Everyone thought the savior had finally arrived. In March 2014, when Phil Jackson walked into that press conference at Madison Square Garden, the energy was different. He looked like the answer. After all, this was the man with eleven rings as a coach and two more as a player with the Knicks back in the seventies. He was New York royalty. The expectation wasn't just that he’d fix the team; it was that he’d restore the franchise's soul.
It didn't happen.
Honestly, it was a disaster. Instead of a triumphant homecoming, we got three years of public feuds, outdated tactics, and a roster that looked like it was built for 1998 rather than 2015. When people talk about Phil Jackson coaching Knicks fans today, they don't talk about the Triangle Offense with reverence. They talk about it with a shudder. The "Zen Master" tag started to feel less like a compliment and more like an insult for someone who seemed totally out of touch with the modern, three-point-heavy NBA.
The Triangle Offense in a Square World
The biggest issue? The Triangle. Phil was obsessed with it. It’s the system that made Michael Jordan and Kobe Bryant global icons, but by the time Phil got to the Knicks front office, the league had changed. You had the Golden State Warriors starting to explode with Steph Curry and Klay Thompson. Space was the new currency. The Triangle, conversely, relies on mid-range jumpers and post-up play.
It was clunky.
Imagine trying to install a rotary phone in a world of iPhones. That’s what it felt like watching the Knicks try to run Phil’s preferred sets. He hired Derek Fisher to coach, but everyone knew Phil was pulling the strings from the executive suite. He wasn't technically "Phil Jackson coaching Knicks" players on the floor every day, but his fingerprints were all over the practice sessions. The players hated it. Carmelo Anthony, a legendary isolation scorer, was forced into a system that required constant ball movement and specific spacing he never quite embraced.
The tension was thick. You could see it in the body language on the court. While the rest of the league was hunting for corner threes and easy layups, the Knicks were stuck in a perpetual loop of elbow passes and backdoor cuts that went nowhere.
✨ Don't miss: Finding the Best Texas Longhorns iPhone Wallpaper Without the Low-Res Junk
The Carmelo Anthony Feud
The relationship between Phil and Carmelo Anthony became the defining soap opera of the era. It was ugly. Phil didn't just disagree with Melo’s playstyle; he went after him publicly. He used Twitter—which he wasn't exactly a pro at—and various interviews to suggest that Melo held the ball too long. He basically tried to bully the star player into waiving his no-trade clause.
It backfired.
The fans, who were already frustrated with the losing, started to side with Melo because Phil’s methods felt cruel and unnecessary. You don't build a winning culture by trashing your best player in the media. It’s Leadership 101. But Phil, perhaps blinded by his past success, seemed to think his "mind games" would work the same way they did on Shaq or Dennis Rodman. They didn't. In New York, under the bright lights of the tabloid media, it just looked like a disorganized mess.
The Porzingis Mistake
There was one bright spot: Kristaps Porzingis. Phil actually nailed that draft pick. People booed on draft night, but the "Latvian Unicorn" was exactly what the modern NBA needed. He was tall, he could shoot, and he could protect the rim. He was the future.
Then Phil blew that, too.
After Porzingis skipped an exit meeting because he was frustrated with the "chaos" of the organization, Phil didn't try to mend fences. He put Porzingis on the trade block. He told the media that the team was listening to offers. It was the final straw for many fans. You don't find a generational talent and then try to ship him off because he showed a little bit of backbone. It felt like Phil was more interested in being right than being successful.
🔗 Read more: Why Isn't Mbappe Playing Today: The Real Madrid Crisis Explained
Why the Zen Master’s Philosophy Failed
Success in the NBA is often about ego management. Phil was the master of that when he was on the sidelines. But there’s a massive difference between being a coach and being a President of Basketball Operations. As a coach, you're in the trenches. You see the guys every day. You build relationships. As an executive, Phil was distant. He spent a lot of time at his home in Montana during the off-season.
The "Zen" started to look like "apathy."
The league was moving toward analytics, player empowerment, and high-volume shooting. Phil was still looking for centers who could pass out of the high post. He signed Joakim Noah to a massive $72 million contract that almost immediately became one of the worst deals in franchise history. Noah was a warrior, sure, but his body was breaking down, and he couldn't hit a jump shot to save his life. It was a move based on what a player used to be, not what the game was becoming.
The Coaching Carousel
The instability was staggering. First, it was Derek Fisher, who got fired amid off-court distractions and poor performance. Then came Kurt Rambis as the interim—a Phil loyalist who the fans never warmed to. Finally, Jeff Hornacek was hired. Hornacek wanted to run a faster, more modern offense, but Phil reportedly kept pushing him to stick to the Triangle.
You can't have two masters.
The players were confused. The coaches were handcuffed. The win-loss record reflected the dysfunction. In his three full seasons, the Knicks never won more than 32 games. They went 17-65 in 2014-15, the worst season in the history of the franchise at that point. It was a long way from the championship glory Phil had promised.
💡 You might also like: Tottenham vs FC Barcelona: Why This Matchup Still Matters in 2026
The Legacy of the Phil Jackson Era
When Phil and the Knicks finally "mutually parted ways" in June 2017, the relief in the city was palpable. The experiment was over. It had cost the team millions of dollars and years of development. But looking back, there are some hard truths to acknowledge.
- The Draft Record: Beyond Porzingis, Phil did draft Frank Ntilikina, who didn't pan out, but he also found Willy Hernangómez, who was a solid second-round find.
- The Salary Cap: He did eventually clear some space, though the Noah contract negated much of that progress.
- The Culture: He tried to instill a "winning" culture, but his methods were too abrasive for the modern locker room.
The lesson here is simple: past performance doesn't guarantee future results, especially when the landscape of the industry changes. Phil Jackson is a genius, but his genius was tied to a specific era of basketball. When he tried to force that era into the present day, it crumbled.
Moving Forward: What We Learned
If you're a student of the game or a business leader, the Phil Jackson coaching Knicks saga is a masterclass in what not to do when taking over a legacy brand. You can't just rely on what worked twenty years ago. You have to adapt.
- Listen to your talent. If your star players are telling you the system isn't working, pay attention. Don't just call them "uncoachable" in the press.
- Modernize or die. The NBA evolves fast. If you aren't embracing the three-point line and pace-and-space, you're losing.
- Presence matters. You can't lead a New York franchise from a ranch in Montana. You need to be in the building, building trust with the staff and the players.
- Value the youth. Trading away or alienating your young stars over "discipline" issues is a quick way to set a franchise back a decade.
The Knicks eventually moved on and found a different path under Leon Rose and Tom Thibodeau, focusing on grit and defense rather than outdated offensive philosophies. It took years to wash the taste of the Phil Jackson era out of the fans' mouths. It remains one of the most fascinating "what if" scenarios in sports history. What if he had just hired a modern coach and stayed out of the way? We'll never know. We just have the record, and the record wasn't pretty.
To truly understand why this failed, look at the spacing in any 2016 Knicks game compared to the Warriors or Cavs from that same year. The visual evidence is all you need. The game had passed the Triangle by, and Phil was the last person to realize it.
Next Steps for Deep Diving into Knicks History
- Analyze the Joakim Noah Contract: Research the specific salary cap implications that hampered the Knicks for years after Phil's departure.
- Study the 1973 Knicks: To understand Phil's obsession, look at the ball-movement heavy championship team he played on; it explains his "ideal" version of basketball.
- Review the 2015 NBA Draft: Look at who the Knicks could have taken instead of the players Phil prioritized to see the opportunity cost of his tenure.