Walk into any high-end boutique in Antwerp or New York’s Diamond District, and you’ll see the same thing. Rows of Round Brilliants. It’s the default. It’s safe. But honestly, most people confuse "shape" with "cut," and that’s the first mistake that costs them thousands of dollars.
When we talk about precious stone cuts shapes, we’re actually talking about two distinct things. The shape is the outline—heart, square, oval. The cut is the technical arrangement of facets that dictates how light moves through the pavilion and bounces back to your eye. You can have a pear shape that looks like a dull piece of glass because the cut proportions are garbage. It happens more than jewelers like to admit.
I’ve spent years looking at stones under 10x magnification. Most buyers focus on carat weight, thinking bigger is better. It isn't. A poorly cut 2-carat Sapphire will look smaller and "muddier" than a perfectly proportioned 1.5-carat stone. This is because a shallow cut allows light to "leak" out the bottom, creating a "window"—basically a big dead spot in the middle of the gem.
The geometry of the Round Brilliant vs. everything else
The Round Brilliant is the king of precious stone cuts shapes for a reason. Marcel Tolkowsky basically mathematically perfected it back in 1919. He calculated the exact angles—usually a 34.5-degree crown angle and a 40.75-degree pavilion angle—to ensure maximum fire. It has 57 or 58 facets. It’s bright. It’s classic.
But it’s also incredibly wasteful.
When a cutter takes a piece of rough stone, they often lose over 50% of the original weight just to get that perfect round shape. That's why rounds are the most expensive per carat. You’re paying for the dust left on the cutting floor.
✨ Don't miss: Why T. Pepin’s Hospitality Centre Still Dominates the Tampa Event Scene
If you want value, you look at "fancy shapes." These are basically anything that isn't round. Ovals, Marquise, and Pears are fantastic because they are elongated. They "face up" larger. An Oval cut Sapphire of the same weight as a Round will almost always look bigger to the naked eye because of that length. Plus, they make fingers look longer and slimmer, which is a nice bonus if you're into that.
The Step Cut: Why Emerald and Asscher are for the brave
Step cuts are different. Unlike the "brilliant" style, which uses triangular and kite-shaped facets to create sparkle, step cuts use long, rectangular facets that look like a hall of mirrors. The Emerald cut is the most famous example.
It’s an honest cut.
You can’t hide inclusions in an Emerald cut. If there’s a tiny "feather" or a spot of carbon in a diamond, or a "silk" inclusion in a Ruby, a Brilliant cut might disguise it with all that flashing light. An Emerald cut? It’s a window. It demands high clarity. If you buy a low-clarity stone in an Emerald shape, you’re going to see every single flaw. But when you get a clean one? There is nothing more sophisticated. It’s architectural.
The Asscher cut is the Emerald’s square cousin. Developed by the Asscher Brothers in Holland in 1902, it gained massive popularity during the Art Deco movement. It has a higher crown and a smaller table (the flat top of the stone) than a standard Emerald cut. It’s moody. It’s vintage. It feels like old money.
🔗 Read more: Human DNA Found in Hot Dogs: What Really Happened and Why You Shouldn’t Panic
Why some precious stone cuts shapes work better for colored gems
Diamonds are all about dispersion—the "fire" or "rainbow" flashes. Colored stones like Emeralds, Rubies, and Sapphires are about "extinction" and "saturation."
If you cut a Ruby like a Diamond, you might actually lose color. The light path needs to be longer inside the stone to pick up the rich red hues. This is why you see so many colored stones in "Cushion" or "Oval" cuts with "brilliant" tops and "step" bottoms. It’s called a mixed cut.
Take the "Cushion" cut. It’s been around for 200 years. It looks like a square with rounded corners—sorta like a pillow. It’s the go-to for Sapphires because it retains the most natural color from the rough.
- Radiant Cuts: These are great for stones with slightly weaker color because the facet pattern (70 facets!) intensifies the hue.
- Princess Cuts: This square, sharp-cornered cut is incredibly popular for engagement rings, but be careful. Those corners are thin. They can chip if they aren't protected by the prongs of the setting.
- Heart Shapes: These are technically difficult. If the "cleft" (the dip at the top) isn't deep enough, it just looks like a lumpy triangle.
The physics of the "Bow-Tie" effect
If you are shopping for Ovals, Marquise, or Pear shapes, you have to look for the bow-tie. It’s exactly what it sounds like: a dark, tie-shaped shadow across the middle of the stone.
It’s caused by light blockage. When you look at the stone, your head and shoulders actually block some of the light that would otherwise enter the gem. Because of the way these elongated shapes are faceted, they reflect that darkness back at you.
💡 You might also like: The Gospel of Matthew: What Most People Get Wrong About the First Book of the New Testament
A slight bow-tie is normal. It gives the stone character. But a heavy, black bow-tie that kills the sparkle in the center? Walk away. No "good deal" is worth a dead stone.
How to actually choose without getting ripped off
Most people go into a jewelry store and just pick what looks "pretty" under the bright halogen lights. Those lights are designed to make even a piece of salt sparkle.
Ask the jeweler to see the stone under natural light. Take it to a window.
Look at the length-to-width ratio. For an Oval, a classic look is usually between 1.30 and 1.50. Anything higher and it looks like a skinny toothpick; anything lower and it looks like a "squoval" (a fat oval). For a Marquise, you’re looking at 1.75 to 2.15. These ratios are the "secret sauce" of precious stone cuts shapes that pros use to determine if a stone is well-proportioned.
Also, check the "girdle"—the thin edge where the top of the stone meets the bottom. If it's too thin, the stone is fragile. If it's too thick, you’re paying for "hidden" weight that you can’t even see once it's in a setting. It’s "dead weight" that adds to the price but adds zero beauty.
Actionable steps for your next purchase
Don't just buy the first sparkly thing you see. If you're serious about getting the best value and look, follow this checklist:
- Prioritize Cut Grade over Carat Weight: A 0.90-carat "Excellent" cut stone will often outshine and out-measure a 1.00-carat "Good" cut stone. It’ll be cheaper too because it stays under the 1-carat price jump.
- Verify the Shape Ratio: If you’re buying an Oval or Pear, ask for the length-to-width ratio. Don't rely on your eyes alone; the numbers don't lie.
- Check for "Windowing": Hold the stone over a piece of paper with text on it. If you can read the text through the stone, the cut is too shallow. That’s a window. It shouldn't be there.
- Consider the Setting: If you love the Marquise or Pear shape, ensure your setting has a V-prong to protect the pointed tips. Those are the most vulnerable parts of the stone.
- Look for Symmetry: In shapes like the Heart or Pear, draw an imaginary line down the center. One side should be a mirror image of the other. If one "shoulder" is higher than the other, the stone will always look "off."
Understand that the "best" shape is subjective, but a "good" cut is objective science. You want the science to work in your favor so the subjective beauty actually shines through. Go for the "Fancy" cuts if you want more bang for your buck, but stick to the "Brilliant" style if you want that classic, room-filling sparkle. Keep the ratios in mind, avoid the windows, and never buy a stone under jewelry store spotlights alone.