You’ve probably driven past it a thousand times. It's sitting right there on East Main Street, tucked into that familiar stretch of Reynoldsburg where the traffic always seems a bit too heavy for a Tuesday afternoon. Most people look at the sign for Play It Again Sports Reynoldsburg and think one of two things: it’s either a dusty "pawn shop for jocks" or a place where you can only find beat-up baseball gloves from 1994.
Honestly? Both of those guesses are pretty far off the mark.
I’ve spent a lot of time talking to local athletes and parents around Columbus, and there’s a weird disconnect between what this store actually is and what people assume. It’s a franchise, sure, but it’s one of those rare spots that actually feels like a neighborhood hub. If you’re trying to outfit a kid for their first season of suburban league soccer or you're a seasoned disc golfer looking for that one specific overstable driver, this place is basically a local landmark.
The Reality of Selling Gear at Play It Again Sports Reynoldsburg
Let's get the elephant out of the room first. The biggest gripe people have—and you see it in Reddit threads and Google reviews all the time—is the payout.
"They lowballed me!" is the classic refrain.
💡 You might also like: Cómo entender la tabla de Copa Oro y por qué los puntos no siempre cuentan la historia completa
But here is how the math actually works at the 6011 E Main St location. They aren't trying to rob you; they’re trying to stay in business in an era where Amazon exists. Typically, the store aims to resell used items for roughly 40% to 60% of what they’d cost brand new today. From that resale price, they offer you about 30% to 50% in cash or trade-in value.
It’s a business. They have to pay for the lights, the staff, and the floor space while the gear sits there waiting for a buyer.
If you bring in a pair of cleats that originally cost $100, and they think they can sell them for $50, don't expect a $40 check. You're likely looking at $15 to $20. Is it less than you'd get on Facebook Marketplace? Yeah, probably. But you also don't have to meet a stranger in a gas station parking lot at 9:00 PM only for them to tell you the cleats "don't fit right."
Pro Tip: If you want the most bang for your buck, take the trade-in credit. The Reynoldsburg crew usually bumps up the offer if you’re applying it toward something else in the store. It’s the smartest way to handle the "my kid grew three inches in six months" problem.
📖 Related: Ohio State Football All White Uniforms: Why the Icy Look Always Sparks a Debate
What’s Actually Inside? (It’s Not Just Used Junk)
One of the most surprising things for first-timers is the amount of brand-new inventory. About half the store—give or take depending on the season—is actually crisp, never-been-touched gear. They stock the big names like Innova, CCM, Adidas, and Rawlings.
They basically use the used gear to subsidize the cost of the new stuff.
The Heavy Hitters in Reynoldsburg:
- Disc Golf: This is arguably their strongest suit. The selection of discs, bags, and targets is massive. If you’re hitting up the nearby Brent Hambrick Memorial Course, this is the unofficial pit stop.
- Hockey: Columbus is a Blue Jackets town, and the Reynoldsburg location leans into that. From skates to pads, they carry enough gear to outfit a youth player without draining your 401(k).
- Fitness Equipment: Treadmills, kettlebells, and weight benches are always rotating through. Honestly, buying a used weight bench is one of the smartest financial moves you can make—steel doesn't exactly "wear out."
- Baseball & Softball: This is their bread and butter during the spring. Walls of gloves and bags of bats.
The Secret Seasonality Strategy
If you walk in with a bag of snowboards in July, don't be shocked if the offer is... underwhelming.
The staff at Play It Again Sports Reynoldsburg buys all year round, but their "Most Wanted" list shifts with the calendar. They want what they can sell now. If you bring in football pads in August, you have leverage. If you bring them in February, they're just taking up space in the back for six months.
👉 See also: Who Won the Golf Tournament This Weekend: Richard T. Lee and the 2026 Season Kickoff
Timing is everything.
I’ve noticed the Reynoldsburg shop stays pretty consistent with their hours (usually 10:00 AM to 8:00 PM on weekdays), but they tend to get slammed on Saturday mornings. If you're looking to sell gear, go on a Tuesday morning. The buyers have more time to actually look at your stuff, and the vibe is way more relaxed.
Is It Worth the Trip?
If you’re a gear snob who only wears the absolute latest $300 carbon-fiber-everything, you might still find what you need, but you’ll be paying closer to retail.
However, for the rest of us—the weekend warriors, the parents of three athletes, and the casual gym rats—it’s a goldmine. The staff at this location actually knows their stuff. They aren't just retail clerks; most of them are local athletes themselves who can actually explain the difference between a mid-kick and a low-kick hockey stick.
It’s also about the community. This store sponsors local leagues and keeps equipment in circulation rather than letting it rot in a landfill. In 2026, that kind of sustainability actually matters to people.
Actionable Next Steps:
- Inventory Your Garage: Grab anything your kids haven't touched in a year. Clean the mud off the cleats and wipe down the weights. Presentation actually matters when they’re quoting you a price.
- Call Ahead for Big Items: If you’re trying to move a treadmill or a full squat rack, give them a shout at (614) 868-0018 first. Space is at a premium, and they might tell you they're "full" on cardio equipment that week.
- Check the Disc Golf Bin: Even if you aren't a player, it’s a great place to find cheap gifts. The used disc bin often has high-end plastic for $8 or $9.
- Join the Loyalty Program: They have a text-based program (usually you can sign up at the counter) that sends out discount codes. It’s worth the occasional notification for 20% off a big-ticket item.
Stop overthinking the "used" label. Most of the gear at the Reynoldsburg shop is just stuff that someone else didn't have time to use. Their loss is your gain.