Week 3 is where the wheels usually fall off. By now, everyone thinks they’ve figured out who the contenders are and who is just tanking for a draft pick. They saw a blowout in Week 1, a lucky comeback in Week 2, and suddenly they're convinced they have the "edge." Honestly? That’s exactly how you lose your pool. Pick em week 3 is historically the "Correction Week," where the overhyped teams crash back to earth and the 0-2 desperate squads play like their lives depend on it.
Confidence is a dangerous thing in September. If you're looking at the betting lines or your office pool sheet and thinking "this looks easy," you're already in trouble.
The Overreaction Trap in Pick Em Week 3
Most people make their picks based on what they saw last Sunday. It's called recency bias. If a quarterback threw four touchdowns in Week 2, the public floods him with picks in Week 3. But the NFL is a league of adjustments. Defensive coordinators now have two games of fresh tape on that guy. They’ve seen his tendencies. They know he hates pressure from the left interior.
Look at the data from the last few seasons. Teams that start 0-2 cover the spread at a significantly higher rate in Week 3 than teams that start 2-0. Why? Because the 2-0 team is feeling themselves. They're reading their own press clippings. Meanwhile, the 0-2 team is having "come to Jesus" meetings in the locker room. In the NFL, desperation is a powerful metric. When you're making your pick em week 3 selections, you have to look for the teams with their backs against the wall.
I’ve seen it happen dozens of times. A "powerhouse" team travels across the country to face a winless underdog. The public sees a blowout. The sharp players see a trap.
Why the Home Dog is Your Best Friend
Home-field advantage isn't what it used to be, but for a winless team in front of their own fans in Week 3, it's massive. Noise matters. Communication breaks down for the visiting favorite.
If you see a home underdog in your pick em week 3 slate, don't just scroll past. Take a second. Check the injury report. Often, the favorite is nursing a few "minor" injuries that the betting public ignores because they won big last week. But those lingering hamstring issues or offensive line rotations become glaring weaknesses when a desperate defensive front is pinning their ears back.
It’s about leverage.
Understanding the Variance of Early Season Stats
Stats in September are basically lies. Or at least, they’re very loud half-truths. A team might rank #1 in passing yards after two weeks simply because they played two terrible secondaries or were trailing by twenty points and had to throw every single down. That’s "garbage time" production, and it doesn't win games.
When analyzing your pick em week 3 options, you need to look at "success rate" rather than just total yardage. Is the team actually staying ahead of the chains? Or are they just hitting a few lucky deep balls?
- Look for offensive line continuity. If a team lost a starting guard in Week 2, their Week 3 run game is going to suffer, no matter how good the running back is.
- Red zone efficiency usually regresses to the mean. If a team is scoring touchdowns on 90% of their red zone trips, they're due for a cold streak. Don't chase the points.
- Check the weather. Late September can bring weird heat waves or early-season rainstorms that turn a high-flying offense into a grinding, low-scoring mess.
You’ve got to be a bit of a detective. You can't just look at the scoreboards. You have to look at how the points were scored. A pick-six or a muffed punt can swing a game’s score by 14 points without actually reflecting which team was better on the field.
The Psychology of the "Must-Win" Game
Coaches like Dan Campbell or Mike Tomlin thrive in this environment. They know how to use a 0-2 start to galvanize a locker room. On the flip side, some "finesse" teams struggle when the physical intensity ramps up in Week 3.
The NFL season is a marathon, but for the teams at the bottom of the standings right now, Week 3 is a sprint. Statistically, the chances of making the playoffs after an 0-3 start are abysmal—usually around 2% to 5% depending on the year. Players know this. Agents know this. This is the week where "business decisions" stop and guys start throwing their bodies around.
How to Handle the High-Spread Favorites
In many pick em week 3 pools, you'll see a couple of games with massive spreads—maybe 10 or 13 points. In a straight-up "win/loss" pool, these feel like "free" squares. But if you’re in a "confidence" pool where you rank your picks from 1 to 16, be careful about putting your 16-point max on these huge favorites.
High spreads often lead to "backdoor covers" or weirdly close games because the favorite gets conservative in the fourth quarter. If the favorite is up by 17 and starts playing "prevent" defense, the underdog can easily score two late touchdowns to make it a 3-point game. If your pool uses the spread, these are the most dangerous games on the board.
Even in a straight-up pool, the "upset of the week" almost always happens in one of these "locks." Someone is going to lose. It might as well be the team everyone is picking.
✨ Don't miss: Kilmarnock vs St Mirren: Why This Relegation Scuffle Is Getting Weird
Strategy for Victory in Your Pool
Winning a long-term pick em contest isn't about being perfect; it's about being better than the average person in your group. You don't need to get every game right. You just need to avoid the "groupthink" that leads everyone to fail together.
Step 1: Identify the "Public" Teams
Go to any major sports site and look at the "percentage of picks" for each game. If 90% of people are picking a specific team in your pick em week 3 lineup, that's a red flag. If that team loses and you picked against them, you gain a massive jump on the entire field.
Step 2: Focus on the Trenches
Stop looking at the wide receivers. Look at the injury report for the offensive and defensive lines. A star QB can't do anything if he's being hit in 2.1 seconds. If a team has two backup linemen starting in Week 3, they are a prime candidate for an upset, no matter who is under center.
Step 3: Ignore the Hype
The media loves a story. After Week 2, there’s always a "surprising" team that everyone starts talking about as a playoff sleeper. Usually, that's the moment their value is at its lowest. Don't buy high on a team that has only proven themselves over 120 minutes of football.
Actionable Next Steps for Week 3 Success
To maximize your chances of winning your pool this week, follow these specific steps before locking in your ballot:
👉 See also: Arsenal Injuries and Return Dates: Why the Emirates Treatment Room is the Biggest Threat to the Title
- Cross-reference the Injury Report on Friday afternoon: This is the most critical window. "Limited Participation" on a Thursday often turns into "Out" on a Friday. Look specifically for injuries to the "anchor" positions: Left Tackle, Center, and Interior Defensive Line.
- Evaluate the Travel Schedule: Is a West Coast team flying East for an early 1:00 PM kickoff? These teams often start slow, their internal clocks are off, and they frequently fall behind early.
- Check the "Turnover Luck" Metric: Look for teams that have won despite losing the turnover battle, or teams that have lost despite winning it. Turnovers are often random. A team that is -4 in turnovers but only lost by 3 points is actually a very strong team that had bad luck. They are a great "buy" for your pick em week 3 picks.
- Weight Your Confidence: If you are in a confidence-point pool, don't put your highest points on the biggest favorites. Instead, put them on the teams with the most stable situations—teams with healthy lines, veteran quarterbacks, and established coaching staffs.
Efficiency in Week 3 is about filtering out the noise. The NFL is designed for parity. The league wants every team to be 8-9 or 9-8. When you see a team that looks "unstoppable" or "broken" this early, remember that the league's gravity is always pulling everyone back toward the middle. Use that knowledge to pick the spots where the public has tilted too far in one direction.