You’ve just booted up your Game Boy Color. That iconic chime hits, and suddenly you’re back in New Bark Town. Honestly, there’s a reason we still talk about these games decades later. They weren’t just sequels; they were a complete overhaul of what a monster-collecting game could be. But if you’re diving back in today, whether on original hardware or a "found" digital copy, you probably remember things being a lot easier or more straightforward than they actually are.
Most people treat a pokemon gold silver guide like a simple checklist. Catch this, beat that gym, move on. But Gen 2 is weird. It’s buggy in charming ways, and it’s surprisingly punishing if you make the wrong calls in the first three hours.
Why Your Starter Choice Is Basically Hard Mode
Let’s get real about Chikorita. I love the little pear-headed dinosaur, but picking it is a death wish for a casual run. The first gym is Flying. The second is Bug. The third is Whitney—and we all know about that Miltank. If you pick Chikorita, you’re not just playing Pokemon; you’re playing a survival horror game where every bird on Route 29 wants your lunch money.
🔗 Read more: Jersey Evening Pick 3 Explained: What Most People Get Wrong
Cyndaquil is the "intended" easy mode. It shreds the early game. However, if you want the most "balanced" experience, Totodile is the way to go. Why? Because the move pool in Johto is shallow. Finding a good Water-type early that doesn't require a Great Rod or surfing is surprisingly annoying. Plus, Totodile gets Rage early, which is basically a "win button" for the first two gyms if you time it right.
The Whitney Strategy No One Tells You
Everyone complains about Whitney's Miltank. The Rollout of doom. Usually, a pokemon gold silver guide tells you to go catch a Machop in the Goldenrod Dept. Store. You trade an Abra for it. It’s a solid plan.
But there's a better, weirder way.
Go to the Union Cave on a Friday. Catch a Lapras? No, that’s too late. Instead, find a Gastly in Sprout Tower at night. Most people think Ghost-types are useless against Normal-types like Miltank because they can't hit each other. Wrong. Gastly learns Curse. Since Gastly is a Ghost, Curse cuts your own HP to put a ticking clock on the opponent. Whitney’s Miltank has ridiculous HP and loves to use Milk Drink. You can't out-damage it easily, but you can definitely out-stall it with a curse and a few Super Potions.
Quick tips for the early Johto grind:
- Check the Clock: Some Pokemon like Hoothoot or Spinarak only show up at night. If you're playing at 2 PM, you're missing half the Dex.
- Talk to Mom: Seriously. Let her save your money. She’ll occasionally buy you items like the Silk Scarf or even a Moon Stone, which are otherwise incredibly rare in Johto.
- The Mystery Egg: Don't just dump it in the PC. Togepi isn't great in battle for this generation, but the happiness mechanic starts here. You need to walk with it to make it useful.
The Legendary Beast Headache
Raikou, Entei, and Suicune. The "dogs" or "cats" or whatever you want to call them. They are the biggest source of frustration in any pokemon gold silver guide. You encounter them in the Burned Tower, they run away, and then the real nightmare begins.
Here is the thing about roaming legendaries in Gen 2: they are smart. Well, the AI is programmed to be annoying. If you Fly to a city, they move. If you cross a route border, they move.
The trick? Don't chase them. Pick a spot—I usually like the area between Violet City and Route 31—and just walk back and forth across the "seam" of the map. Check your PokeGear map every time you change locations. Eventually, the Beast's icon will overlap with yours.
🔗 Read more: Stuck on the NYT Connections Hint Feb 17? Here is How to Solve Today's Tricky Groups
Pro Tip: Lead with a Pokemon that knows Mean Look or Spider Web. If you don't trap them on turn one, they flee. And even if you do trap them, they can use Roar to end the battle. It's brutal. Honestly, just save your Master Ball for Raikou. He’s the fastest and the biggest pain in the neck.
Things the Manual Never Told You
Did you know that the Fast Ball is bugged? In the original Gold and Silver, it’s supposed to work better on Pokemon that flee. Because of a coding error, it actually only works on three specific Pokemon: Magnemite, Grimer, and Tangela. It does absolutely nothing special for the Legendary Beasts.
Also, the Moon Ball? It’s supposed to work on Pokemon that evolve with a Moon Stone. It doesn't. It actually only works on Pokemon that evolve with a... Burn Heal? Yeah, the code is a mess. Stick to Heavy Balls for Lugia and Great Balls for everything else.
The Kanto "Post-Game" Reality
Once you beat the Elite Four, the game isn't over. You head to Kanto. This is where the level scaling gets wonky. You’ll find trainers with level 30 Pidgeottos while you’re rocking a level 55 Typhlosion. It feels like a victory lap, but don't get cocky. Red is waiting at the top of Mt. Silver with a team in the high 70s and 80s.
💡 You might also like: Ultra Ego Vegeta Sparking Zero: What Most People Get Wrong
To prep for Red, you need a diverse team. Most people stack their team with legendaries, but a well-trained Ampharos or an Espeon (evolved from Bill's Eevee with high friendship during the day) will do more work than a Lugia with a bad moveset.
Actionable Next Steps for Your Journey
If you're starting a fresh save right now, do these three things immediately to save yourself hours of backtracking:
- Catch a Spearow on Route 33. There’s a guy in the gatehouse north of Goldenrod who gives you a Spearow with a piece of mail. Keep the Spearow. You can deliver the mail later for a TM, but having a Flying-type that isn't Pidgey makes the early game 10x faster.
- Buy the Elemental Punches. In the Goldenrod Department Store, you can buy Fire Punch, Ice Punch, and Thunder Punch. In Gen 2, these are Special attacks, not Physical. This makes Pokemon like Alakazam or even your starter incredibly versatile.
- Headbutt every tree. Once you get the TM for Headbutt in Ilex Forest, use it on the small trees in towns. This is the only way to find Heracross, who is arguably the best Fighting-type in the game and a hard counter to Whitney and late-game Dark-types.
Forget the "perfect" team you see in competitive forums. Johto is about the vibe, the day-night cycle, and finding those weird secrets like the Lapras that only shows up on Fridays. Just keep your PokeGear charged and don't let Mom spend all your money on plushies for your room.