Ever notice how we just accept that a massive, trunk-swinging mammal and a stubborn farm animal run our country? It’s weird. Honestly, if you sat down today to pick mascots for the two most powerful political machines on earth, you probably wouldn’t choose a "jackass" and a creature known for being easily spooked by mice. Yet, here we are. The story of political cartoons elephant donkey isn't some high-minded branding strategy cooked up in a boardroom. It’s actually a tale of 19th-century "trash talking" that just kind of... stuck.
The Donkey: From Insult to Badge of Honor
Most people think the Democratic donkey started with a specific cartoon. Not quite. You’ve got to go back to 1828. Andrew Jackson was running for president, and his opponents were, well, mean. They called him a "jackass." They meant he was stubborn, dumb, and low-class.
Jackson was a different breed of politician, though. He didn't get offended; he got creative. He actually put the donkey on his campaign posters. He basically told the world, "Yeah, I'm stubborn, but I'm also hardworking and loyal to the common man." Talk about a rebrand. But after Jackson left the scene, the donkey sort of faded into the background. It took a guy named Thomas Nast—basically the godfather of American political cartoons—to make it permanent in 1870.
Nast was a fierce Republican. He drew a donkey kicking a dead lion in Harper’s Weekly. The lion represented Edwin Stanton, Lincoln’s recently deceased Secretary of War. The donkey? It represented the "Copperhead" Democrats who Nast felt were disrespecting a great man’s legacy. He was calling them asses. Plain and simple.
✨ Don't miss: Who Has Trump Pardoned So Far: What Really Happened with the 47th President's List
Enter the Panic-Stricken Elephant
The Republican elephant has an even weirder origin story. It showed up in a Nast cartoon called "The Third Term Panic" in 1874. At the time, there were rumors that Ulysses S. Grant might run for a third term. The New York Herald, a Democratic-leaning paper, was screaming "Caesarism!" and claiming Grant wanted to be a dictator.
Nast didn't like the fear-mongering. He drew a donkey (representing the Herald) wearing a lion’s skin, running around the forest scaring all the other animals. Among those frightened animals was a massive elephant labeled "The Republican Vote."
It wasn't a compliment.
🔗 Read more: Why the 2013 Moore Oklahoma Tornado Changed Everything We Knew About Survival
Nast was actually making fun of his own party. He thought Republican voters were being timid and foolish for falling for the Herald’s "fake news." He drew the elephant teetering on the edge of a pit labeled "Chaos."
He used the elephant because it’s big, powerful, and supposedly has a great memory, but it’s also surprisingly easy to scare into a stampede. The GOP eventually decided that "big and powerful" was a better takeaway than "scared and clumsy," and they officially adopted the pachyderm.
Why Do These Symbols Still Work?
Symbols matter because they’re shorthand. In the 1800s, literacy rates weren't what they are now. If you couldn't read a 2,000-word editorial on inflation or reconstruction, you could still look at a drawing of a donkey falling into a ditch and get the gist.
💡 You might also like: Ethics in the News: What Most People Get Wrong
- Visual Branding: Today, the parties have "cleaned up" the images. The GOP elephant is usually red with three stars; the Democratic donkey is blue.
- Subtle Meanings: Democrats still lean into the "beast of burden" idea—the animal that does the hard work for the people.
- The "GOP" Factor: The Republican elephant is inextricably tied to the "Grand Old Party" moniker, which also gained steam around the same time.
It's funny that the Democrats have never officially adopted the donkey, even though it’s on every piece of merch they sell. The Republicans, on the other hand, signed off on the elephant long ago.
How to Use This Knowledge Today
Understanding the political cartoons elephant donkey dynamic helps you see through modern political branding. These aren't just cute animals. They are remnants of a time when politics was even more bare-knuckled and insulting than it is now.
Next time you see a political meme, look for the "Nast-y" influence. Is the elephant being portrayed as a noble protector or a bumbling giant? Is the donkey shown as a hardworking helper or a stubborn mule? The tropes haven't changed in 150 years.
To really get a handle on this, you should check out the digital archives of Harper’s Weekly. Seeing the original woodblock engravings changes how you view a standard campaign sticker. You realize that our entire political identity is built on the sketches of a guy who really, really liked to pick fights with his pen.
Actionable Insight: If you're interested in political history or graphic design, look up the "Third Term Panic" cartoon specifically. Trace the labels on the different animals (there’s even a giraffe in there!) to see how 19th-century satire functioned as the "Daily Show" of its era. It’s a masterclass in visual storytelling that still dictates how we see our leaders today.