It was the 90s. Everything was bigger. Everything was louder. If you walked into Times Square back then, you weren't looking for a quiet bistro or a farm-to-table salad. You wanted the neon. You wanted the noise. Specifically, you probably wanted a glimpse of Arnold Schwarzenegger or Sylvester Stallone. That’s the vibe Planet Hollywood Broadway New York NY captured perfectly for nearly three decades. It wasn't just a restaurant; it was a museum of kitsch and cinema that defined an era of Manhattan tourism that honestly doesn't exist anymore.
Times Square has changed. Obviously. But for a long time, Planet Hollywood was the undisputed king of the "eatertainment" world. It sat right in the heart of the action, first at 57th Street and then later at the iconic 1540 Broadway location. It was the kind of place where you’d pay twenty bucks for a burger just so you could sit three feet away from the actual leather jacket worn by the Terminator. It sounds cheesy now. Maybe it was. But at the time, it was the peak of cool for every family visiting the city.
The Rise of the Movie Star Fortress
The origins of Planet Hollywood Broadway New York NY are actually pretty fascinating from a business perspective. It wasn't just a random corporate launch. This was the brainchild of Robert Earl and Keith Barish. They had this wild idea: what if we took the Hard Rock Cafe model but swapped the guitars for movie props? Then they brought in the heavy hitters. Bruce Willis. Demi Moore. Stallone. Schwarzenegger. These weren't just "influencers" in the modern sense; they were the biggest stars on the planet, and they were actual shareholders.
When the 57th Street location opened in 1991, people lost their minds. The lines wrapped around the block. You had to wait three hours just to get through the door. Once you were inside, it was a sensory overload. You had the Wayne’s World AMC Pacer hanging from the ceiling. You had Dorothy’s dress from The Wizard of Oz. It felt like Hollywood had finally moved to New York. The New York Times and other major outlets covered it not just as a restaurant opening, but as a cultural shift. It was the "Disneyfication" of New York in real-time.
Business was booming. By the mid-90s, the company went public. The stock price soared. It seemed like the party would never end. But the thing about novelty is that it wears off. Fast.
✨ Don't miss: Who was the voice of Yoda? The real story behind the Jedi Master
Moving to 1540 Broadway: The Second Act
By the early 2000s, the shimmer was fading. The company actually went through two bankruptcies—once in 1999 and again in 2001. Most brands would have folded right then. Instead, Planet Hollywood doubled down on the New York market. They moved from their original 57th Street spot to the massive space at 1540 Broadway, right at the corner of 45th Street. This was the heart of the beast.
This new iteration of Planet Hollywood Broadway New York NY was massive. It spanned 30,000 square feet. It was designed to handle the crushing weight of thousands of tourists a day. If you visited between 2000 and 2020, this is the version you remember. The red carpets. The giant screens playing movie trailers on a loop. The gift shop that sold those iconic leather jackets for hundreds of dollars.
Kinda weirdly, the food was almost secondary. People always joked about the "Cap’n Crunch Chicken Crunch." It was literally chicken breaded in cereal. It sounds gross. It was actually delicious. But you weren't there for the culinary innovation. You were there because it was one of the few places in New York that felt like a "big event" for kids and adults alike. It served a very specific purpose in the ecosystem of Midtown Manhattan. It was a safe, loud, recognizable anchor in a city that can often feel overwhelming to outsiders.
Why the Lights Finally Went Out
Nothing lasts forever, especially in New York real estate. The 1540 Broadway location was a titan, but it faced a perfect storm of problems. First, the rent in Times Square is astronomical. We’re talking millions of dollars a year just to keep the lights on. Second, the "themed restaurant" trend started to die a slow death. People started wanting "authentic" experiences. They wanted local pizza or trendy ramen, not a corporate burger surrounded by Rocky memorabilia.
🔗 Read more: Not the Nine O'Clock News: Why the Satirical Giant Still Matters
Then 2020 happened.
The pandemic was the final blow for many of these high-volume, tourist-dependent spots. Planet Hollywood Broadway New York NY shuttered its doors in 2020 and never really recovered its footing in that space. The lease was up, the tourists were gone, and the world had moved on. The space at 1540 Broadway eventually transitioned, and the memorabilia—that massive collection of cinema history—was packed up. Some of it went to other locations like Las Vegas or Orlando, and some of it was auctioned off to private collectors.
It’s easy to be cynical about places like this. Critics called it a "tourist trap." And sure, it was. But it also provided jobs for hundreds of New Yorkers for decades. It was a place where a kid from Ohio could see a piece of movie history without buying a ticket to LA. There’s a specific kind of nostalgia for that version of New York—the pre-streaming, pre-social media era where physical "stuff" like a movie prop actually felt magical.
The Legacy of the Hollywood Style
If you go to Times Square today, the ghost of Planet Hollywood is still there in the architecture and the way the area is designed. The brand itself still exists, of course. They have the resort in Cancun, the hotel in Vegas, and a few remaining cafes. But the loss of the Broadway flagship marked the end of an era for Manhattan.
💡 You might also like: New Movies in Theatre: What Most People Get Wrong About This Month's Picks
What can we learn from the rise and fall of Planet Hollywood Broadway New York NY?
Basically, entertainment isn't enough to sustain a business anymore. You need a mix of experience, quality, and adaptability. The brands that survived the Great Rebalancing of the 2020s were the ones that didn't just rely on nostalgia. They evolved. Planet Hollywood tried to evolve—they added more modern tech, they revamped the menu—but the sheer overhead of Broadway eventually became too much to bear.
Honestly, if you missed out on it, you missed a piece of 90s Americana that can't be replicated. It was loud, it was expensive, and it was unapologetically flashy. It was exactly what Times Square used to be.
How to Experience Planet Hollywood Today
Even though the Broadway restaurant is gone, the brand's footprint is still accessible if you know where to look. If you’re a fan of that specific blend of cinema and hospitality, here is how you can still engage with that legacy:
- Visit the Las Vegas Resort: This is now the flagship of the brand. It carries the same DNA but on a much larger, more integrated scale with a casino and massive theater.
- The Orlando Location: Located at Disney Springs, this is probably the closest experience you’ll get to the old Broadway vibe. It still features a massive collection of props and that classic observatory-style architecture.
- Auction Houses: Keep an eye on Heritage Auctions or Prop Store. Much of the NYC memorabilia rotates through these sites. You can literally buy a piece of the restaurant's history if your wallet is deep enough.
- Check Out 1540 Broadway: The building still stands. While the restaurant is gone, the location remains a hub of activity. It’s a good reminder of how quickly the New York landscape shifts.
The story of Planet Hollywood in New York is really the story of the city itself: constantly moving, constantly rebranding, and always looking for the next big show. It served its time as the center of the tourist universe, and now it lives on in the memories of millions of people who once sat under a suspended stunt car and ate chicken tenders while watching movie trailers.
Actionable Insight for Travelers: If you are looking for that "themed" experience in New York today, your options have shifted toward immersive theater like Sleep No More or high-concept bars like Beetle House. The era of the "Mega-Cafe" has largely been replaced by smaller, more Instagram-focused venues. If you want the classic movie-magic feel, stick to the Museum of the Moving Image in Queens—it has the props without the overpriced burgers.