You’re standing in the dark in Sunny Meadows. Your flashlight is flickering, the air is freezing, and you have absolutely no idea where the ghost is. Then you see it—a shriveled, mummified hand sitting on a table. It's the Monkey Paw. Most players see it and think, "Sweet, free evidence," but then they end up dead ten seconds later because they didn't realize that Phasmophobia monkey paw wishes are basically a contract with a very angry, very dead devil. It's one of the most powerful Cursed Possessions in the game, but it’s also the most punishing if you’re just screaming random words into your mic without a plan.
The Monkey Paw doesn't just give you what you want; it takes something back. It’s a trade. Kinetic Games designed this thing to be a high-risk, high-reward tool that can save a failing investigation or absolutely tank a "Perfect Investigation" run in a single heartbeat.
What Actually Happens When You Wish?
Every time you make a wish, one of the fingers on the paw curls down. You get five wishes on lower difficulties, but if you’re playing on Professional or Nightmare, you only get three. Once those fingers are gone, the paw is just a creepy paperweight. But the real kicker is the "price." You aren't just losing sanity; you're often losing your vision, your ability to run, or even your life.
The Wishes That Help You Find Evidence
If you’re stuck and the ghost is being shy, you’ll probably be tempted to wish for evidence. "I wish to see the ghost" is the classic trap.
Honestly, it sounds great on paper. The ghost instantly spawns right in front of you for a ghost photo. Easy, right? Wrong. The moment the ghost appears, your vision goes pitch black for a few seconds, and a cursed hunt starts immediately. You’re basically standing next to a killer while blind. If you aren't standing next to a hiding spot or a smudge stick, you're done.
Then there is "I wish for activity." This one is less lethal but still annoying. It boosts ghost activity—throws, doors, footsteps—but at the cost of breaking the fuse box permanently and locking the front door for two minutes. It’s great for getting that "disturb a salt pile" objective, but it makes the rest of the match a lot harder since you’ll be sitting in the dark for the duration.
"I wish for evidence" is the one most people use when they’re down to the last two ghost types. The ghost will give you a piece of evidence at its current location. But, your vision becomes blurred and your sanity takes a massive hit. It’s a desperate move. If you use this on a ghost that doesn't have a third piece of evidence (like on Insanity difficulty), it’ll just give you a random "fake" interaction and drain your sanity anyway.
🔗 Read more: Jigsaw Would Like Play Game: Why We’re Still Obsessed With Digital Puzzles
Managing Your Sanity and the Map
Sometimes the problem isn't the ghost; it's you. Or your teammates.
"I wish to be sane" is the ultimate reset button. It sets everyone’s sanity to 50%. If you were at 0%, that’s a win. But if your teammate was at 100%, you just dragged them down to the danger zone with you. It also increases how fast your sanity drains for the rest of the game. It’s a temporary fix that makes the endgame much more volatile.
Then we have "I wish for weather." It's mostly used for the "change the weather" challenge or if you hate trying to hear footsteps over heavy rain. There isn't a huge downside here other than a small sanity drain, making it one of the safest wishes in the kit.
"I wish to leave."
This one is for when everything has gone wrong. Maybe you're trapped in a hunt and the front door is locked. This wish unlocks the doors instantly, even during a hunt. The catch? You move at a snail's crawl for several seconds and your vision dims. It's a race against time to see if you can limp out of the house before the ghost catches your slow-moving self.
The "I Wish for Anything" Gamble
This is the chaotic neutral option. When you say "I wish for anything," the game picks a random wish from the entire pool. You could get a full sanity reset, or you could trigger a hunt right on top of your head.
Experienced players usually stay away from this unless they're bored. In Phasmophobia, unpredictability is usually what gets you killed. When you're playing on a map like Prison or Maple Lodge Campsite, the last thing you want is a random event that might lock you in a room with a Revenant.
💡 You might also like: Siegfried Persona 3 Reload: Why This Strength Persona Still Trivializes the Game
The Most Dangerous Wishes: Life and Death
"I wish to revive my friend."
This is the only way to bring a dead player back to life. It feels heroic. You say the words, your friend spawns back in, and everyone cheers. Then, you realize there’s a 50% chance you just died to make it happen. It’s a literal life-for-a-life trade. Even if you survive the initial wish, the ghost might immediately hunt. It’s a gamble that usually results in the same number of dead bodies, just different names on the headstones.
"I wish for knowledge."
This is for the scholars. It crosses out incorrect evidence in your journal. It’s incredibly powerful for narrowing down the ghost type. However, the price is steep. The ghost starts a hunt nearby, and for the rest of the game, your audio is muffled and your vision is partially obscured. You’re basically playing the rest of the match with a bag over your head.
Why the Monkey Paw Changes How You Play
Before the Monkey Paw was added, Cursed Possessions like the Tarot Cards or the Ouija Board were the kings of the meta. The Monkey Paw changed that by being more "reliable" but far more punishing. With the Ouija board, you might lose some sanity. With the Paw, you might lose your literal sight.
It forces a different kind of teamwork. You can't just have one person go in and wish for everything. You have to coordinate. "Okay, I'm going to wish for evidence, you stand by the door with a smudge stick."
The Strategy of Placement
Where you use the Paw matters just as much as what you wish for. Using "I wish to see the ghost" in a hallway is suicide. Using it in a room with a locker? Now you're talking.
📖 Related: The Hunt: Mega Edition - Why This Roblox Event Changed Everything
- Check your surroundings. Always know your exit.
- Have a smudge stick ready. This is non-negotiable for most wishes.
- Communicate. Don't reset everyone's sanity without telling them.
Hidden Mechanics and Tricks
There's a specific trick with the "I wish to be sane" command. If you're playing a map with a lot of lights on, and you use that wish, it often blows the lights in the room you're in. The game is constantly trying to balance the scale.
Also, keep in mind that the Monkey Paw responds to text-to-speech or voice recognition. If your mic is crackly, it might misinterpret your wish. There’s nothing quite as terrifying as trying to wish for "weather" and having the game think you said "see the ghost."
Common Misconceptions About Phasmophobia Monkey Paw Wishes
A lot of players think the "I wish for life" command is guaranteed if they have high sanity. It’s not. It’s a coin flip. Period. I’ve seen players at 100% sanity drop dead instantly because they thought they were "safe" enough to tank the penalty.
Another myth is that the Monkey Paw can give you the "Deadly" ghost types specifically. It doesn't bias toward Thays or Demons; it just interacts with the mechanics of whatever ghost is already there. If you wish to see a shade, it’ll show up, but it’ll still be a boring shade after the cursed hunt ends.
Mastery and Next Steps
If you want to actually get good at using the Monkey Paw, you need to stop treating it like a toy. It’s a tool for specific situations.
- Use it for the 'hard' objectives. If you need a ghost photo and the ghost is being stubborn, use the "see the ghost" wish, but only if you have a Tier 2 or Tier 3 Smudge Stick.
- Use it to save time. On large maps like High School, "I wish to know where the ghost is" saves you ten minutes of wandering around with a thermometer. Just be ready for the sanity drain.
- Practice in Amateur mode. The penalties are the same, but the ghost is slower and less aggressive. Get used to the visual filters that kick in after a wish so you don't panic when your screen goes dark.
The next time you find that mummified hand, don't just start blabbering. Think about what your team actually needs. Do you need evidence? Or do you just want to see a dead friend again? Just remember: the Paw always gets its due.
Actionable Next Steps:
- Load into a private match on Tanglewood Drive with the Monkey Paw forced as the Cursed Possession.
- Test the "I wish to see the ghost" command specifically to practice your "blind" movement to a hiding spot.
- Note the exact visual changes for "I wish for knowledge" so you can recognize the muffled audio during a real investigation.
- Use the "I wish to be sane" command when your team is at 0% to see the impact on your light sources and fuse box stability.