You’ve probably been there. You spend three hours grinding out Tera Raids or catching high-level Paradox Pokemon in Area Zero, feeling like an absolute god, only to have your prized Charizard decide it would rather take a nap than use Flamethrower. It’s infuriating. It feels like the game is broken. But honestly, it's just the Pokemon Scarlet and Violet level caps doing exactly what they were designed to do: stop you from steamrolling the entire Paldean ecosystem before you've even met your first Titan.
Paldea is an open world. That's the selling point. You can go anywhere, but you can't necessarily control everything once you get there. Unlike previous games where level caps were mostly tied to specific badges for traded Pokemon, Scarlet and Violet apply these rules to every single creature you catch. If you don't have the right number of gym badges, that Level 50 Tinkaton you found in the wild is basically a very cute, very pink paperweight.
The Brutal Reality of Obedience Levels
In older titles, if you were the "Original Trainer" (OT), your Pokemon followed orders. Period. You could grind your starter to Level 100 before the first gym, and it would obey every command. Scarlet and Violet changed the script. Now, the game checks your progress against the level of the Pokemon at the moment you caught it.
Here is how the math actually shakes out. If you have zero badges, Pokemon caught at Level 20 or lower will listen to you. Grab your first badge? That ceiling bumps up to Level 25. By the time you’ve cleared all eight gyms, every Pokemon, regardless of level, will fall in line.
But there is a nuance most people miss. If you catch a Magikarp at Level 5 and grind it manually up to Level 70 without winning a single badge, it will still obey you. The "cap" only triggers based on the met level. The game tracks the level at which the Pokemon entered your party. If it was "legal" when you caught it, it stays legal as it grows. This is a massive distinction that players often confuse with the "traded Pokemon" rules of the past.
Why Game Freak Made This Change
It’s about balance. Sorta. Because you can technically ride Koraidon or Miraidon straight to the high-level areas of the map within the first hour, Game Freak had to put some guardrails up. Without these Pokemon Scarlet and Violet level caps, the "choose your own path" mechanic would collapse. You’d just catch a Level 50 Haxorus in the North Province and delete the early-game gyms.
The frustration is real, though. Especially when you’re trying to complete the Pokedex. You see a cool Pokemon, you use a Quick Ball, it’s yours—but you can’t use it in battle for another five hours of gameplay. It’s a pacing tool that feels like a leash.
👉 See also: What Can You Get From Fishing Minecraft: Why It Is More Than Just Cod
Managing Your Team Without Losing Your Mind
If you're hitting the ceiling, you have to pivot. Stop catching high-level stuff for your main roster. It's tempting, but it's a trap. Stick to the Pokemon you caught early and evolved yourself. Those are your ride-or-die companions. They won't ignore you.
There’s also the "Overworld Encounter" factor. Many players think that the level caps are universal for the area they are in. They aren't. You might be in a Level 15 zone, but a "Static Encounter" or a "Wild Tera Pokemon" could be Level 50. If you manage to catch that glowing Lucario standing in the cave, don't expect it to help you in the next gym fight unless you've got at least six or seven badges in your pocket.
The DLC Complication: Teal Mask and Indigo Disk
Things got even weirder when the DLC dropped. The Pokemon Scarlet and Violet level caps behave differently depending on when you start the Teal Mask or Indigo Disk expansions. If you head to Kitakami at the start of the game, the levels are scaled down. If you go after finishing the main story, they’re scaled up.
But here’s the kicker: the obedience rules follow you.
If you go to the Blueberry Academy (Indigo Disk) before finishing the Paldea story, you are going to have a bad time. The trainers there don't play around. Their AI is actually decent, and if your Pokemon start loafing around because you haven't finished the Victory Road path back home, you'll be staring at a "Blacked Out" screen faster than you can say "Terastal."
Common Misconceptions About the Cap
People love to complain that the "badges don't work." I’ve seen countless forum posts claiming their Pokemon stopped obeying even after getting a badge. Usually, this is because they are miscalculating the jumps. The progression isn't linear.
✨ Don't miss: Free games free online: Why we're still obsessed with browser gaming in 2026
- 0 Badges: Up to Level 20
- 1 Badge: Up to Level 25
- 2 Badges: Up to Level 30
- 3 Badges: Up to Level 35
- 4 Badges: Up to Level 40
- 5 Badges: Up to Level 45
- 6 Badges: Up to Level 50
- 7 Badges: Up to Level 55
- 8 Badges: All Levels
If you catch a Level 32 Pokemon and you only have two badges, it will ignore you. Getting that third badge doesn't just make it "better"—it unlocks that Pokemon's loyalty instantly because the cap moved to 35.
Another weird quirk? The "Affection" system. In some games, high friendship could override some obedience issues. Not here. You can wash your Pokemon, feed it sandwiches, and play ball until your fingers hurt, but if you don't have the badges, it’s still going to ignore your "Dragon Claw" command in favor of turning its back on you. It's cold. It's calculated. It's Game Freak's way of forcing you to engage with the gym leaders.
How to Work Around the System
You want a high-level team early? There is a way, but it requires patience. You have to catch them low and level them high.
Exp. Candies from Tera Raids are your best friend. Since Pokemon you catch at a low level will always obey you regardless of how high their level gets through training, you can farm Level 1 or 2 raids, dump those candies into a Level 10 Fuecoco, and walk into a gym with a Level 100 Skeledirge. It will obey every single command because you "raised" it. The Pokemon Scarlet and Violet level caps only care about the starting point.
This creates a weird incentive. It encourages you to ignore the cool, evolved Pokemon in the wild and instead hunt for their unevolved "babies" just so you can keep control of the battle. It's a bit of a meta-game that savvy players use to bypass the intended difficulty.
The Problem With Traded Pokemon
Traded Pokemon are a whole different beast. They have always been subject to level caps in every Pokemon game, and Scarlet/Violet is no exception. If your friend sends you a Level 100 Shiny Mewtwo at the start of your journey, it’s going to be useless. Actually, it's worse than useless because it will take up a party slot and refuse to move while the enemy Lechonk slowly tackles it to death.
🔗 Read more: Catching the Blue Marlin in Animal Crossing: Why This Giant Fish Is So Hard to Find
Even if you are the one who caught it on a different save file, the game sees that "Trainer ID" and treats it as a foreign entity. No shortcuts allowed.
The Verdict on Paldea's Rules
The system is polarizing. On one hand, it prevents the game from becoming a complete joke if you happen to stumble upon a high-level encounter early. On the other hand, it feels antithetical to the "freedom" promised by an open-world RPG. If I can catch it, I should be able to use it, right?
Well, the designers clearly disagreed. They wanted to ensure that the "Starfall Street," "Path of Legends," and "Victory Road" stories had some semblance of challenge. By tethering obedience to the "met level," they created a system that rewards long-term training over lucky catches.
If you’re feeling stuck, stop trying to recruit the giants wandering the deserts. Go back to the basics. Catch a small team, win a few badges, and watch the world open up. The Pokemon Scarlet and Violet level caps aren't there to ruin your fun; they're there to make sure you actually play the game instead of just skipping to the end.
Actionable Next Steps for Trainers:
- Check your Trainer Card: Always verify how many badges you actually have before attempting a high-level catch. If you’re at 4 badges, don’t bother with anything over Level 40 for your active team.
- Prioritize Gyms: If you find a Pokemon you absolutely love but it's too high-level to obey, make a beeline for the nearest Gym Leader. Clearing gyms is the only way to "unlock" that Pokemon for use.
- Farm Experience, Not Encounters: Use the Tera Raid dens to get Exp. Candies. Use these on Pokemon you caught at low levels to bypass the obedience cap entirely.
- Breed for Success: If you catch a high-level Pokemon that won't listen, breed it with a Ditto. The Level 1 offspring will be 100% loyal to you and will remain loyal no matter how high you level it.