Finding a place that actually understands the structural integrity of a butter crust is harder than it looks. Most bakeries choose between a flaky lid or a sturdy base. They rarely nail both. But if you’ve spent any time in Indianapolis, you know that the Pots & Pans Pie Co menu isn't just a list of desserts. It’s a specialized lineup of sweet and savory heavy-hitters that has essentially redefined what comfort food looks like in the 46205 zip code.
Located right on College Avenue, this isn’t your grandma’s dusty pie shop, though the recipes feel like they could be. It’s modern. It’s precise. Honestly, it’s a little bit addictive once you realize they do way more than just sugar and fruit.
The Savory Side of the Pots & Pans Pie Co Menu
Most people walk in thinking about sugar. They’re wrong. The real soul of the Pots & Pans Pie Co menu lies in the savory pot pies. These aren't those watery, frozen cubes of salt you find in the grocery aisle. We’re talking about massive, deep-dish affairs that weigh enough to be a blunt instrument.
The Beef & Mushroom is arguably the king of the savory list. It’s packed with red wine-braised beef that actually tastes like it spent twelve hours in a slow cooker. They don’t skimp on the cremini mushrooms either. When you crack that top crust, the steam smells like a Sunday dinner at a house you actually want to visit. It’s rich. It’s heavy. You will probably need a nap afterward.
Then there’s the Thai Chicken. This is where things get interesting and a little bit risky for a traditional pie shop. It features a coconut curry base with ginger, lime, and just enough spice to make it interesting without ruining your palate. It’s an unexpected pivot from the traditional American pot pie, but it works because the crust—a signature, all-butter masterpiece—acts as the perfect neutral vessel for those vibrant Southeast Asian flavors.
If you’re meat-free, they usually have a rotating vegetable option that doesn't feel like an afterthought. Sometimes it’s a root vegetable mashup; other times it’s a creamy spinach and artichoke vibe. They treat their vegetables with the same respect as their brisket, which is a rare find in the Midwest.
Let’s Talk About That Sugar
You can’t mention the Pots & Pans Pie Co menu without discussing the Sugar Cream Pie. If you aren't from Indiana, you might not get the hype. It’s the state pie. It’s basically just sugar, heavy cream, and vanilla. It sounds simple. It is simple. But getting the texture right—that custard-like wobble that isn't runny but isn't a brick—is a high-wire act. Theirs is dusted with a heavy hand of nutmeg, and it’s essentially a hug in edible form.
But honestly? The Biscuits & Gravy Pie (yes, really) and the seasonal fruit options are where the kitchen shows off. Depending on when you visit, you might find:
- Blueberry Goat Cheese: A tangy, sweet hybrid that ruins regular blueberry pie for you forever.
- Strawberry Rhubarb: Only available when the stalks are actually good, which is how it should be.
- Bourbon Pecan: It’s boozy, crunchy, and syrupy in all the right ways.
The menu shifts. That’s the thing. They follow the seasons, so if you see something like a Peach Habanero in July, you buy it. You don't wait. It won't be there in October.
Why the Crust Matters More Than the Filling
Every baker has a secret. For the team at Pots & Pans, it’s the fat-to-flour ratio. They use a standard 9-inch tin, but the crust feels thicker because it’s so laminated. It shatters when you hit it with a fork.
A lot of shops use shortening because it’s stable and cheap. Pots & Pans uses butter. Real butter. This means the shop smells like a dairy farm's best day ever, but it also means the pies have a specific "short" texture. It’s crumbly. It’s salty enough to balance the sugar. If you’re the type of person who leaves the crust edges on the plate, you’re doing it wrong here. That’s the best part.
The Take-and-Bake Factor
One of the smartest things on the Pots & Pans Pie Co menu isn't even served hot. It’s the frozen section. They sell these pies unbaked. Why? Because a pot pie is 40% better when it comes straight out of your own oven, bubbling and piping hot, rather than sitting in a cardboard box in your passenger seat for twenty minutes.
Pro tip: if you’re hosting people and want to pretend you spent all day in the kitchen, buy the frozen Beef & Mushroom, egg-wash the top, and bake it until your house smells like heaven. No one has to know.
Beverages and "Side Pockets"
You need something to cut the richness. They usually have a solid rotation of local coffee and teas. But keep an eye out for the "Side Pockets." These are basically their version of a hand pie or a high-end Pop-Tart. They’re perfect for when you want the experience of the Pots & Pans Pie Co menu but you’re driving and don't want to end up with gravy on your shirt. The fillings change constantly, but they always feature that same ridiculous crust.
The shop itself is small. It’s cozy. It’s the kind of place where you see neighbors chatting and people picking up dinner on their way home from work. It’s a community staple for a reason. They aren't trying to be a massive franchise; they’re trying to make the best possible version of a very specific thing.
How to Navigate the Menu Like a Local
If it’s your first time, don’t overthink it. Most people get overwhelmed by the seasonal chalkboard. Here is the move:
- Check the "Savory" board first. If the Chicken Pot Pie is available, get it. It’s the baseline. It’s the control group for all other pies.
- Grab a slice of the Sugar Cream for the road.
- Check the freezer. If they have the Apple Sage Sausage rolls or any of the savory hand pies, grab a few for breakfast the next day.
Prices are higher than what you’d pay at a grocery store, obviously. You’re looking at $30+ for a full pie. But consider the labor. Consider the butter. One savory pie easily feeds two or three people, making the "per person" cost actually pretty reasonable for a high-quality meal.
The Pots & Pans Pie Co menu thrives because it doesn't try to do everything. You won't find salads here. You won't find sandwiches. You find pie. And when you do one thing this well, you don't really need to do anything else.
💡 You might also like: Cooper and Humbles Obituaries: What Really Happened to Local Memorials?
Actionable Next Steps for Your Visit
- Check the Hours: They aren't open 24/7. Check their Instagram or website before you head to College Ave, as they sometimes sell out of specific flavors by mid-afternoon.
- Pre-order for Holidays: If it’s Thanksgiving or Christmas, forget about walking in. You need to get your order in weeks in advance. The line usually wraps around the block for pre-order pickups.
- Try the "Salty" Side: Don't just go for sweets. The savory pies are the hidden gems that actually make this a dinner destination rather than just a bakery.
- Ask About the "Pie of the Month": There is almost always a weird, experimental flavor that isn't on the printed menu. Sometimes it’s a miss, but usually, it’s a brilliant seasonal hit.
- Park Around the Corner: Street parking on College can be a nightmare during peak hours. Slip into the residential side streets for an easier time.
The reality is that this menu is a love letter to Indiana's agricultural roots, wrapped in a French pastry technique. It’s sophisticated but entirely unpretentious. Whether you're grabbing a frozen tin for a rainy Tuesday or a slice of something sweet to celebrate a win, you’re getting the best version of a classic. Just make sure you have enough napkins. You'll need them.