Peter Minuit: The Man Who Actually Bought Manhattan (Twice)

You’ve probably heard the story. It’s the one where a Dutch guy buys Manhattan for $24 worth of beads and trinkets. People call it the biggest swindle in history. But if you actually look at the life of Peter Minuit, the reality is a lot weirder, messier, and honestly, way more interesting than a trivia fact about glass beads.

He wasn't even Dutch. Not really.

Peter Minuit was a Walloon, born in the German city of Wesel around 1580. His family were French-speaking Protestants who fled what is now Belgium to escape the Spanish Inquisition. He grew up in a world of religious refugees and sharp-edged business deals. By the time he hit his 40s, he wasn't just some bureaucrat; he was a diamond cutter by trade with a knack for survival that would eventually land him at the center of the American colonial project.

The 60-Guilder Question

In 1626, Minuit arrived at the tip of Manhattan as the third Director of New Netherland. The colony was a disaster. Settlers were scattered all over the place, getting killed by the Mohawk or starving in isolated outposts. Minuit’s first big move was a "consolidation" plan. He needed everyone in one place where they could actually defend themselves.

That place was Manhattan.

✨ Don't miss: Why the Siege of Vienna 1683 Still Echoes in European History Today

Now, about that $24. The number comes from a 19th-century historian who converted 60 Dutch guilders into 1840s dollars. In 1626, 60 guilders was actually a decent chunk of change—roughly the equivalent of about $1,200 today. But more importantly, the "trinkets" weren't just shiny garbage. We’re talking about iron kettles, axes, hoes, and high-quality wool cloth. For the Lenape people, these were high-tech tools.

But here’s the kicker: the Lenape didn't think they were "selling" the land.

They didn't have a concept of permanent, private land ownership. To them, the exchange was likely a treaty—a rent payment or a gift to seal a military alliance. They thought the Dutch were paying for the right to use the land, not to own every blade of grass forever. This fundamental misunderstanding basically set the stage for the next 400 years of American history.

A Career Change and a Second Colony

If you think Minuit was a loyal company man, you've got the wrong guy. The Dutch West India Company (WIC) fired him in 1631. Why? Because he was getting too cozy with the "patroons"—rich landowners who were essentially trying to build their own private fiefdoms in the New World. The WIC saw this as a threat to their monopoly on the fur trade.

🔗 Read more: Why the Blue Jordan 13 Retro Still Dominates the Streets

Minuit didn't just go home and retire. He was pissed.

He took all his insider knowledge of the American coast and walked straight over to the Swedish government. He told them, "Hey, I know exactly where the Dutch aren't looking. Let’s start a rival colony."

In 1638, he led two Swedish ships, the Kalmar Nyckel and the Fogel Grip, into the Delaware River. He "bought" land again—this time from the Susquehannock and the Lenape in what is now Wilmington, Delaware. He called it New Sweden.

The Dutch governor in Manhattan, Willem Kieft, sent him a furious letter saying, "Get out, this is our land." Minuit basically ignored him. He knew the Dutch didn't have the manpower to stop him. He built Fort Christina, named after the Swedish Queen, and established the first permanent European settlement in the Delaware Valley.

💡 You might also like: Sleeping With Your Neighbor: Why It Is More Complicated Than You Think

The Mystery of the Missing Governor

Minuit’s end was as dramatic as his career. Later in 1638, after getting New Sweden up and running, he sailed to the Caribbean to trade for tobacco. While he was visiting a Dutch friend’s ship, the Flying Deer, in the harbor of St. Christopher (now St. Kitts), a massive hurricane hit.

The ship was lost with all hands.

Peter Minuit vanished into the Atlantic. No body was ever found, and no portrait of him from his lifetime actually exists. Every image you see of him today is a complete guess by a later artist. He’s a ghost in the very history he helped write.

Why Minuit Still Matters

What people get wrong about Minuit is the "swindler" narrative. He wasn't a cartoon villain; he was a pragmatist in a brutal era. He was the one who realized that if New York (then New Amsterdam) was going to survive, it couldn't just be a trading post—it had to be a community.

• He established the first "Council of Five": A tiny seed of representative government in the colonies.
• He was a polyglot: He moved between French, Dutch, German, and eventually Swedish, mirroring the multicultural chaos that Manhattan would eventually become.
• He was the original "disruptor": When his first employer let him go, he used his expertise to launch a competitor.

If you want to see his legacy, don't look for a statue. Go to Peter Minuit Plaza next to the Staten Island Ferry terminal in Lower Manhattan. It’s a busy, noisy, confusing transit hub where people from every corner of the planet are rushing to get somewhere else. Honestly, for a guy who spent his life navigating between empires and cultures, that’s probably the most fitting monument he could have.

Next Steps for History Buffs:
If you're in New York, skip the tourist traps and head to Inwood Hill Park at the northern tip of Manhattan. There’s a rock there with a plaque marking the "supposed" site of the purchase. It’s a quiet spot that feels more like the 1620s than anywhere else in the city. After that, look up the "Schaghen Letter" online; it’s the original 1626 document that first mentioned the 60-guilder deal. It’s the closest thing we have to a birth certificate for New York City.