in solidarity.
But in The Voyage of the Dawn Treader, he’s the one driving the plot. He isn't looking for lost lords. He’s looking for the "utter East." He wants to find Aslan's Country.
There is a weirdly beautiful, lonely ending to his story. He paddles a small coracle up a literal wall of water at the end of the world and disappears. No one else can go. It’s a one-way trip. Even as a kid, that felt heavy. It's about the "last adventure" we all eventually take.
How to Read Them Today
If you're revisiting these, don't follow the "chronological order" that HarperCollins tries to push now. Reading The Magician's Nephew first ruins the mystery.
👉 See also: Mike Judge Presents: Tales from the Tour Bus Explained (Simply)
Start with The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe, then hit Prince Caspian, then The Voyage of the Dawn Treader. This is the order they were published, and it's how the narrative "unfolds." You're supposed to discover Narnia's history at the same time the Pevensies do.
Actionable Takeaways for Fans
- Check out the BBC Miniseries (1989): Yeah, the effects look like they were made with cardboard and hope, but it’s way more faithful to the books than the big-budget movies.
- Look for the "Planet Narnia" Theory: Scholar Michael Ward argues that each Narnia book corresponds to one of the seven medieval planets. Prince Caspian is Mars (War). Dawn Treader is Sol (Light/Sun). It changes how you see the imagery.
- Read the "Un-Dragoning" Chapter Aloud: Even if you aren't religious, the prose in that chapter of Dawn Treader is some of the best Lewis ever wrote.
The real magic of Prince Caspian and The Voyage of the Dawn Treader isn't the talking animals. It’s the feeling of growing up and realizing that the "magic" of childhood is something you have to carry with you, even when the wardrobe door won't open anymore. You eventually get too old for Narnia, just like Peter and Susan did. But as Aslan says, the goal is to find him in our world, under a different name.
Whatever that means to you, the journey on the ship is well worth the ticket.
Next Steps: If you're looking to dive deeper into the lore, your best bet is to find a copy of The Narnian by Alan Jacobs. It’s the definitive biography of C.S. Lewis that explains exactly why he put things like "Dufflepuds" and "Telmarines" into his stories. Also, keep an eye on the Greta Gerwig Netflix adaptations currently in development—they’re rumored to be going back to the "weird" roots of the books.