You just spent five hundred bucks on a new optic, it arrives, and... something is off. Maybe the reticle isn't as crisp as you thought it would be, or perhaps you realized you bought the wrong mount entirely. It happens. But now you’re staring at the box, wondering if the Primary Arms return policy is going to be a total nightmare or a breeze.
Buying gun parts online is tricky.
Most people think they can just slap a label on a box and ship it back like they’re returning a pair of socks to Amazon. Honestly, it doesn't work that way in the firearms industry. Primary Arms is actually pretty reasonable compared to some of the "all sales are final" shops out there, but they have some hard lines in the sand that will get your return rejected faster than a cheap casing in a high-end race gun.
The 90-Day Window and the "New" Condition Trap
First thing you've got to know: you have 90 days. That sounds like a lot of time. It is. But there is a massive catch that trips up almost everyone who isn't a seasoned builder. The item has to be new, unaltered, and in the original packaging.
If you mounted that scope, tightened the screws down, and left those tiny little "ring marks" on the tube, you’ve basically bought it.
Primary Arms is sticklers about this. They have to be. They aren't an outlet mall; they are a high-volume retailer that prides itself on QC. If you send back a red dot that has a scratch on the battery cap from a screwdriver, their intake team is going to see it. They won't be able to sell it as "new" to the next guy, so they won't give you a full refund.
✨ Don't miss: At Home Fake Plants: Why Your Decor Probably Looks Cheap and How to Fix It
What happens if you did mount it? Usually, they’ll offer a partial refund or just send it back to you. It's a bummer, but it's the reality of the business. If you’re unsure about an optic, hold it up, look through it, but for the love of everything holy, don't mount it to a rail until you’re 100% sure it’s staying.
The Absolute "No-Go" Items
There are things you simply cannot return. Period.
- Ammunition: For obvious safety and legal reasons, once that ammo leaves their warehouse, it is yours forever. No one wants to buy "second-hand" ammo that might have been stored in a humid garage or tampered with.
- Firearms: This is the big one. Once you walk out of your local FFL (Federal Firearms Licensee) and the transfer is complete, the Primary Arms return policy effectively ends for that serialized lower or rifle. If you find a defect later, you're dealing with the manufacturer's warranty, not the Primary Arms customer service desk.
- Binary Triggers and Certain Internal Parts: Some high-performance parts are considered final sale due to the nature of their installation and use.
Check your order twice.
If you bought a 30-round mag and you live in a state where they only allow 10 rounds, they might not even ship it, but if it slips through and you try to return it? That gets complicated legally. Always know your local laws before hitting that "checkout" button because a "mistake" isn't always a valid reason for a return in the eyes of their legal department.
Dealing with Defective Stuff and the "Save the Day" Warranty
Now, if the product is actually broken? That's a different story.
Primary Arms is actually famous for their own brand of optics—the PLx, GLx, and SLx lines. If you bought a Primary Arms branded scope and the illumination flickers or the turrets feel like they're filled with sand, they generally take care of you. Their "Lifetime Warranty" is legit.
I’ve seen cases where guys beat the hell out of an SLx optic, and the company still swapped it out because the internal component failed. They want you to trust their glass.
However, if it’s a third-party brand—like a Holosun or a Trijicon—Primary Arms will often tell you to go to the manufacturer first. Why? Because Trijicon wants to see their own failures. It’s faster for you, too. If Primary Arms takes it back, they just ship it to Trijicon anyway. You might as well cut out the middleman and get your replacement faster.
📖 Related: Weather Atlanta Georgia January: What Most People Get Wrong
The RMA Process: Don't Just Mail It
Whatever you do, do not just put a stamp on the box and send it to their Pearland, Texas address. It will get lost. Or worse, it will sit in a corner of the warehouse for three weeks because no one knows why it’s there.
You need an RMA (Return Merchandise Authorization).
- Log into your account.
- Find the order.
- Click the return button.
- Wait for the email.
They usually respond pretty quickly—typically within 24 to 48 business hours. Once you have that RMA number, write it in big, bold Sharpie on the outside of the shipping box. Not the product box. The shipping box.
Shipping Costs: Who Pays?
If you just changed your mind? You pay.
It sucks, especially with shipping rates going up, but that’s the standard. If they messed up—like they sent you a 5.56 muzzle brake when you ordered a .308 one—they will send you a pre-paid label.
Pro tip: Keep your tracking number.
I can't tell you how many people I've talked to who sent back a $600 optic and didn't get a tracking number, only for the package to go "missing" in the USPS ether. Without that number, Primary Arms can't help you, and the post office certainly won't.
The Refund Timeline
Expect to wait.
Once the tracking says "Delivered" in Texas, don't expect the money in your bank account five minutes later. Their returns department has to physically open the box, inspect the item for those "ring marks" we talked about, and verify all the parts (like the lens cloth and the little hex keys) are still in the box.
Usually, it takes about 3 to 5 business days for them to process it, and then another 3 to 7 days for your bank to stop holding onto your money. Basically, figure on a two-week turnaround from the day you ship it.
Why Some People Get Mad
Most negative reviews about the Primary Arms return policy come from one of three things:
- Trying to return a firearm after the FFL transfer.
- Trying to return an optic that was clearly mounted and scratched.
- Missing the 90-day window.
If you stay within the rules, they are actually one of the easiest companies in the industry to work with. They aren't trying to scam you; they’re just trying to make sure they aren't losing money on "used" gear being passed off as new.
Actionable Steps for a Smooth Return
If you're sitting there with a box right now, here is exactly what you should do to ensure you get your money back without a fight:
- Inspect the item immediately. Do not wait 89 days. Open the box, check the glass, check the finish.
- Take photos. Before you put it back in the box, take a quick photo of the item showing it’s in perfect condition. If it gets damaged during shipping back to Texas, you’ll want proof it wasn't you.
- Include everything. If it came with a sticker, a manual, and a cheap plastic bag, put it all back. Missing accessories can lead to "restocking fees" which are usually around 10-15%.
- Use a sturdy outer box. Don't just slap a label on the manufacturer's box. Put the product box inside another box with some packing peanuts or paper.
- Check your email for the RMA. If you don't see it, check your spam folder. It’s almost always there.
If you follow those steps, you’ll be fine. Primary Arms is run by enthusiasts, and they get that sometimes gear just doesn't fit the build. Just treat their stuff with respect, and they’ll treat your refund with respect.
If you have a specialized case—like a warranty claim on an older optic—skip the standard return portal and call their customer service line directly. Talking to a human in Texas is usually the fastest way to solve a weird problem that doesn't fit into a standard drop-down menu on a website. They’re known for actually picking up the phone, which is a rarity these days.
Don't overthink it. Just be honest about the condition, move fast, and keep your paperwork. You'll have your funds back for your next build before you know it.