Let’s be real. Walking into a gym for the first time feels like being a tourist in a country where you don’t speak the language. You’re staring at rows of purple machines, wondering if you’re supposed to sit on them or lift them, and then a staff member hands you a clipboard with options. Choosing between planet fitness membership types shouldn't feel like signing a mortgage, yet people get paralyzed by the choice every single day.
It’s just a gym.
But it’s a gym with a specific "Judgment Free" vibe that has turned it into a massive franchise with over 2,500 locations. Honestly, most people end up overpaying because they think they need the fancy perks, while others miss out on huge value because they’re trying to save five bucks a month.
The Classic Card: The $10 Myth?
You’ve seen the ads. They’ve been running them for years. Ten dollars a month. It’s the price of a fancy burrito bowl, and it’s the foundation of the Planet Fitness empire. But here is the thing: it’s rarely just ten dollars anymore in many markets, and even when it is, there’s a catch. Or a few catches.
The Classic Membership is basically your "no-frills" ticket to the floor. You get through the door. You use the treadmills. You hit the dumbbells. You leave. That’s it.
What’s actually in the fine print?
Most people forget about the annual fee. If you sign up for the Classic, you’re looking at a $49 annual fee (though this fluctuates based on seasonal promos) that usually hits your account about two months after you join. If you aren't expecting it, that "cheap" membership suddenly feels a bit more expensive when your bank account takes a surprise hit in March.
Also, you are locked into one location. This is the biggest dealbreaker for people who travel or live between two parts of town. If you sign up at the club near your office, but you want to go on a Saturday to the one near your house? Tough luck. You’ll usually have to pay a "franchise fee" or a guest fee just to get in the door of a sister location.
The Classic is for the person who has a routine and sticks to it. If you’re a creature of habit who only goes to one specific gym at 6:00 AM before work, don't let them upsell you. You don't need the rest.
🔗 Read more: Why Everyone Is Still Obsessing Over Maybelline SuperStay Skin Tint
The PF Black Card: Is the Luxury Worth It?
This is where the marketing gets heavy. The PF Black Card is the "premium" tier of the planet fitness membership types, and it usually sits around $24.99 to $25.99 a month. It sounds like a lot compared to the ten-spot, but the math changes if you’re someone who actually uses the amenities.
First off, the reciprocal access is huge. You can go to any Planet Fitness in the world. Seriously. Whether you're on a business trip in Chicago or visiting family in Florida, your digital key tag works. For people who can't stand missing a workout just because they’re ten miles away from their "home" gym, this is the only logical choice.
The Black Card Spa: Not Just a Gimmick
Most clubs have a dedicated "Black Card Spa" area. It’s usually tucked away behind a glass door near the front desk. Inside, you’ve got:
- HydroMassage beds: These are essentially water beds that shoot high-pressure jets at your back. It’s weird at first. Then it’s addictive.
- Massage chairs: Standard robotic massage chairs. Great if you just worked an eight-hour shift on your feet.
- Total Body Enhancement: This uses red light therapy (specifically Beauty Angel booths). Some people swear it helps with skin tone and recovery; others just like the warmth.
- Tanning: Standard beds or stand-up booths. Note that there are health risks here, and some states have strict age requirements.
But the real "hack" of the Black Card? The guest pass.
You can bring a guest for free. Every. Single. Time.
Think about that. If you and a partner both want to work out, you don't need two memberships. You just need one Black Card. As long as the primary member is present, the guest can work out for $0. The only downside is the guest doesn't get to use the massage chairs or the tanning beds. It's a "workout only" pass for them. Still, it cuts your household gym bill in half instantly.
The Hidden Costs Nobody Mentions
Let’s talk about the money. Not the monthly fee, but the other stuff. Planet Fitness is famous for the "Commitment" vs. "No Commitment" struggle.
💡 You might also like: Coach Bag Animal Print: Why These Wild Patterns Actually Work as Neutrals
When looking at planet fitness membership types, you have to check if there is a contract. Usually, the Classic has a 12-month commitment. If you try to cancel in month four because you realized you actually hate the elliptical, they’ll hit you with a buyout fee. This is often around $58.
The Black Card is frequently offered as a "no commitment" plan, meaning you can cancel anytime without that buyout fee. However, you still have to deal with the notice period. Most locations require you to cancel by the 10th of the month to avoid being charged for the next month.
The Cancellation Dance
Honestly, this is the part everyone hates. You usually can't cancel via email or phone. You either have to show up in person and sign a form or send a certified letter. It’s old school. It’s annoying. But it’s the reality of the business model.
Choosing Between the Tiers
Still undecided? Let’s break it down by personality.
If you are a Budget Warrior, stick to the Classic. You don't care about red light therapy. You don't have a gym buddy. You just want a place that isn't your living room to lift some weights. The $10-15 price point is unbeatable. Just remember to budget for that $49 annual fee so it doesn't ruin your week when it clears.
If you are a Social Exerciser, get the Black Card. Bringing a friend makes the gym less intimidating. Plus, if you find yourself skipping workouts, the "reward" of a 10-minute HydroMassage afterward can actually be the psychological bridge that gets you out of the house.
If you are a Traveler, the Black Card is mandatory. The "home club only" rule on the Classic is strictly enforced.
📖 Related: Bed and Breakfast Wedding Venues: Why Smaller Might Actually Be Better
What About "PF+ Digital"?
There’s a third, newer option that often gets lost in the shuffle. Planet Fitness launched a digital-only tier through their app. It’s for the people who want the coaching and the workout videos but don't actually want to step foot inside a physical building.
It’s fine. But honestly? There are better fitness apps out there if you’re staying home. The real value of Planet Fitness is the physical equipment. The rows of Smith machines, the 30-minute express circuit, and the functional training areas are why you pay the monthly fee.
The "Judgment Free" Nuance
People make fun of the "Lunk Alarm"—that purple siren that goes off if someone drops weights or grunts too loudly. In reality, it rarely goes off. Most staff members hate the awkwardness of it as much as you do.
But it does set a tone. If you’re looking for a place to do heavy Olympic powerlifting, drop 400 lbs from overhead, and use chalk everywhere, Planet Fitness isn't for you. Not because of the membership types, but because of the equipment. They don't have traditional squat racks or platforms. They have Smith machines.
This is a crucial distinction. A Smith machine has the bar on a fixed track. It’s safer for beginners, but it limits your range of motion. If your fitness goals involve competitive bodybuilding or powerlifting, even the best planet fitness membership types will feel like a cage after six months.
Actionable Steps to Join the Right Way
Don't just walk in and sign the first thing they put in front of you. Do this instead:
- Check the Date: Planet Fitness almost always has a "down payment" of $10 to $29 to join. However, about once a month, they run a "$1 down" promotion. If you can wait a week or two, you can save enough for a couple of smoothies.
- Audit Your Travel: Open Google Maps. Search "Planet Fitness." If there are three locations you might realistically use, you need the Black Card. If there is only one, the Classic is your winner.
- Read the Annual Fee Date: Ask specifically which month the annual fee will be charged. Write it on your calendar.
- Test the Water: Most locations offer a free day pass if you go to their website. Use it. Check if the machines you like are broken. Check if the locker rooms are clean at the time you actually plan to work out.
- The Guest Strategy: If you're joining with a friend, decide who gets the Black Card. Rotate who pays every six months via Venmo. It’s the smartest way to utilize the system.
Ultimately, the best membership is the one you actually use. The "tax on the lazy" is a real thing in the gym industry. Millions of people pay for the Classic membership and never go. At $10, it's low enough that you don't "feel" the loss, which is exactly what they want. Whether you go basic or go Black Card, make sure the purple card in your wallet actually sees the light of day.