Let’s be real for a second. When we all heard there was going to be a reboot of the original Freeform fever dream, expectations were... mixed. But Pretty Little Liars: Summer School—the second season of the Original Sin era—didn’t just try to copy the homework of the OG series. It pivoted. Hard. If you grew up watching Aria and Spencer get texts about their boyfriends while wearing five-inch heels to homeroom, the vibe in Millwood is going to feel like a punch to the gut.
It's grittier. It’s bloodier. And honestly? It’s basically a slasher movie stretched out over eight episodes.
The premise is simple enough. Our core five—Imogen, Tabby, Faran, Mouse, and Noa—are trying to move past the trauma of Archie Waters. But because the universe hates them, they’ve flunked their sophomore year thanks to all the serial killer distractions. Now, they’re stuck in summer school. But instead of just worrying about remedial math, they’re being hunted by a new, bandaged nightmare known as Bloody Rose.
Who Was Actually Under the Bandages?
Everyone spent the better part of the season pointing fingers at everyone from Dr. Sullivan (the ultimate throwback character) to Kelly Beasley’s unhinged mother. The show really leaned into the "urban legend" aspect of it all. They used this site called Spooky Spaghetti—which is such a ridiculous name that it somehow works—to build up Bloody Rose as this supernatural boogeyman.
✨ Don't miss: Temuera Morrison as Boba Fett: Why Fans Are Still Divided Over the Daimyo of Tatooine
But the reveal? It was grounded in something much more personal and, frankly, petty.
Mrs. Langsberry, the mother of the predatory Chip from season one, was the one wielding the knife. She wasn't acting alone, though. The mastermind was Wes, Tabby’s pretentious boss at the Orpheum. His motive was basically "I'm a frustrated white male filmmaker who wants to create the ultimate slasher movie." It’s meta, it’s a little bit cringe, and it’s exactly the kind of unhinged logic you want in a Pretty Little Liars spinoff.
The season finale, "Final Exam," really put the "final" in Final Girl. Seeing Tabby emerge as the ultimate survivor wasn't just satisfying; it felt like the show finally figured out its own identity. It’s not about secrets and high-school cliques anymore. It’s about survival.
🔗 Read more: Why Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy Actors Still Define the Modern Spy Thriller
Why This Season Hit Differently
Most reboots fail because they’re too scared to leave the shadow of the original. Pretty Little Liars: Summer School leaned into the horror tropes. We’re talking Texas Chain Saw Massacre levels of tension.
- The Final Girl Tests: Each girl had to face a personalized "test" from Bloody Rose. Faran holding up a literal steel beam to save her life? Iconic. Mouse dealing with the psychological wreckage of her Spooky Spaghetti obsession? Relatable for anyone who spends too much time on Reddit.
- The Cult Vibes: The introduction of the Redemption House and the creepy church elements added a layer of "small-town rot" that the original series never quite touched.
- The Trauma is Real: Unlike the OG girls who seemed to bounce back from kidnapping with a fresh blowout, these girls are struggling. They’re in therapy. They’re messy. They make terrible romantic choices (looking at you, Noa).
One thing that genuinely surprised me was how they handled Dr. Sullivan. Bringing back Annabeth Gish was a masterstroke for the fans, but the writers weren't afraid to use her as more than just a walking Easter egg. Her death at the hands of Archie Waters in the final moments was the show's way of saying, "The old world is dead. Welcome to the new Millwood."
The Bloody Rose Legacy
If you're wondering if the show is coming back, the ending basically screamed "Season 3." With Archie Waters still on the loose and a whole new "slasher villain" (or villains) being teased by Tabby, the stakes are only going up.
💡 You might also like: The Entire History of You: What Most People Get Wrong About the Grain
There's a lot of debate online about whether the Mrs. Langsberry reveal was "too obvious." Sure, she had the motive. But in a show that often tries to subvert expectations just for the sake of it, having the killer be the person with the most logical reason for revenge felt... right. It wasn't a "secret twin from England" situation. It was a mother’s grief turned into a homicidal performance art piece.
The cinematography this season also took a massive leap forward. The Hudson Valley locations—Saugerties, Newburgh, and Kingston—provide this oppressive, humid atmosphere that makes the summer setting feel claustrophobic instead of sunny. You can almost smell the popcorn and stale soda at the Orpheum.
What to Do Next
If you just finished your binge-watch and your brain is still spinning, here is how to stay ahead of the next season:
- Re-watch the "Final Girl" Tests: Look closely at the background of Faran’s and Noa’s scenes. There are subtle nods to the "mastermind" behind the camera that you likely missed the first time.
- Track the Archie Waters Timeline: Since he’s officially "resurrected" and out for blood, mapping out his connections to the remaining parents in Millwood is going to be key for season three theories.
- Check out the Horror References: Tabby mentions dozens of films. Watching the classics like Scream 2 (which heavily influenced the motive this season) or Midsommar gives you a better appreciation for the visual cues the directors were using.
The transition from a mystery-drama to a full-blown slasher series is complete. Millwood is officially a death trap, and honestly, we wouldn't have it any other way. Keep an eye on the casting calls for 2026; if the production stays in New York, we're likely looking at another blood-soaked summer very soon.
To get the most out of the upcoming theories, start by documenting the survivors of the "Redemption House" cult, as they are the most likely candidates for Archie's new "followers" in the next chapter.