Walk into any bar in Western Pennsylvania or a tailgating lot in Happy Valley, and the tension is thick enough to cut with a dull knife. You don’t even have to say a word. Just wear the wrong shade of blue. It is one of the most storied, bitter, and frankly, confusing rivalries in the history of college sports. For a long time, Pittsburgh vs Penn State football wasn't just a game; it was the entire season.
But here we are in 2026, and the schedule is looking... empty.
If you grew up in Pennsylvania, you probably remember the "glory days." The 1970s and 80s were essentially a decade-long war for the soul of the state. It wasn't just about who had the better quarterback—though when you’re talking about Dan Marino vs. Todd Blackledge, that’s a hell of a conversation—it was about culture. It was the "City" vs. the "Valley." The steel-toed boots of Pittsburgh clashing against the pastoral, white-out intensity of State College.
Honestly, the fact that these two teams haven't played a down against each other since 2019 is a crime against football. People keep asking when it’s coming back. You hear rumors every offseason. But the reality is a lot messier than just "scheduling conflicts."
The 100-Game War and Why it Stopped
The history is deep. Like, 1893 deep. Penn State won that first meeting 32-0, and they actually lead the all-time series 53-43-4. But Pitt fans will be the first to remind you that they held a 14-game winning streak from 1922 to 1938.
The rivalry basically fell apart because of math and money. That sounds boring, but it’s the truth. Back when both schools were independents, they could play whoever they wanted. Then Penn State joined the Big Ten in the 90s. Suddenly, their schedule was packed with midwestern giants. Pitt eventually landed in the ACC.
Trying to fit a non-conference rivalry game into a modern schedule is like trying to solve a Rubik's cube where the colors keep changing.
The last time we saw this matchup was the 100th meeting back in 2019. Penn State took that one 17-10 in a game that felt like a defensive slog from a different era. Since then? Silence. Pitt’s new Athletic Director, Allen Greene, has been making noise lately about wanting to bring it back. He’s been pretty vocal. But Penn State’s side has been a bit more... non-committal.
👉 See also: Yao Ming Shoe Size: The Massive Logistics of Being 7'6"
The "Unrivaled" Problem
You’ve probably seen the Penn State slogan: "Unrivaled."
Pitt fans hate that. They see it as a direct snub, a way for the Nittany Lions to act like they’re "above" the petty squabbles of an in-state feud. Meanwhile, Penn State fans will tell you their "real" rival is Ohio State or Michigan. It's a classic case of one side caring just a little bit more than the other, which only makes the side that cares more (Pitt) even angrier.
There’s also the "home game" issue.
Penn State plays in Beaver Stadium, which holds over 100,000 people. Pitt plays at Acrisure Stadium (it'll always be Heinz Field to us), which holds about 68,000. From a pure business perspective, Penn State wants to maximize home games. They’ve suggested "2-for-1" deals in the past—two games in State College for every one in Pittsburgh. Pitt, understandably, told them where to shove that proposal.
What Really Happened in 2016?
If you want to know why this rivalry still matters, look at 2016. That game was electric. It was the first time they’d played in 16 years, and the atmosphere in Pittsburgh was unlike anything I’ve ever seen.
Pitt won 42-39.
It was a shootout. Trace McSorley almost led a legendary comeback for the Lions, but an end-zone interception sealed it for the Panthers. That single loss is widely blamed for keeping Penn State out of the College Football Playoff that year, despite them winning the Big Ten.
That’s the beauty of this game. It doesn't just provide bragging rights; it ruins seasons.
The 2026 Reality Check
So, why isn't it happening this year?
Well, look at the 2026 schedules. Pitt just added Bucknell to fill a slot, and they’ve got games against UCF and Miami (Ohio). They had a series with Wisconsin that got cancelled, which opened up a window, but instead of calling State College, the logistics fell toward other Power 4 or FCS matchups.
The Big Ten moving to a nine-game conference schedule really put the nail in the coffin. When you only have three non-conference slots, and you want seven home games a year to keep the boosters happy and the lights on, a home-and-home with a tough in-state rival is a hard sell for an AD.
👉 See also: 2026 Frozen Four TV Schedule: What Most People Get Wrong
The Key Players Who Defined the Series
- Tony Dorsett (Pitt): His 1976 performance against Penn State (224 yards!) basically secured his Heisman and Pitt's National Championship.
- Dan Marino (Pitt): He was the king of the city, but even he struggled against the Nittany Lion defense at times.
- Todd Blackledge (Penn State): Led the 48-14 blowout in 1981 that broke Pitt hearts when they were ranked No. 1.
- Saquon Barkley (Penn State): His five-touchdown explosion in 2017 was a reminder of the talent gap that occasionally opens up between the programs.
Can the Rivalry Be Saved?
Honestly, it’s going to take a miracle or a massive shift in how the College Football Playoff is structured. As long as a "strength of schedule" loss to an in-state rival can tank your championship hopes, big programs are going to stay cautious.
However, there is a glimmer of hope.
With the playoff expanding to 12 (and now 14) teams, a single loss doesn't mean the end of the world anymore. This might actually encourage ADs to schedule "high-risk, high-reward" games like Pittsburgh vs Penn State.
Actionable Steps for the Fans
If you're tired of watching these teams play "directional" schools instead of each other, here is how the landscape actually changes:
- Pressure the ADs: Public sentiment in Pennsylvania is the only thing that moves the needle. Letters to Allen Greene (Pitt) and Patrick Kraft (Penn State) actually get read.
- Support the "Neutral Site" Idea: There has been talk about playing the game at a neutral site like Philadelphia or even back-to-back years in a specific venue. It’s not ideal, but it’s better than nothing.
- Watch the 2030 Window: Most experts agree that the next real chance for a multi-game series won't happen until after 2030 due to existing contracts. Keep an eye on those future schedule announcements.
The bottom line is that Pennsylvania football is better when these two schools hate each other on the field. The state is divided, the bars are full, and the stakes are real. We don't need another game against a Sun Belt team. We need the Keystone Classic back.
🔗 Read more: Joe Thomas: Why the First Offensive Lineman in Space Matters
The most effective next step for any fan is to monitor the ACC and Big Ten's future scheduling mandates. As conference realignment continues to shake the foundation of the sport, the pressure for "regional pods" or protected out-of-conference rivalries is growing. Staying vocal on social media and through alumni networks is currently the only way to ensure the 101st meeting doesn't stay a "what if" forever.