So, you want to tackle the Persona series. It's a massive undertaking. Most people see the flashy, jazz-infused aesthetics of the recent hits and think they can just jump in, but the timeline is actually a bit of a nightmare if you’re a perfectionist. Honestly, if you try to play persona games in order of their actual release, you’re going to hit a brick wall of 90s clunkiness long before you ever meet Joker or the Phantom Thieves.
It's weird.
👉 See also: Fortnite New Years Event: What to Actually Expect This Time Around
The series started as a spin-off of Shin Megami Tensei, and those early games? They aren't the high-school social simulators we know today. They’re punishing dungeon crawlers. If you aren't prepared for high encounter rates and grid-based movement, starting from the literal beginning might actually kill your interest in the franchise.
The Brutal Reality of the Early Timeline
Technically, the journey begins in 1996 with Revelations: Persona on the PlayStation. But here is the thing: the American localization was a mess. They changed character names, altered the setting to "Lunar Vale," and even changed the race of a character (Masao became "Mark"). It’s a fascinating relic of 90s localization, but if you want the real experience, you have to look toward the PSP remake.
Then we get to the Persona 2 duology. Yes, it’s a duology. Innocent Sin and Eternal Punishment.
For years, Western fans were stuck in a bizarre limbo. We got the second half of the story (Eternal Punishment) on the PS1, but the first half (Innocent Sin) didn't officially make it over until the PSP era. It’s a mess. These games are arguably the peak of the series in terms of pure psychological horror and narrative depth, dealing with rumors becoming reality and the literal personification of Jungian shadows. But there are no Social Links here. No hanging out at a ramen shop to boost your Guts stat. You’re talking to demons. You’re managing "Contact" combos. It is a completely different beast.
The Modern Era: Where Most People Actually Start
If you ask a random person on the street about the series, they’re probably thinking of the "Hashino Era." This is when Katsura Hashino took over as director and introduced the calendar system.
- Persona 3 (and its many, many versions): You have the original, FES, Portable, and now Reload. If you’re playing persona games in order to see the evolution of mechanics, Reload is the smoothest entry point, but Portable lets you play as a female protagonist, which changes the entire vibe of the social links.
- Persona 4: Originally a PS2 swan song. Later, Persona 4 Golden added Marie and a whole extra winter month. It’s the "Scooby-Doo" entry—lots of bright yellow, small-town vibes, and a murder mystery that actually gets pretty dark.
- Persona 5: The behemoth. Persona 5 Royal is the definitive version. It’s stylish. It’s loud. It’s over 100 hours long.
Most fans suggest starting here. Why? Because going backwards is easier than going forwards. If you start with the 1996 original, you might give up. If you start with P5R, you’re hooked on the loop of "study for exams, then kill a god," which makes the older, clunkier mechanics of P3 or P2 more bearable because you’re already invested in the lore.
The Spin-off Trap
Don’t even get me started on the spin-offs. If you’re trying to follow the persona games in order of canon, you have to deal with Persona 4 Arena, which is a fighting game that serves as a direct sequel to both P3 and P4. Then there's Persona 5 Strikers, which is a Musou-style action game that continues the story of the Phantom Thieves.
It's a lot.
And then there's the dancing games. Yes, they are canon. No, they don't matter much to the overall plot, but they exist. The Persona Q series on the 3DS brings the casts together, but it exists in a sort of "pocket dimension" timeline that wipes everyone’s memories at the end. It's basically the writers' way of having their cake and eating it too.
Why Chronology is a Trap for New Players
If you try to play the persona games in order strictly by the calendar years they are set in, you’re going to be jumping between vastly different console generations and gameplay styles.
- Persona 1 (1996)
- Persona 2: Innocent Sin (1999)
- Persona 2: Eternal Punishment (1999)
- Persona 3 (2009)
- Persona 4 (2011)
- Persona 5 (2016)
Notice the gaps? The jump from P2 to P3 is jarring. The series basically reinvented itself. In P1 and P2, everyone in your party can swap Personas. In P3 onwards, only the protagonist (the "Wild Card") has that power. This is a massive shift in how you build your team.
The difficulty curve is also inverted. The older games are "Nintendo hard." They will end your run because of a bad RNG roll or a demon that decides to reflect your own attack back at you. The modern games are much more forgiving, focusing on the "One More" system that rewards you for hitting weaknesses.
Honestly, the best way to handle the persona games in order is to group them by "philosophical eras." P1 and P2 are about the collective unconscious and direct psychological trauma. P3 is about memento mori—remembering that you will die. P4 is about the pursuit of truth behind the "fog" of society. P5 is about rebellion against corrupt adults.
What You Should Actually Do Next
If you’re serious about this, don’t just buy the first game you see on a Steam sale. You need a roadmap or you’ll burn out.
- Start with Persona 5 Royal. It is the most polished version of the formula. If the social elements and the 100-hour runtime don't scare you off, you're ready for the rest.
- Play Persona 3 Reload next. It uses the same engine as P5, so the transition is seamless. You'll get to see where the modern "Social Link" system really found its footing, but with 2024-era graphics and QoL updates.
- Go back to Persona 4 Golden. It’s a bit dated visually, but the writing is arguably the best in the series. The chemistry between the cast members in Inaba is something the other games haven't quite replicated.
- Save the Classics for last. Only tackle Persona 1 and the Persona 2 duology once you are a "die-hard" fan. Use the PSP versions. They have better soundtracks and slightly—only slightly—better UI.
The series is a marathon, not a sprint. You're looking at roughly 400 to 500 hours of gameplay to get through the mainline titles alone. Take your time. Don't rush the dialogue. The whole point of Persona is the "slice of life" experience. If you're just clicking through text to get to the next dungeon, you're missing the soul of the game.