It didn't work. That is the simplest, most honest starting point for any conversation about the movement to pray away the gay. For decades, thousands of people walked into church basements and clinical offices hoping to flip a switch on their biology. They were told that their sexual orientation was a "maladaptive" response to childhood trauma or a spiritual failing that could be scrubbed clean with enough fasting and focused prayer. It sounds like a relic of the 1950s, doesn't it? But this isn't ancient history. It’s a living, breathing reality for many, and the wreckage it left behind is still being mapped out by psychologists today.
The term "conversion therapy"—or sexual orientation change efforts (SOCE)—is a bit of a misnomer because "therapy" implies a clinical standard of care. There isn't one here. Basically, it’s a patchwork of religious counseling and discredited psychological theories that claim you can change who you love.
📖 Related: Anthony Fauci: What Most People Get Wrong About His Age and Legacy
The Rise and Fall of Exodus International
You can't talk about the effort to pray away the gay without talking about Exodus International. Founded in 1976, it was the "Big Box Store" of conversion efforts. It grew into a massive global network. They had the pamphlets, the conferences, and the charismatic leaders who claimed they were "ex-gay." People looked at someone like Alan Chambers, the former president of Exodus, and saw hope. If he could do it, they could too.
Then everything collapsed.
In 2013, Chambers did something almost unheard of in the world of religious advocacy. He apologized. He didn't just step down; he shut the whole thing
down. He admitted that 99.9% of the people he met in the movement hadn't actually experienced a change in their orientation. They had just learned to hide it. Or they had learned to live in a state of perpetual self-denial that Chambers eventually recognized as deeply harmful. When the biggest organization dedicated to this goal closes its doors and says, "We were wrong," it should have been the end of the story.
But it wasn't. It just went underground.
Why People Still Buy Into It
You might wonder why anyone would still seek this out in 2026. Honestly, it usually comes down to a desperate desire to belong. If your entire social structure, your family, and your eternal salvation are tied to being straight, you'll try almost anything to make that a reality. It’s a survival mechanism.
The logic used in these circles often revolves around "reparative therapy." This was popularized by guys like Joseph Nicolosi. He argued that male homosexuality was caused by a "father wound"—basically, a lack of connection with a father figure during childhood. The "cure" was to engage in hyper-masculine activities. Go to the gym. Watch football. Bond with men in non-sexual ways. It was a pseudo-scientific attempt to fix a problem that major health organizations like the American Psychological Association (APA) and the American Medical Association (AMA) say doesn't exist.
The APA has been pretty clear about this for a long time. They’ve stated that there is no credible evidence that sexual orientation can be changed through these methods. More importantly, they’ve highlighted the risks: depression, anxiety, and a significantly higher risk of suicide. When you tell someone that their core identity is a mistake that needs to be fixed, and then that "fix" fails, the person doesn't blame the method. They blame themselves.
The Harm is Quantifiable
We aren't just guessing about the damage anymore. The Trevor Project and researchers at UCLA’s Williams Institute have put numbers to the pain. According to their data, LGBTQ youth who underwent conversion therapy were more than twice as likely to report having attempted suicide in the past year compared to those who weren't subjected to it.
Think about that.
It's not just "ineffective." It's dangerous.
The techniques have evolved, too. In the old days, some extreme versions used "aversion therapy." This involved giving people electric shocks or nausea-inducing drugs while showing them images of same-sex partners. While that kind of "Clockwork Orange" stuff is rarer now, the modern version is often more subtle. It’s "talk therapy" that uses shame as a primary tool. It's telling a teenager that their feelings are a "temptation" rather than an identity. This kind of spiritual grooming can leave scars that take decades to heal.
What the Law Says Now
The legal landscape is a bit of a mess, depending on where you live. In the United States, several states have banned conversion therapy for minors. The logic is that kids can't truly consent to a practice that major medical boards have labeled as harmful. California was a pioneer here, and many others followed.
However, these bans usually only apply to licensed secular professionals. They often don't touch "pastoral counseling." This creates a massive loophole. If a church leader wants to tell a kid to pray away the gay, they are often protected by religious freedom laws. This is where the bulk of this activity happens today—in private homes and church offices, away from the eyes of state regulators.
✨ Don't miss: 8 oz Milk Calcium: Why This Tiny Glass Still Sets the Gold Standard for Your Bones
In other parts of the world, the crackdown is harder. Countries like Germany, Canada, and France have passed much broader bans. They see it as a human rights issue. They argue that nobody should be allowed to "treat" someone for something that isn't a disease.
The Myth of the "Ex-Gay"
We’ve seen a pattern over the last few decades. A "star" of the ex-gay movement emerges. They write a book. They go on the talk show circuit. They become the poster child for the idea that change is possible. And then, five or ten years later, they come out.
Look at John Paulk. He was the face of the "Love Won Out" campaign and appeared on the cover of Newsweek with his wife. He was the gold standard for the movement. Years later, he was spotted in a gay bar, eventually apologized for his role in the movement, and is now living as an openly gay man.
These stories aren't outliers; they are the trend. The human brain is incredibly resilient, but sexual orientation is baked in pretty deep. You can't just "un-wire" it through sheer willpower or repetitive chanting.
The Shift Toward "Sexual Fluidity" Misuse
Recently, some proponents of these methods have started using the term "sexual fluidity" to justify their work. They take the legitimate research of people like Dr. Lisa Diamond—who found that some people’s attractions can change over time—and weaponize it. They argue that if sexuality is fluid, then we should be able to "direct" that fluidity toward heterosexuality.
Dr. Diamond has been very vocal about how her research is being misused. Fluidity isn't something you can force. It’s a natural, internal process for some people, but it’s not a tool that a therapist can use to "steer" someone away from being gay. It’s a cynical rebranding of the same old "pray away" goals.
Navigating the Aftermath
If you or someone you know has been through this, the road back is often long. It involves "un-learning" a lot of self-hatred.
The first step is usually finding a "trauma-informed" therapist. Not just any therapist, but one who understands the specific religious trauma associated with conversion efforts. You have to deconstruct the idea that your feelings are a moral failure.
✨ Don't miss: How Many Calories in a Tablespoon of Honey: What Most People Get Wrong
It also involves finding a new community. For many, leaving the "pray away" world means losing their entire social circle. That’s a terrifying prospect. But there are groups like "Encircle" or the "Q Christian Fellowship" that work with people trying to reconcile their faith with their identity without trying to "fix" who they are.
Real Insights for Moving Forward
If you are a parent or a church leader, the most important thing to understand is that "behavioral compliance" is not the same as "change." A kid might stop talking about their attractions because they want to please you or because they are scared. That doesn't mean the attractions are gone. It just means they’ve gone underground, where they can turn into depression or self-harm.
Here are the actionable realities:
- Check the Credentials: If a counselor claims they can help "reduce" same-sex attractions, they are practicing SOCE, regardless of what they call it. This is a red flag that they are operating outside of mainstream medical ethics.
- Prioritize Mental Health Over Identity Goals: Instead of focusing on "becoming straight," focus on reducing anxiety and increasing self-esteem. When the goal is "wholeness" rather than "conversion," the health outcomes are significantly better.
- Listen to the Survivors: Read the stories of people who have been through these programs. Don't just look at the glossy testimonials on a ministry website. Look at the long-term data. Most survivors describe the experience as the most damaging period of their lives.
- Recognize the Difference Between Faith and Therapy: It is possible to have a deep religious life without participating in practices that harm your mental health. Many denominations now fully affirm LGBTQ individuals, proving that the choice isn't necessarily between "God" and "Gay."
The era of pray away the gay is slowly ending, not because of some "woke" agenda, but because it simply didn't deliver what it promised. It promised peace and change; it mostly delivered trauma and silence. Moving forward requires accepting people as they are, which, funnily enough, is what most of those old religious texts were supposed to be teaching in the first place.