It was the game everyone said was a Smash Bros. rip-off. Honestly? They weren't entirely wrong, but that’s not the whole story.
Back in 2012, Sony decided to throw its hat into the platform fighter ring. They gathered Kratos, Nathan Drake, and a bunch of other icons for PlayStation All-Stars Battle Royale. Some people loved it. Most people compared it to Nintendo’s juggernaut and found it lacking. But here we are in 2026, and the conversation around this weird, experimental brawler won't stay dead. Why?
Because it was bold. It tried to reinvent the wheel in a genre that usually just copies the leader.
The Super Move Problem (And Why It Was Kind of Brilliant)
If you played Smash, you know the goal: knock people off the stage. Damage makes them fly further. Simple.
PlayStation All-Stars Battle Royale took that playbook and threw it out the window.
Instead of health bars or ring-outs, the game relied entirely on "Supers." You hit people to build a meter. You use that meter to trigger a Level 1, 2, or 3 Super attack. These were the only way to actually score a point. If you missed your Super? You wasted all that effort. You were back at zero.
It created a tension that other fighters lack. Imagine being one hit away from a Level 3 Super—the kind that wipes the whole screen—while a Sackboy is hunting you down with a Level 1 jab. It was stressful. It was chaotic.
Critics hated it. They said it felt "unrewarding" to land 50 punches and get nothing for it because you whiffed the final move. But for the competitive scene, it turned the game into a high-stakes hunt for "kill confirms." You didn't just mash; you looked for that one specific opening.
👉 See also: What Can You Get From Fishing Minecraft: Why It Is More Than Just Cod
A Roster of Misfits
The character list was... eclectic. You had the heavy hitters:
- Kratos (the God of War version, before he grew the beard and got feelings)
- Nathan Drake (throwing salt at everyone)
- Sly Cooper (stealing meter like a pro)
But then things got weird. Sony didn't own Crash Bandicoot or Spyro at the time (licensing is a nightmare, basically). So we got the Big Daddy from BioShock. We got Dante—but specifically the "New Dante" from the DmC reboot that everyone was mad about back then. We even got Fat Princess.
It felt like a house party where half the invited guests didn't show up, so Sony invited the neighbors.
The SuperBot Legacy and the "Title Fight" Days
The development of this game is a tragedy in three acts. Originally, Sony wanted Naughty Dog to make it. They were busy with The Last of Us—good call, probably—so Sony built a studio from scratch: SuperBot Entertainment.
They were "purpose-built" for this one game. They hired fighting game legends like Seth Killian (a co-founder of EVO) to make sure the mechanics were deep. And they were. The combo system in PlayStation All-Stars Battle Royale is actually more complex than most people realize. You could air-dash, cancel moves, and chain attacks in ways that felt more like Street Fighter than a party game.
But the polish wasn't there.
The menus looked like a budget mobile app. The "story" mode was just a series of static images with some text. When the game launched, it sold about a million copies. For a mascot fighter, that’s a "flop" in the eyes of corporate bean counters. Sony cut ties with SuperBot shortly after. The studio basically evaporated.
✨ Don't miss: Free games free online: Why we're still obsessed with browser gaming in 2026
Is It Actually Canon?
Here is a fun fact for the lore nerds: PlayStation All-Stars Battle Royale is technically canon in the God of War universe.
In God of War Ragnarök, Mimir asks Kratos about a "tournament" he once joined. He mentions Kratos fighting against "beasts, scoundrels, a princess, the undead, and history's greatest musician" (PaRappa the Rapper). Kratos just grunts and says, "I would not speak of this."
It’s a hilarious nod to the fact that, yes, the Ghost of Sparta once got his butt kicked by a 2D paper dog who raps about noodles.
The 2026 Perspective: Will We Ever Get a Sequel?
We've seen the "leaks" for years. PlayStation All-Stars 2 has been rumored for every State of Play since 2018.
Recently, former PlayStation boss Shawn Layden gave the idea an "amber light." He didn't say no. He just said it’s a tough sell. In the current market, games like MultiVersus have shown that there’s still an appetite for crossover brawlers, but they need a "live service" hook to survive.
Honestly, the biggest hurdle isn't the gameplay—it's the characters. Today’s PlayStation is different. It’s "Prestige Gaming." It’s The Last of Us, Ghost of Tsushima, and Horizon. Seeing Ellie from The Last of Us curb-stomp Astro Bot is a weird tonal clash that Sony might be afraid of.
But imagine the roster now:
🔗 Read more: Catching the Blue Marlin in Animal Crossing: Why This Giant Fish Is So Hard to Find
- Aloy using her Focus to find weaknesses.
- Jin Sakai with stance-switching mechanics.
- Venom (if they can swing the Marvel license).
- Selene from Returnal using bullet-hell Supers.
It would be a powerhouse.
Why People Still Play It
If you head over to certain Discord servers or the dusty corners of Reddit, people are still playing the original on PS3 and Vita. They use fan-made patches. They host small tournaments.
They stay because there isn't anything else like it. The "Super" system, despite its flaws, created a specific type of gameplay that no other platform fighter has replicated. It wasn't just a Smash clone; it was a "combat-heavy" experiment that just needed a bit more time in the oven.
Actionable Steps for Fans and Newcomers
If you're feeling nostalgic or curious about this forgotten piece of gaming history, here is what you can actually do right now:
- Check your digital library: If you bought it back in the day, you can still download it on PS3 or Vita. The servers are officially down for ranked play, but local couch co-op still works perfectly.
- Look into the RPCS3 community: The PS3 emulator has made massive strides. There are groups dedicated to playing PlayStation All-Stars Battle Royale online via emulation with improved resolution and frame rates.
- Support the spiritual successors: Keep an eye on the indie scene. Games like Rivals of Aether and Brawlhalla carry the torch for non-Smash platform fighters.
- Voice your interest: Sony is currently in a "remake and remaster" era. If the demand is vocal enough on social media—especially with the 15th anniversary approaching in a few years—a "Definitive Edition" for PS5/PC isn't outside the realm of possibility.
The game was a beautiful, messy, frustrating piece of Sony history. It tried to give PlayStation an identity beyond just "single-player movies," and while it didn't dethrone the king of the genre, it earned its place in the hall of fame. Or at least, in the hall of "I can't believe they actually put a Big Daddy in a fighting game."
The legacy of PlayStation All-Stars Battle Royale is that it proved Sony could have a mascot culture. They just have to be willing to embrace the weirdness again.