When people think about the papacy these days, they usually picture Pope Francis—the "cool" Pope who snaps selfies and talks about climate change. But there was a man who came before him, a man whose presence still looms large over the Vatican. Pope Benedict XVI, born Joseph Ratzinger, was the pope before Pope Francis, and honestly, he was about as different from his successor as you can get.
He didn't want the job. That’s the first thing you have to understand.
The Reluctant Pontiff
When the white smoke billowed from the Sistine Chapel in 2005, a 78-year-old German cardinal stepped onto the balcony. He looked... well, a bit overwhelmed. Benedict later admitted he prayed to God not to be elected. He wanted to retire to a quiet life of writing books and playing the piano. Instead, he became the leader of over a billion Catholics.
He was a world-class academic. A "Mozart of theology," as some called him. While Francis is a man of the people, Benedict was a man of the library. He spoke in complex, beautiful sentences that required a dictionary and a quiet room to truly grasp.
The "God’s Rottweiler" Myth
Before he was the pope before Pope Francis, Ratzinger spent decades as the head of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith. This was the Vatican's "orthodoxy" office. His job was basically to tell people when they were wrong about Church teaching.
This earned him some pretty intense nicknames. "The Enforcer." "The Panzer-Cardinal."
But people who knew him personally described him as incredibly gentle. Shy, even. He loved cats. There’s this famous story that when he was a cardinal, he’d wander the streets of Rome, and the local strays would all come running to him. It's a weirdly sweet image for a man often portrayed as a rigid disciplinarian.
Why He Really Resigned
You’ve probably heard the rumors. People love a good Vatican conspiracy. Was it the "VatiLeaks" scandal? The pressure of the clergy abuse crisis?
The truth is likely much simpler and, in a way, more radical.
In February 2013, Benedict did something no pope had done in almost 600 years. He quit. He stood up in a room full of cardinals and announced—in Latin, because that’s just who he was—that he was stepping down.
"After having repeatedly examined my conscience before God, I have come to the certainty that my strengths, due to an advanced age, are no longer suited to an adequate exercise of the Petrine ministry."
Basically, he was tired. He saw how his predecessor, John Paul II, had suffered a long, public decline, and Benedict didn't want that for the Church. He felt the world was moving too fast, and he didn't have the "strength of mind and body" to keep up.
It was a total shock. People literally didn't think a pope could do that. By resigning, he paved the way for the very different style of Pope Francis. He turned the papacy from a "life sentence" into a job that requires a certain level of physical and mental stamina.
The Two-Pope Dynamic
For nearly a decade, we had two "popes" living in the Vatican. Benedict became "Pope Emeritus" and moved into a converted convent in the Vatican gardens.
It was awkward. Sorta.
Conservatives who didn't like Francis's more liberal leanings often tried to use Benedict as a symbol of "the old ways." They’d point to his writings or his love for the Latin Mass to criticize the new guy. But by all accounts, the two men actually liked each other. Francis famously compared having Benedict nearby to having a "wise grandfather" living at home.
Benedict stayed mostly quiet, but when he did speak, it made waves. Whether it was a letter on the causes of the abuse crisis or a book on priestly celibacy, his words were dissected by both sides of the Catholic "culture war."
The Legacy Left Behind
What do we make of the pope before Pope Francis now that he’s gone? He passed away on New Year’s Eve in 2022 at the age of 95.
His legacy is a mixed bag, depending on who you ask.
🔗 Read more: Map of Ukrainian Regions: What Most People Get Wrong
- The Intellectuals: They see him as a giant whose books on Jesus of Nazareth will be studied for centuries.
- The Traditionalists: They thank him for bringing back the "Old Latin Mass" and focusing on the beauty of the liturgy.
- The Critics: They point to his handling of abuse cases during his years as a cardinal and his struggle to manage the Vatican bureaucracy.
Honestly, Benedict was a man out of time. He was a 19th-century soul trying to lead a 21st-century institution. He didn't have the charisma of John Paul II or the populist touch of Francis. He was just a scholar who loved God and was asked to do a job he never wanted.
What You Can Learn from Benedict XVI
Even if you aren't Catholic, there's something to be said for his humility in stepping down. In a world where people cling to power until the very last second, he had the self-awareness to say, "I can't do this anymore."
If you want to understand the current state of the Catholic Church, you have to look at Benedict. You can't understand the "Francis Revolution" without seeing what he was reacting to.
To dig deeper, start by reading his first encyclical, Deus Caritas Est (God is Love). It’s surprisingly accessible and shows a much warmer side of the man than the "Rottweiler" headlines ever did. You could also watch the movie The Two Popes on Netflix—it takes some creative liberties, but it captures the vibe of their relationship pretty well.
The story of the pope before Pope Francis isn't just a footnote in history. It's the story of how the oldest institution in the world finally decided to face the modern age, even if it meant breaking a few centuries-old rules along the way.